Game Thread One Night Ultimate Werewolf XV.2

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
imagine you rolled wolf for the second game in a row. First round, you picked a fakeclaim that was hard to dispute and slipped through mostly unnoticed. No Tanner, no counterclaim, works pretty well. I mean, he still lost, but it was close

so second game, that ploy probably won't work as well - cards are mostly the same, but the deck's been reshuffled. How do you undercover as wolf? pull the exact same claim out of your ass and pass as Tanner, because what kind of wolf would try the same trick twice? Tanner needs to be lynched to win, so picking a role that's hard to counterclaim doesn't work too well to draw attention to yourself. you'll notice Turmoil claimed early this game - that's because he wants to get ahead of incoming counterclaims if they exist, whereas a Tanner would intentionally show up late (like someone else in this game) because that's scummier

y'all won't argue with me because you know I'm right
If you truly believed you were a Tanner now you wouldn't want to point out anything like this, now if you believed you were a Wolf..
 

Dr. Worm

Has a PHD in Worms
If you truly believed you were a Tanner now you wouldn't want to point out anything like this, now if you believed you were a Wolf..
if I'm a Tanner, I need to keep arguing to make myself a bigger target so no one steals my thunder in the last hour
 

Dr. Worm

Has a PHD in Worms
I believe in the Heart of the Cards, and I believe the Heart of the Cards has led me to the promised land of Tannerdom
 

Dr. Worm

Has a PHD in Worms
B-Dubs knows claiming last and then doing nothing else is the scummiest possible move to make - he's so committed, he's not even reading the thread, because reading would tempt him to drop the act. This is next-level play, folks, since it masquerades as inactivity while still lending itself to being a lynch target

Now, which card wins by being the scummiest card possible, and loses if it tries too hard?
 

Faddy

of, having, or involving transitory whims
B-Dubs knows claiming last and then doing nothing else is the scummiest possible move to make - he's so committed, he's not even reading the thread, because reading would tempt him to drop the act. This is next-level play, folks, since it masquerades as inactivity while still lending itself to being a lynch target

Now, which card wins by being the scummiest card possible, and loses if it tries too hard?

When he dumpsters his team at 1 minute to deadline it is going to be great.

If not then he is probably the Tanner and knows nothing.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
I didn't ask to put on the B-Dubs Mask, DAD
You had to be a weirdo and pick Card 1! Think of how easy this game could've been if you picked Card 2.

Note: By easier I mean for us, not for you. You would've been extra screwed lol
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
if I was a townie, this would be concerning to me

good thing I don't have to care about silly things like "lynching wolves," eh
welp, I feel the same as Geno (someone mark the date on that one) so congrats if you're the tanner!
 

Faddy

of, having, or involving transitory whims
We know B-Dubs is a bad guy. Therefore if Chuggs is also a bad guy he was the last person to claim and could safely pick Troublemaker with no issues.

He has also been pretty inactive and not really tried to do anything to solve the game.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Where is the like button.

Also I can't believe Chuggs is just going to get away with it.
I'm okay if we lose to that. If the reality is that you're town that super bungled this whole thing then that's karma I guess for all the props you were getting from last game lol
 

Faddy

of, having, or involving transitory whims
what's the point of fakeclaiming Troublemaker if you don't gambit with it

use your head, you hapless townie

That the team is Turmoil/B-Dubs and Chuggs as wolves plus Geno.

They win with me getting lynched. Chuggs didn't have to do anything.
 

Faddy

of, having, or involving transitory whims
I'm okay if we lose to that. If the reality is that you're town that super bungled this whole thing then that's karma I guess for all the props you were getting from last game lol

If town lose I will take a huge part of the blame but I am trying to fix my error by solving the game.
 

Dr. Worm

Has a PHD in Worms
I'm okay if we lose to that. If the reality is that you're town that super bungled this whole thing then that's karma I guess for all the props you were getting from last game lol
there's no point in reasoning with him, Natiko. the man clearly has no haps.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
ANrRcfT.jpg
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
If town lose I will take a huge part of the blame but I am trying to fix my error by solving the game.
You have thrown out every possible theory without following up on anything or really pressing anything. You've even thrown out theories you said yourself were wrong. You have contradicted yourself, sometimes within a single post.

That's not solving. That's noise.
 

malus

#1 official chartmaker
I can't stop laughing at the current situation lol.

If we go by the theory that there are 2 wolves and 1 tanner among Turmoil, Faddy and Apopheniac, then the wolves can only win if town spreads their votes evenly among 4 different people so they can force the town lunch. This means that wolves will definitely want Geno and possibly other people to be a viable targets.
 

Faddy

of, having, or involving transitory whims
I can't stop laughing at the current situation lol.

If we go by the theory that there are 2 wolves and 1 tanner among Turmoil, Faddy and Apopheniac, then the wolves can only win if town spreads their votes evenly among 4 different people so they can force the town lunch. This means that wolves will definitely want Geno and possibly other people to be a viable targets.

Geno is the minion. They have me in the vote pool. That is how the wolves are going to win.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
Has Faddy thrown an activity charge of obvious wolfishness at turmoil or just people who are more likely to be town? I know he has turmoil in his baddie pool, but just wondering.
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
Is there a world where Geno, Chugg, Turmoil, and Dubs were the original bad guys?

The current Center Cards in that world would be Drunk, Troublemaker, and Revealer. Chugg + Worm for current Wolves, and then Turmoil the Tanner and Geno the Minion?

I'm just not sure if I buy that as much.
 

Faddy

of, having, or involving transitory whims
You have thrown out every possible theory without following up on anything or really pressing anything. You've even thrown out theories you said yourself were wrong. You have contradicted yourself, sometimes within a single post.

That's not solving. That's noise.

The only 2 people who seem committed to anything are Fanto and Natiko.
 

Faddy

of, having, or involving transitory whims
Is there a world where Geno, Chugg, Turmoil, and Dubs were the original bad guys?

The current Center Cards in that world would be Drunk, Troublemaker, and Revealer. Chugg + Worm for current Wolves, and then Turmoil the Tanner and Geno the Minion?

I'm just not sure if I buy that as much.

Yes but Chuggs doesn't have to be a wolf. He can be the real troublemaker and there is a bad guy in the middle
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
Yes but Chuggs doesn't have to be a wolf. He can be the real troublemaker and there is a bad guy in the middle
Right, that too.

That world plus the world where you and Worm are the current Wolves makes me lean towards his vote now, yeah.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
Is there a world where Geno, Chugg, Turmoil, and Dubs were the original bad guys?

The current Center Cards in that world would be Drunk, Troublemaker, and Revealer. Chugg + Worm for current Wolves, and then Turmoil the Tanner and Geno the Minion?

I'm just not sure if I buy that as much.
It's possible, but if so, voting Wormiac still means a town win.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
Yeah, that's what I'm thinking, if that spot always equal Wolf in my head, then I'm probably feeling better about going there than for Faddy now.
He's trying real hard now to get us think he's tanner, though. I don't think I buy it.
 

malus

#1 official chartmaker
I think Apo is the safer option than Faddy. Apo and Turmoil are 100% lying while Faddy is only about 99% lying.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Is there a world where Geno, Chugg, Turmoil, and Dubs were the original bad guys?

The current Center Cards in that world would be Drunk, Troublemaker, and Revealer. Chugg + Worm for current Wolves, and then Turmoil the Tanner and Geno the Minion?

I'm just not sure if I buy that as much.
It's possible, which just gives more credence to voting Dr. Worm. I think that's where my vote is going at this point.

Just as a reminder - no fake out nonsense coming. I was the Witch, I inspected Card 1 and saw Insomniac, and I gave that card to B-Dubs.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
It's possible, which just gives more credence to voting Dr. Worm. I think that's where my vote is going at this point.

Just as a reminder - no fake out nonsense coming. I was the Witch, I inspected Card 1 and saw Insomniac, and I gave that card to B-Dubs.
Which means it's very likely we only lose here under one of the following scenarios:
-Dubs didn't understand the game
-Dubs had some correction that he just really couldn't post for whatever reason, busy, etc.

And both those seem unlikely here with mitigating factors.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Which means it's very likely we only lose here under one of the following scenarios:
-Dubs didn't understand the game
-Dubs had some correction that he just really couldn't post for whatever reason, busy, etc.

And both those seem unlikely here with mitigating factors.
Or option C of Dubs slowplayed the fuck out of Tanner and we're giving Dr. Worm a win, but c'est la vie if so.
 

Faddy

of, having, or involving transitory whims
Or option C of Dubs slowplayed the fuck out of Tanner and we're giving Dr. Worm a win, but c'est la vie if so.

I know I have not believed this since I think it is more likely to be Geno but you give no credence at all to Dubs being the minion?
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
Or option C of Dubs slowplayed the fuck out of Tanner and we're giving Dr. Worm a win, but c'est la vie if so.
Worm would have totally lucked into that and it would be fun to see, tbh. Also there's irony in the drunk failing upwards. I'm cool with it.
 

Faddy

of, having, or involving transitory whims
So are you just avoiding the Wormiac scenario or...?

No. But I think the fact that Dubs hasn't done anything means he is most likely to be tanner. If he was on the wolf team I feel like he would speak up for the sure win.

I guess their is still time.
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
I won't be mad regardless of the outcome, ONUW is pretty fun, I think I'd definitely be interested in playing again.

And yeah, I'm just voting Worm here.
 
Majority has been reached!
The game's over, and here are your results!

Initial Role Distribution:


Faddy as the Werewolf
B-Dubs as the
Werewolf
Malus
as the Mason
Lone_Prodigy
as the Mason
Geno
as the Apprentice Seer
Fantomas
as the Paranormal Investigator
Dr. Monkey
as the Robber
Natiko
as the Witch
TheChuggernaut
as the Troublemaker
Apopheniac
as the Drunk
Turmoil7
as the Tanner

Center card #1 - Insomniac
Center card #2
- Minion
Center card #3
- Revealer

Night Actions:


Faddy and B-Dubs wake up and see each other.
Malus and Lone_Prodigy wake up and see each other.
Geno
looks at card #2, sees the Minion.
Fantomas
investigates Dr. Monkey and Apopheniac; learns they're Robber and Drunk respectively.
Dr. Monkey robs Natiko, they switch roles.
Natiko hexes card #1 (Insomniac) and hands it to B-Dubs. Werewolf now card #1.
TheChuggernaut exchanges Dr. Monkey's and Fantomas' roles.
Apopheniac swaps his Drunk card with card#1, becomes Werewolf.

Final Role Distribution:


Faddy as the
Werewolf
B-Dubs
as the Insomniac
Malus
as the Mason
Lone_Prodigy
as the Mason
Geno
as the Apprentice Seer
Fantomas
as the Witch
Dr. Monkey
as the Paranormal Investigator
Natiko
as the Robber
TheChuggernaut
as the Troublemaker
Apopheniac
as the Werewolf
Turmoil7
as the Tanner

Center card #1 - Drunk
Center card #2
- Tanner
Center card #3
- Revealer


Final Votes:

Apopheniac: 6
(Malus, Geno, Fantomas ,Dr. Monkey ,Natiko ,Chuggernaut)

Faddy: 2
(Lone_Prodigy, Apopheniac)

B-Dubs: 1
(Faddy)

Apopheniac the Werewolf has been lunched!
Village wins! Congratulations!


how-to-cook-a-wolf.jpg


The End (again)
 
Last edited:
Man, town roles pretty much targeted and confirmed each other. Close to impossible game for team werewolves, IMO.

Also, it looks like something came up for B-Dubs and he couldn't participate as much as he wanted. He asked to be replaced 2 hours before the game was over after I sent him a game reminder, but there wasn't much point by then.
 

Faddy

of, having, or involving transitory whims
Man, town roles pretty much targeted and confirmed each other. Close to impossible game for team werewolves, IMO.

Also, it looks like something came up for B-Dubs and he couldn't participate as much as he wanted. He asked to be replaced 2 hours before the game was over after I sent him a game reminder, but there wasn't much point by then.

Pretty much.

I saw all the town being confirmed and yolo'd the seer claim. Maybe I should have been more coy with what card I saw but there wasn't much else to do.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Woo - go us. That was a rough game for the wolves to try and do anything with. Thanks everyone for the fun game! I felt like I actually got to contribute which was more than I can say for my other ONUW games.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
Pretty much.

I saw all the town being confirmed and yolo'd the seer claim. Maybe I should have been more coy with what card I saw but there wasn't much else to do.
You tried. And it was a great effort in a rough situation.
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
Well shit, I feel like I helped solve the game!

That was fun!

Sorry Faddy, you played a great game, enough for us to be too paranoid to vote for you even!
 

Faddy

of, having, or involving transitory whims
Woo - go us. That was a rough game for the wolves to try and do anything with. Thanks everyone for the fun game! I felt like I actually got to contribute which was more than I can say for my other ONUW games.

I had fun playing it out. I pushed every angle I could possibly think of but you called it, I had no chance of winning.
 

Faddy

of, having, or involving transitory whims
Well shit, I feel like I helped solve the game!

That was fun!

Sorry Faddy, you played a great game, enough for us to be too paranoid to vote for you even!

Town rolled pretty much the best roll interactions possible.

Fanto confirms Monkey and Worm
Monkey confirms Natiko
Natiko confirms the masons
Chuggs almost certainly confirms monkey didn't rob a bad guy

My yolo claim lost out to geno but that didn't even matter due to establishing Dubs as wolf. I guess Fanto had the best read that Turmoil was the tanner.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
I had fun playing it out. I pushed every angle I could possibly think of but you called it, I had no chance of winning.
Yeah, you managed to do a good job with a bad situation. In the end I convinced myself there was a decent chance you were the Tanner (until I came back after day end and saw your final push for Geno lol) which is actually a pretty great situation to be in in as a wolf. Just wasn't much you could do to save your teammate or swing it to a winning target.
 
Top Bottom