You didn't do anything. You just shouldn't assume that dude is ever misguided town. Sometimes he is. But always kill him anyway.
Spectator Thread Inside Muffin
- Thread starter Geno
- Start date
You didn't do anything. You just shouldn't assume that dude is ever misguided town. Sometimes he is. But always kill him anyway.
The only flips that were changed are the two from today. According to Geno Jedah always flips without info.
@Fandorin you were targeted by FoD because they desperately needed attention to go elsewhere. They hit your bp before, suspected your were in [Redacted] and maybe thought you were scum.
@weemadarthur You were supposed to be Fandorin's scapegoat, so nobody would look for Jedah.
And I guess everyone knows who is holding like half of all the items now
This reminds me, Fandorin why didn't you send Frostmourne to Stu?
@Fandorin you were targeted by FoD because they desperately needed attention to go elsewhere. They hit your bp before, suspected your were in [Redacted] and maybe thought you were scum.
@weemadarthur You were supposed to be Fandorin's scapegoat, so nobody would look for Jedah.
And I guess everyone knows who is holding like half of all the items now
Sorian
This reminds me, Fandorin why didn't you send Frostmourne to Stu?
Last edited:
Hey Stu, get better soon. You got played in-game by non-town. Different forces ridiculed you, until you got, idk sulky? (I'm not sure that's the right choice of words, non native language is hard, I don't mean offense)
You were spot-on with your suspicions, but just bombarded the thread with the same thing over and over again. Calling everyone dumb hardly gets you any followers. In general we can talk about aggressions postgame. I think a calm approach would've been more fruitful. Some were willing to listen.
Sorian antagonized you pretty well. Still no one is pointing out that he's siding with Muffin because Muffin failed to copy him. All the robo nonsense came from him. I think only Wee poked against him a bit (but half-heartedly)
You were spot-on with your suspicions, but just bombarded the thread with the same thing over and over again. Calling everyone dumb hardly gets you any followers. In general we can talk about aggressions postgame. I think a calm approach would've been more fruitful. Some were willing to listen.
Sorian antagonized you pretty well. Still no one is pointing out that he's siding with Muffin because Muffin failed to copy him. All the robo nonsense came from him. I think only Wee poked against him a bit (but half-heartedly)
I got pissed. I could have handled people not believing me as much as it annoyed me but when I started getting some of the shit flung at me that I was. I just went "fuck this"
I wasn't calling people dumb. Gullible yes but not dumb. I wanted people to consider a world where Geno was a giant bastard (<3 Geno) with Muffin's 'confirmation' and tried multiple approaches until it came down to me repeating myself over and over (I had multiple posts with more than just my 'suspicions' but people were just skipping over them).
Even mentioned how Sorian was the first person to bring up Robo and Muffin was just allowing it all to fall in his lap basically. But all of that doesn't matter because 'mod-confirmed town'
So sorry I didn't save you @Zippedpinhead :(
Jedah spoilers
Fando can we talk about how you used the power? I'm not talking about the post manipulation, that power was a mess, I'm talking fake flip, like, you should've tried to confuse everyone more. Make up something, like "Lex Luthor, you are aligned with Lexcorp", make up a super crazy power and a super crazy boost, everyone will think there's yet another faction.
Fanto
Confirmed Town
He seemed fine while I was in there, it was once I left that he started talking about robots and Muffin and shit lol. :P
But yes, if he's alive by D3 there's no need to keep him around really, this is something I have learned now lol.
TP knew I had it with me, so I didn’t want to give it straight away to him. Thought sending it to Sorian could work as a workaround way to get it to him.
I wanted the thread to believe the fake flip as much time as possible, so molding my own role made sense to avoid hitting a villain and fake claim that was in the game. I also wanted to give confirmation to town that the FoD actually existed since they are the biggest threat right now and probably who will take this win. Having a 4th faction or giving out OP fake powers to weem wouldn’t make sense further in the end game, at least I thought so.
I see that the fake two shot forced post command might force Chuggs to come forward. I still don’t get what happened there, but Zeke caught it on.
I see that the fake two shot forced post command might force Chuggs to come forward. I still don’t get what happened there, but Zeke caught it on.
It’s weird being a spectator before your character has died lol
I hope Sneeks lives to see the death of Sorian. All I ask
I hope Sneeks lives to see the death of Sorian. All I ask
weemadarthur
Mad as in angry, or mad as in crazy?
Smart move by VA.....
Damn, that is irrelevant. The spelling thing comes back to be a giant nothing. Also why am I lauded as a brilliant scum when I’m town. I ain’t shit as scum.
weemadarthur
Mad as in angry, or mad as in crazy?
I hope they start analyzing all the jokes I made with sorian and conclude we were scum partners. And then faddy too.
weemadarthur
Mad as in angry, or mad as in crazy?
omg lol
You’re the best flipped scum ever weem.
This is great lol
omg, Sorian is actually in the lead once with Votes.
Fun fact: I suspected there was something up with them near the start of the game. They were almost tooo cordial with each other and very much agreeing with each other or at least seeming like they were a team if that makes sense?
I just didn't bring it up cause I couldn't find a way to where it wouldn't get shouted down immediately haha.
Fun fact: I suspected there was something up with them near the start of the game. They were almost tooo cordial with each other and very much agreeing with each other or at least seeming like they were a team if that makes sense?
I just didn't bring it up cause I couldn't find a way to where it wouldn't get shouted down immediately haha.
We were a good scum team ;-;
weemadarthur
Mad as in angry, or mad as in crazy?
We had FUN but we still lost lol. I’ve only ever accidentally won as scum. And I didn’t help at all.
weemadarthur
Mad as in angry, or mad as in crazy?
weemadarthur
Mad as in angry, or mad as in crazy?
<3
I love this show lol.
weemadarthur
Mad as in angry, or mad as in crazy?
So....is Muffin a godfather too, and that’s why the innocent child role worked that way?
Frostmourne, you were very close, gave you 1 more shot.
No, the innocent child stuff is what you people made up, the role was never innocent child, it was "mod confirmed town".
Zippedpinhead
Zip it!
Hey, why does Ezekiel rage do the truffle shuffle all the time?
Is that game related or something else? Because either way I missed something.
Also, are we fully spoiled yet?
Is that game related or something else? Because either way I missed something.
Also, are we fully spoiled yet?
that's just zeke XD
weemadarthur
Mad as in angry, or mad as in crazy?
Wow, stu knows you really well lol.
Obviously I'm not the right person for this since I designed the game but I think it was pretty obvious that in a bastard game if scum had a copier their item would have allowed them to copy loki's role.
weemadarthur
Mad as in angry, or mad as in crazy?
I have no idea what I would’ve done with one more shot, tbh. I couldn’t think of anything that would move the game along. I didn’t care who the gossip was.
And sawneeks may never sign up for another geno game.
And sawneeks may never sign up for another geno game.
weemadarthur
Mad as in angry, or mad as in crazy?
Might have been better with a clue. Like, labeling me a watcher instead of not, and the same with all the rest. Because making up a role that exactly mimics the result of innocent child without being innocent child and then having no real way to deduce it, well I think you may be defending this one for a while lol.
Could've targeted chugg n2 to see what forced him to vote aeleus, Sorian did that, he can steal votes, but he's also ninja with his item, you wouldn't know that but it was worth a try
I definitely will and I am prepared for it.
I fucking told people this haha.
I even used the actual title of the role that Loki posted. "Mod-confirmed town" as evidence and was brushed off by almost everyone.
Quite frankly, I'm on Genos side against anyone who feels it was too bastard or whatever. :D
I’m all for making up your own roles, so you’ll get no complaints from me, even if town loses.
I still questioned Muffin’s alignment after the mod confirm. It’s just too convenient to believe and town shouldn’t just write muffin off just because of that, especially in a bastard game.
You should have backed me up, even just a little ;-;
I used the word "bastard game" so much that people just rolled their eyes at it. Someone else doing so might have helped haha.
<3 you anyway. Sorry I was so going at you early days, I was legit not feeling great (better than today/yesterday but still bleh. It was insomnia during the first few days and made me feel ill)
(^ that's why I was snarky and didn't really put in much effort. I just felt too bleh)
Fanto
Confirmed Town
I completely understood it as working this way as well.
Even if it was specifically called an Innocent Child, as I pointed out a couple pages ago in here, the Innocent Child is confirmed publicly as Town, that's their role. Sorian and others were trying to say in the thread that they would have their alignment confirmed publicly, but that's not true, the way the role always works is that the Gamerunner is going to say that they are Town, which means nothing in a Bastard game lol.
I think the day phase muffin became mod confirmed is definitely the one he’s automatically safe from lunching. It’s just how this game goes. With or without Sorian giving you shit, that train was not going to happen that day and I recognized that immediately. So I said what I needed to about it and backed off for the time being.
But if I recall correctly, i was careful to never say you were wrong about him or that he was town.
And no harm at all the first day phases.
I wonder how Muffin felt about me picking on him D2. And it was too obvious he was there the whole time D2 EOD when he claimed Megaman.
He was definitely in scum chat with Swamped lol
tbf, I think without Sorian and maybe Faddy, I'd have been able to convince people. The loudest ones are the ones that can muddy the waters a bit when people start wondering "Hmm... he may be onto something"
ie Sorian brought up the robot stuff, the chip stuff, and both brought up the Innocent Child stuff.
Without that, (since I obviously suck at arguing against people), I may have been able to convince enough people.
My main regret now is not scrutinizing Sorian more. I see more scumminess from him this day phase but I should have looked into him harder even if I was sure on Muffin. My only regret.
That is true now that I think about it lol.
<3 <3
I thought this too but I had no idea how to bring it up without being shouted down haha.
weemadarthur
Mad as in angry, or mad as in crazy?
Interesting.
I haven’t read a wiki in ages. It’s all over my head. And I’m not against a seriously-bastard game, I just wasn’t sure if I should expect it, and my own role sure didn’t tell me to lol.
I haven’t read a wiki in ages. It’s all over my head. And I’m not against a seriously-bastard game, I just wasn’t sure if I should expect it, and my own role sure didn’t tell me to lol.
I guess everyone after this should expect super bastard stuff next time they sign up for a Geno game haha.
Alexem
Yeah, I'm town
*ipodshuffle*
weemadarthur
Mad as in angry, or mad as in crazy?
I promise to listen to you better. Please don’t be scum. XD
Sawneeks is so so correct here.
weemadarthur
Mad as in angry, or mad as in crazy?
They shoulda seen it last day phase. I told em, I TOLD em, millenium hand and shrimp. Buggrit.
weemadarthur
Mad as in angry, or mad as in crazy?
Current argument can be summed up as: it’s the Players who are lying to us in this here bastard game!
Good job paying attention to detail. Just a bit more brainstorming options needed to figure it out.
Good job paying attention to detail. Just a bit more brainstorming options needed to figure it out.
Lone_Prodigy
Am I at 10 posts yet?
Gee look at all these normal role claims.
What is this even
roles~ roles everywhere
I'm okay with this name
Illuminati and Apo spoilers
Yes, that's the big secret of the game, there's a mason group of 5 people that are called the Illuminati, consisting of Lokiduck, Tearablepuns(now Sneeks), Fanto(Zeke now), Fandorin( Who was Jedah) and lastly Ketkat, these people couldn't mention anything about being in a secret chat or the illuminati, the Illuminati and the stone information is hidden from every flip as well. In hindsight I probably shouldn't have included Apo's power since it gives away the group, but I thought someone having info but no evidence of it would've been more fun. Apo is Gill from the SF series, the villain in lore created the Illuminati, so their goal is to eliminate them
Last edited:
their thread is 16 pages long in OM lol
Loki is panicking hardcore right now
There would be no Illuminati mention in the pm.
Lone_Prodigy
Am I at 10 posts yet?
Were they forcing Sneeks to claim? I would have held off, she wasn’t going to be the lunch today anyways
btw
She's lying; i never had the chaos emerald stolen. So, unless she had it stolen N5 (which i dont believe to be the case), she still has it :D
This is true btw
LOL.
damn, 2 items?
welp, i'm 1/3 so far lol better than 0/3 i guess
welp, i'm 1/3 so far lol better than 0/3 i guess
Fanto
Confirmed Town
I didn't read through the whole day, but what is this talk about [REDACTED]!?!!? I saw some specifically say [REDACTED] on the last page of the thread??? I'm gunna have to go look back for when that info came out lol.
It was!!!!
Fanto
Confirmed Town
Also, what Geno didn't mention above there:
Loki was the only one allowed to use her own OM account for the chat. The rest of us had to log in to costume accounts lol. I identity-claimed before the game started, but eventually Fandorin and Ketkat did as well in the first couple days. Tearable I don't think claimed as himself until after I had subbed out though.
Also, I thought Tearable was Verelios at first, which was dead wrong, but I did put the correct identity-read on Ketkat before she claimed lol.
Also, I thought Tearable was Verelios at first, which was dead wrong, but I did put the correct identity-read on Ketkat before she claimed lol.
I stole the Chaos Emerald back right after giving it to you, so Neeks is really telling the truth there. I’m guessing Apop has it actually, or whoever killed me from the FoD.
Lone_Prodigy
Am I at 10 posts yet?
i feel like Sorian should probably lie low during the item grab if he's smart. but then again, he'll probably go for the items b/c Hurricane Sorian
Geno never told me lmao
Facepalm, really? I at least told Sneeks lol
lol it's all good. hoping she saved the last one at least
it's all too obvious who has the stones now that mostly everyone has character claimed. the heroes that were in the narrative of last game...
I was actually very surprised you noticed that, usually my flavor is just flavor but sometimes I do want to reward a small bit the people that read it. So really good work on that
His flip was censored to remove all mentions of Illuminati
Fanto
Confirmed Town
Ah, right, forgot about that haha.
Verelios
Were-elios
That's a baller group.
Lol, actually nvm we found one
my nerdery on full display
LMAO VA hahaha