Spectator Thread Spectator Thread

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
I don’t blame Brazil - it’s really tough subbing in so late. I’m surprised Gorlak is letting himself be so thrown off by Melon though.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Loll... DCPat actually bought the idea that Swamped could protect herself consecutively in scum chat and was thinking he was toast. Then after Gorlak called Swamped out he realized she was bluffing. SIGH.
 
I don’t blame Brazil - it’s really tough subbing in so late. I’m surprised Gorlak is letting himself be so thrown off by Melon though.

Yeah, can't blame Brazil too much.

Loll... DCPat actually bought the idea that Swamped could protect herself consecutively in scum chat and was thinking he was toast. Then after Gorlak called Swamped out he realized she was bluffing. SIGH.

And this is why talking too much about powers is bad.

USUALLY it gets called out People talk about TMI and all that shit.

But here, they spend a lot of time talking about mechanics and PRs and TMI shit.

just wtf guys. what even is this game anymore?
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Leave it to Zeke to try and make rational points only when his ass is on the line, meanwhile in every other situation it’s just *shrug* Melon tho
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
Yep, no one is voting, and the current votes mostly suck. I just hope Malus votes for DCPat soon and encourages others to do so as well.
 
Malus is doing a good job trying to ask questions to get Zekes position. I mean it doesn't even seem like he's scum reading Melon, he just wants to lynch her to confirm other townies lol.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Malus is doing a good job trying to ask questions to get Zekes position. I mean it doesn't even seem like he's scum reading Melon, he just wants to lynch her to confirm other townies lol.
Which is why I would probably always vote Zeke this phase.
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
Why doe Zeke refuse to answer questions? Malus wants to know who he thinks is Scum. Zeke refuses to say, then asks him a question instead. What the fuck is wrong with him?
 

turmoil7

Imperial Corps Commander Who Cheers the Army
Dcpat must be having regrets on not giving himself some margin to vote for melon, he wouldn't have expected Brazil to vote for her.
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
Oh look, Swamped didn't mention DCPat once in her big post there about the state of the game.

giphy.gif
 

Chuggernaut

HONK HONK MF
Stuart’s right. This does show that coasting is a good scum stratagy. So many players just straight up ignore DC and it’s insane
 

Chuggernaut

HONK HONK MF
Melon, Swamped, Zeke, Z Beat, AB, and Brazil won’t even consider DC this today and I can not figure out why. Gorlak is barely giving it a passing thought either. Alex and Malus have this mostly figured out, but they’re just being ignored. I’m still waiting for town to lynch one or two people not named DC from the “Not on the list” pool and when they turn up town, they’ll just ignore it and go after a PR again
 
Melon, Swamped, Zeke, Z Beat, AB, and Brazil won’t even consider DC this today and I can not figure out why. Gorlak is barely giving it a passing thought either. Alex and Malus have this mostly figured out, but they’re just being ignored. I’m still waiting for town to lynch one or two people not named DC from the “Not on the list” pool and when they turn up town, they’ll just ignore it and go after a PR again
manshrug.gif
 

turmoil7

Imperial Corps Commander Who Cheers the Army
With the ninja and sleepwalker flips following the cop should be stupid easy, but not even AB claims some leadership. The day is going to end and he hasn't even voted so far
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
Malus being completely on the right track and Zeke making fun of him is...whew.
I've been there, I was in a similar situation in GoT where I was totally right about someone, but was made fun of for my scum read on them by a more veteran player. It didn't make me feel good.

But yeah, it's just really frustrating watching this. Other than Alex and Malus, they're all out there just guessing and shrugging at each other, voting randomly for Gorlak close to EoD lol. Like, what the fuck.
 
I think this might be the worst town game I've seen since I started playing Mafia here.

and yes I know we're in spec thread and thus "IN THE KNOW" but there is no excuse for this town.

I'll forgive Brazil cause he subbed in quite late though.
 

Chuggernaut

HONK HONK MF
Honestly, Gorlak should know better here. He’s brought up why DC has been scum read only to be ignored and now he has two players bringing up points he didn’t and he’s ignoring them like everyone else.
 

Chuggernaut

HONK HONK MF
No one is even really town reading him. It’s a lot of “Well I just don’t know what to think about him”

You should have an opinion on someone by this point of the game
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
At least Town in Conspiracy were utterly befuddled due to the bastard nature of the game, my gambit eating up three days, and Neutral LP being just as sketchy as the remaining Scum members. Here though? I think Stu's right, no excuses really.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
I think this might be the worst town game I've seen since I started playing Mafia here.

and yes I know we're in spec thread and thus "IN THE KNOW" but there is no excuse for this town.

I'll forgive Brazil cause he subbed in quite late though.
Yeah this is bad. I’m not going to act like DCPat is the obvious choice here, I already admitted if I was in the game I’d probably be ignoring the most likely scum candidates and voting Zeke because of how incredibly anti-town his play has been. That being said, they should in no way have spent most of the day discussing the PRs. You don’t lynch there until you think you’re in lylo at best. Scum can’t afford to leave them on the board. YOU JUST HAD A NO KILL NIGHT. Clearly that should indicate something to town, yet they’ve just plodded on focusing on the PRs. Everyone is aimless and letting themselves be derailed by a truly destructive tunnel on one player’s part.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
I still think they will get there in the end but holy shit just..what. So does Zeke seriously think Gor and Melon are scummates? How the fuck does that make any sense?
 

Chuggernaut

HONK HONK MF
This Gorlak lynch is bad. It’s just going to be back to fucking Melon the next day if they do this. This is one of the worst possible things town can do here.

I’m going to keep rooting for town because of Malus and Alex

I’m actually kind of mad about Zeke making fun of Malus for that read. That is the most not cool thing he’s do in this entire game of him doing not cool things.
 
I mean Gorlak talked about Policy lynching CS earlier.

Knowing Zeke is town, I'd be fine with Policy lynching him for his play today.
 

turmoil7

Imperial Corps Commander Who Cheers the Army
I consider D2 and D5 as town victories because of the valuable information those phases provided, even with that it feels like if town will win by accident
 

Chuggernaut

HONK HONK MF
Dammit Malus, YOU WERE THE CHOSEN ONE!!!!

I don’t blame him for that vote at all. He’s on the right track. And unless town assumes there was no scum involved at all in that Alex vote that gives them a good place to look. (Here’s betting they fucking won’t though)
 

Chuggernaut

HONK HONK MF
I consider D2 and D5 as town victories because of the valuable information those phases provided, even with that it feels like if town will win by accident

I still can’t believe they saw are filps and assumed all three of us were town because of it.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Zeke literally just out here making up bullshit narratives for no reason. “Claiming that I was in a chat with Fanto has done nothing but harm to me!” The fuck, you’ve barely had anyone vote for you before today.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
I would say a PR, but town seems to want to just do that themselves
It’ll be Swamped. He knows she can’t protect herself again and that she will likely target AB. If Melon lives though there’s hope she uses the protect on Swamped.
 

Chuggernaut

HONK HONK MF
It’ll be Swamped. He knows she can’t protect herself again and that she will likely target AB. If Melon lives though there’s hope she uses the protect on Swamped.

She’s got herself in a position where she can actually blind side him with that too.
 

Verelios

Were-elios
I think this might be the worst town game I've seen since I started playing Mafia here.

and yes I know we're in spec thread and thus "IN THE KNOW" but there is no excuse for this town.

I'll forgive Brazil cause he subbed in quite late though.
It's close but Pokemon Mafia rounds it out for me. Over half of the scum team were 'town leaders' and town was pretty much coasting by with them. By Mylo it felt like talking into the void whenever I posted.

But this is a lot more messy. I don't understand what Zeke's going for today, and it feels like everyones exhausted and going through the motions, which would be fatal...if DC still had a better chance to comback.
 
I'll be honest, there's a scene coming into my head that I wish I could find a gif for in regards to how I feel at this moment but since I can't find that at the moment, here is my secondary appropriate gif:

cJia40a.gif


we are the cat trying to persuade bird!town.
 

Chuggernaut

HONK HONK MF
Zeke knows he’s town. He knows Alex was a counter wagon to Faddy. There’s most likely scum there. It was either scum vs scum or DC is probably scum. He’s still scum reading Alex, but he’s decided to not push hard for that at all for some reason? And instead he think Gorlak and Melon are a team? What?
 

Chuggernaut

HONK HONK MF
He still would be wrong, but at least an Alex lynch would give them more information then fucking Gorlak or Melon. And information lynches seem like his jam at this point
 
It's close but Pokemon Mafia rounds it out for me. Over half of the scum team were 'town leaders' and town was pretty much coasting by with them. By Mylo it felt like talking into the void whenever I posted.

But this is a lot more messy. I don't understand what Zeke's going for today, and it feels like everyones exhausted and going through the motions, which would be fatal...if DC still had a better chance to comback.

oh my. Sounds like an easy win for scum there.
 

Chuggernaut

HONK HONK MF
Would AB see movement if someone was protected? Like if he tracked DC to Swamped and Melon protected Swamped, what would happen?
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Would AB see movement if someone was protected? Like if he tracked DC to Swamped and Melon protected Swamped, what would happen?
He’s a tracker so he would know DC visited Swamped, but that’s all. He would (if town was reasonable) be lynched that day phase with what PRs have claimed but who the fuck knows what they would actually do.
 
I think the strat is obvious here:

Vote outside the wagons on an unlikely to happen wagon. That way after the town flip, he won't have been listed as on the town wagon
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
EzekelRAGE said:
VOTE: Gorlak

Listed how I can see a scum gorlak working.

Doesn’t seem the melon train is picking up.

EzekelRAGE said:
I can reconcile it by voting for survival.

If ever an example was needed of how he’s just out here bullshitting. “Oh I can totally see Gorlak as scum and explained so earlier.”

“Jk just a survival vote”

I’m not sure I’ve ever felt a town player seemed scummier than I have this game lol
 
If ever an example was needed of how he’s just out here bullshitting. “Oh I can totally see Gorlak as scum and explained so earlier.”

“Jk just a survival vote”

I’m not sure I’ve ever felt a town player seemed scummier than I have this game lol

Exactly what I thought.

In any normal game, that would be called out

HELL, I'm pretty sure I was called out once for a similar thing.

urgh
 
Like I said, I'll give Zeke this.

If he was on the scum side, he'd probably end up winning. Just because people think this is usual Zeke and probably town.
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
Any town would be fine with voting for Zeke here. Who cares what they said earlier, Zeke is the clear choice among the vote leaders. But DC wants to go for Malus. Why? He already knows the leaders are Town, doesn't want to be connected to them, and thinks Malus can be mislynched tomorrow or the next day. HE IS SCUM
 
oh yeah that reminds me!

kind of off-topic from ranting at town but there was a GoT trailer on tv the other day with that scene in the gif and it made me think of you fantomas XD.

Back to regularly scheduled 'WHY TOWN!' now
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Oh Brazil, how different this could have been if you were in from the start. Feel like he just is lost in the noise and probably can’t fully keep track of everything coming in this late. Sigh. Still think this next matchmake will be DCPat’s undoing.
 
Top Bottom