Luckily for you, Brazil is a liar so there is still hope. Which card did you take from the middle?
Game Thread ONUW 13 - This One's Ruff
- Thread starter Hecht
- Start date
Luckily for you, Brazil is a liar so there is still hope. Which card did you take from the middle?
Nomad Sparkster
This is some wild shit maynard
2
Don't mind me, everyone, just pointing out contradictions for y'all.
Nomad Sparkster
This is some wild shit maynard
Anyone of us could be the werewolf
but it says a lot that Brazil has three people calling BS on him
but it says a lot that Brazil has three people calling BS on him
Where's the contradiction?
Ty4on
The 4 is silent
Is it simply because he quacks like a duck or is there more to it like how he keeps insisting his story is correct?
Natiko
Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
What did you mean by the above message then?
Interesting
Probably because he’s been caught out as a liar, has been fishing for info, and as of yet has done nothing to make it seem like an elaborate villager play. Any reason why you keep dodging talking about yourself?
In this case, the fact that acohrs has nothing to lose by simply saying who the other alleged Mason is.
Ty4on
The 4 is silent
Mazre
Traitor of Humanity
So just to recap:
Brazil claims seer and that he saw rac has robber - this is refuted directly by rac (didn't start as robber), as well as by acohrs (claims robber and whose story is confirmed by Sorian)
Brazil's story is pretty much shot to pieces, the only other possibility that make sense would be if rac was robber who stole wolf and acohrs/sorian were minion/wolf, but Sorian has already implied that his mason buddy is in play so that's the final nail should that piece of info drop
Seems highly probable that Brazil is wolf/tanner/minion, if he was just fishing for info he probably would've recanted by now
Both rac and splinter have soft claimed insomniac (Splinter claims his card was taken (doesn't specify what it was replaced with, rac claims to know based on his card what team he's on); Would lean towards rac between these two, robber claim from acohrs suggests his card wasn't stolen, and I didn't switch him so if he was insomniac claiming his card changed there's currently no way for that to be
I've claimed troublemaker (NO switch of splinter, rac, or acohrs)
Nomad has claimed drunk taking card 2 from the center
No claims:
Natiko, Benghis Khan, and Ty4on
Brazil claims seer and that he saw rac has robber - this is refuted directly by rac (didn't start as robber), as well as by acohrs (claims robber and whose story is confirmed by Sorian)
Brazil's story is pretty much shot to pieces, the only other possibility that make sense would be if rac was robber who stole wolf and acohrs/sorian were minion/wolf, but Sorian has already implied that his mason buddy is in play so that's the final nail should that piece of info drop
Seems highly probable that Brazil is wolf/tanner/minion, if he was just fishing for info he probably would've recanted by now
Both rac and splinter have soft claimed insomniac (Splinter claims his card was taken (doesn't specify what it was replaced with, rac claims to know based on his card what team he's on); Would lean towards rac between these two, robber claim from acohrs suggests his card wasn't stolen, and I didn't switch him so if he was insomniac claiming his card changed there's currently no way for that to be
I've claimed troublemaker (NO switch of splinter, rac, or acohrs)
Nomad has claimed drunk taking card 2 from the center
No claims:
Natiko, Benghis Khan, and Ty4on
Ty4on
The 4 is silent
There's more to it than that. He could also be a wolf trying to look too woolfy to be lynched. I wanted to know if it was a simple or more complex judgement.
rac
whatever
i wasn't thinking about the order of things and was under the impression i was robbed
i was happy to have the information since i was kinda worried about the troublemaker
Oh I’m the actual troublemaker, let me know if y’all think I should say who I swapped.
Natiko
Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Also Mazre - do you really think rac was implying he’s insomniac? I don’t think he could be confused about his role if so since insomniac is the only one that knows for sure who they are at game start.
Now that you’ve reflected on the role order do any of your posts need to be taken with a grain of salt other than the one I picked out?
Mazre
Traitor of Humanity
Thought it was a possibility but may have read to much into rac's statements, definitely overlooked your post about having an info role (GET AVATARS PEOPLE).
rac
whatever
this one maybe?
it seems i still have my card from the beginning if everyone is telling the truth
Nomad Sparkster
This is some wild shit maynard
BOLD MOVE COTTON
Let's see if that pays off later lmao
Natiko what is your claim?
Ty4on
The 4 is silent
Nat claimed seer who didn't check me ._.
Nomad Sparkster
This is some wild shit maynard
Natiko
Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
He’s being snarky because I keep pressing him to commit to something since he’s been avoiding it thus far. Perhaps I did check him though and just want to see if he lies. I won’t be revealing what I did yet, but yes I am the Seer.
Nomad Sparkster
This is some wild shit maynard
Natiko
Get an avatar plz
Get an avatar plz
Nomad Sparkster
This is some wild shit maynard
Seer. Saw rac as Robber.
Ok rac let’s say you were the robber, hypothetically speaking. Did you hypothetically steal and if so, who did you steal from?
Nomad Sparkster
This is some wild shit maynard
What should we ask to see if any of the two are the real seer?
rac
whatever
hypothetically if i was the robber i would have robbed brazil and than saw that i wasn't the robber
I'm asking for troublemakers right now and there is no way to prove them.
Nomad Sparkster
This is some wild shit maynard
Natiko
Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
I’m Seer and looked at cards in the middle. Not going to go further than that yet.
Nomad Sparkster
This is some wild shit maynard
Nomad Sparkster
This is some wild shit maynard
Oh is Natiko a seer?
Is that a hard claim or soft claim?
Is that a hard claim or soft claim?
rac
whatever
by my count
no claims:
myself, splinter, ty4on
two troublemakers
how about we make this interesting splinter, and ty4on
lets play a game and all reveal roles at the same time
yeah?
All we really care about is if you looked at card 2 or not at this point.
I also have no game to play, I'm claimed rac, good try though.
rac
whatever
Natiko
Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
I looked at 1 and 2. @Nomad Sparkster can you confirm you took 2?
rac
whatever
what does im town anyway mean, i was assuming you think im town
but now this
if you think im town how would revealing my role before natiko help?
wouldn't that allow him to just change what he would claim the cards to be?
We have no way to verify what Natiko says regardless. Either he's telling the truth or the seer card was in the middle and we won't know until game end. We could let him go first and have you or Splinter counter claim him but it's a matter of luck either way. I have no outstanding issues with you but Splinter is a crap shoot, we need the claims out now though. We're pushing on time especially with time zones.
acohrs
GIF Voyeur
whose cards did you switch maz?
Natiko
Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
I would really like @Nomad Sparkster to confirm which card he picked up before I reveal what cards 1 and 2 were.
Mazre
Traitor of Humanity
I swapped Brazil and Natiko
Ty4on
The 4 is silent
Mazre
Traitor of Humanity
Boring switch? What does that even mean? Not like I have any info to go on when I'm making a switch at the start of the game. I randomed two people who weren't me and went with it.
Ty4on
The 4 is silent
Randomized in your head or actually randomized from random.org?
Nice.
Natiko
Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
I give up on Nomad. I actually peeked at 1 and 3. I saw Insomniac and Villager. In all likelihood our wolves, minion, and tanner are dispersed as one of Mazre/benghis, brazil/me (depending on which troublemaker is real), splinter, and nomad. Was hoping to pry more info out first but seeing as this game is moving sloooowly I want people to have time to see my info.
rac
whatever
uh huh so let's look at the claims then
mason - acohrs (robbed sorian), sorian, ty4on (?)
seer - brazil (saw me as robber), natiko (saw cards 1 (insomniac) and 3 (villager))
robber - acohrs (started as), sorian (was robbed), splinter (woke up like this)
troublemaker - mazre (swapped brazil (seer) - natiko (also seer)), benghis khan(swapped sorian (robber) - rac (hunter))
drunk - nomad sparkster (picked card 2)
insomniac - splinter (now robber)
hunter - rac
do i have everything right?
mason - acohrs (robbed sorian), sorian, ty4on (?)
seer - brazil (saw me as robber), natiko (saw cards 1 (insomniac) and 3 (villager))
robber - acohrs (started as), sorian (was robbed), splinter (woke up like this)
troublemaker - mazre (swapped brazil (seer) - natiko (also seer)), benghis khan(swapped sorian (robber) - rac (hunter))
drunk - nomad sparkster (picked card 2)
insomniac - splinter (now robber)
hunter - rac
do i have everything right?
rac
whatever
well you bread-crumbed before brazil claimed, so you have that going for you
rac
whatever
in my head it worked something like:
brazil the minion claims seer with an obvious lie, i dont keep my mouth shut and instantly refute it
no counter claims come forward for some time
it is now safe for werewolves to claim seer
Natiko
Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
So before I get on the plane here are my thoughts. I’m fairly confident the baddie breakdown is as I said before:
Mazre/benghis
brazil/me (depending on troublemaker)
splinter
nomad
Two of the four roles are ones we want to lynch so we’re at a 50/50. The seer and troublemaker double claims make it a further toss up if you lynch there. Splinter is lying as well and probably expected a counter claim since he breadcrumbed early too. I think lynching Nomad is the smartest play at this time, but I’ll pop in as I can and re-evaluate at day end.
Mazre/benghis
brazil/me (depending on troublemaker)
splinter
nomad
Two of the four roles are ones we want to lynch so we’re at a 50/50. The seer and troublemaker double claims make it a further toss up if you lynch there. Splinter is lying as well and probably expected a counter claim since he breadcrumbed early too. I think lynching Nomad is the smartest play at this time, but I’ll pop in as I can and re-evaluate at day end.
rac
whatever
Well he is lying. I know you can’t be sure what I’m saying is true but it is. Outside of other actions muddying things and taking claims at face value rac would be a mason (or whatever sorian became ) and sorian would be hunter I believe. OMUW is a interesting game