Spectator Thread GoT and TMBG Spectator Thread

Pedro

The Last Airbender is actually a great movie
Welcome to the spectator thread for Game of Thrones Mafia and They Might be Giants Mafia c:

Since this thread is also for people interested in TMBG, any spoiler from the ASOIAF books and/or GOT show should be properly hidden inside a spoiler tag!
 
Last edited:

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
I think everyone in here right now already has our design sheet lol Maybas well wait for actual players to mosey in (via violent death).
 

Sawneeks

little green dog
tenor.gif
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Faddy's such a smart cookie. Wouldn't surprise me if he figures out all of the hints off the bat except maybe one. We didn't want them to be some impossible challenge though.
 

dragon mom

Plays the Game of Chairs
I dunno, some of them are pretty tricky.

He's dropping all kinds of logic bombs. Way to go, Faddy! Proud of you <3

Hopefully it doesn't get you killed!
 

Sawneeks

little green dog
Also gonna echo the love for Faddy in GoT, that was a really good conclusion. No idea if he's right or not but that's a good guess regardless.
 

dragon mom

Plays the Game of Chairs
Also gonna echo the love for Faddy in GoT, that was a really good conclusion. No idea if he's right or not but that's a good guess regardless.

He's right. The reward goes to the faith player with the longest-standing active vote at day end.
 
Forgot the game was starting today! Faddy is already on the move, that was quick. Some town points for that, hard to see scum just blurting that immediately.

I agree with Faddy's interpretation of the religion hint. If roles stick to the religion they had in the show/books, then that means we'll be able to speculate people's roles based on how they react to religion hints.

Not sure what to think of Faddy's early role claim yet though.

Has Giant Panda played mafia before? This post has all the immediate signs of a newbie scum taking a quick and dirty shot at his opening post.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Apparently we should have gone over our GOT lore with a finer comb. We handed someone the wrong religion canonically. Oh well - not changing it because they're set a certain way for balance. Shrug. My bad.
 

dragon mom

Plays the Game of Chairs
We didn't. According to the wiki:

Raised as a lady, Sansa possesses the traditional feminine graces of her milieu, with a keen interest in music, poetry, singing, dancing, embroidery, and other traditional feminine activities. Like many girls her age, Sansa is enthralled by songs and stories of romance and adventure, particularly those depicting handsome princes, honorable knights, chivalry, and love. She keeps faith with both the old gods and the Seven.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Oh okay. Then eat it haters.

I thought I had checked all that, but doubted myself after reading Monkey’s post. Been a hot minute since we set that stuff lol[/spoiler{
 

dragon mom

Plays the Game of Chairs
After Sansa becomes disillusioned with knightly honor and the virtues of the Seven, she starts to gravitate towards her Northern roots.
 

dragon mom

Plays the Game of Chairs
I’m laughing at

Zeke’s concern trolling and low key fishing for religion alignments, how cute
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Splinter mentioned recruitment

Oh boy here we gooooo
Unfortunately for scum it will be a miss if they target him. They should realize that no vanilla would know they can be recruited though based on the sample PM. They have slightly over a 50% chance to succeed before their skill expires ignoring kills.
 

Dr. Worm

Has a PHD in Worms
someone in scumchat has selected someone to cast suspicion on, and it's the absolute worst choice they could make because of that player's role (which I really like and am proud of)

dis gon be gud
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
someone in scumchat has selected someone to cast suspicion on, and it's the absolute worst choice they could make because of that player's role (which I really like and am proud of)

dis gon be gud
Oh no lol
 

cabot

Why.
Casting suspicion on players before play has even begun?

Rookie mistake. Players give themselves plenty of rope to hang themselves on when it starts
 

cabot

Why.
Monkey says she has perpetual scum disorder, then throws a really terrible defense of Zeke that by her own explanation only she understands.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Monkey says she has perpetual scum disorder, then throws a really terrible defense of Zeke that by her own explanation only she understands.
She likes to protest too much :P How many times has she actually been lynched?
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
I like that people still think they can force Blarg to give up a gimmick just because he's getting voted for it.
 

Dr. Worm

Has a PHD in Worms
notes for GoT:

- oh my god, that alignment/role/religion/whateverthefuck speculation was unbearable
- someone needs to make a plugin that automatically opens all spoiler tags
- ugh
 

dragon mom

Plays the Game of Chairs
When someone remembers your D1 scumread from a previous game <3

Thanks Faddy for remembering me <33333
 

dragon mom

Plays the Game of Chairs
Part of me wants to tell blarg to knock it off with the spoilers but then the other part of me thinks it's hilarious

What a pickle I find myself in
 

dragon mom

Plays the Game of Chairs
The problem with Blarg is that people think he's impossible to read because of his erratic playstyle. That allows him to be utterly transparent in his attempts to needlessly complicate the game without that action rousing the suspicion it rightly should.

nail+hammer.jpg
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Part of me wants to tell blarg to knock it off with the spoilers but then the other part of me thinks it's hilarious

What a pickle I find myself in
He's not breaking any rules, let him have his fun. If he dies for it then that's on him. If he doesn't then no one really has any ground to stand on to complain.
 

cabot

Why.
I don't really like doubled. He seems to be skating and is evasive.

I'd also vote kits cause she's done very little.
 

cabot

Why.
Oh zookfoodle is in this game.


Yeah he'd be a candidate too. Surprised no one has really brought him up
 

cabot

Why.
I always consider blarg as an early lynch, id rather eliminate the noise early, but I don't know he's not been useless in the game so far.

There are better candidates.
 

cabot

Why.
Heads up, I feel something should be done to phase start and end times. This season has been particularly bad for Europeans.

Our meta is still pretty based around a lot of movement at day end so players will miss a lot when they're asleep.

I understand you guys want to be there for your own game but I think the players should come first and a time that is acceptable to the vast majority of players is for the best.

True, the NZers are usually boned but there are only a couple of them frankly and it is a game of numbers.

That's the benefit of an mod team, to be able to make these accommodations.

I can at least help out Dr worm if you want a more fair time for all zones.
 

cabot

Why.
I guess it could change the community meta if it keeps on like this, but my feeling is because so much happens typically at day end in our games it's a little unfair to the sleepers
 

cabot

Why.
Then there's the good old d1 mentality. Who can we lose as town considering the chances of hitting scum are low and who needs more time to figure out alignment?

Out of those choices, kits seems the best lynch. Blarg actually reacting to the backlash is interesting but not particularly alignment indicative.

Splinter and Zeke haven't done enough to be on the table yet.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Heads up, I feel something should be done to phase start and end times. This season has been particularly bad for Europeans.

Our meta is still pretty based around a lot of movement at day end so players will miss a lot when they're asleep.

I understand you guys want to be there for your own game but I think the players should come first and a time that is acceptable to the vast majority of players is for the best.

True, the NZers are usually boned but there are only a couple of them frankly and it is a game of numbers.

That's the benefit of an mod team, to be able to make these accommodations.

I can at least help out Dr worm if you want a more fair time for all zones.
I feel bad moving it up because the 'typical' start time we've had in the past of around 4:00 PM EDT would mean every day start and end that does not fall on the weekend would have to be handled by a mod in all likelihood. We're both at work at that time and while I can check in from work, there's no consistency to when I can depending on my work load, meeting schedule, etc.
 

cabot

Why.
I feel bad moving it up because the 'typical' start time we've had in the past of around 4:00 PM EDT would mean every day start and end that does not fall on the weekend would have to be handled by a mod in all likelihood. We're both at work at that time and while I can check in from work, there's no consistency to when I can depending on my work load, meeting schedule, etc.

Maybe better mod representation from across all time zones so you can give a heads up about not making a deadline, someone else can pick up the day end and post the result, fluff can wait until you're able to do it.

The best solution probably requires a bit more work / availability from mods who aren't game runners, but it would allow the most players to be around for day end.

I'll raise it in a feedback thread which is the most appropriate place to discuss
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
I pray for the day we get a Blarg designed game. His dragon cult post lol
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Also, I'd like to thank everyone that has been helping and posting vote counts. Faddy, Cabot, and Pedro have all done so I believe. Many thanks!
 
My bad. Put myself in the spotlight. Originally I was sincere, then I just kept at it to see who would try to pile on me for no reason.

But then got surprised with an impromptu dinner with friends with 2 hours left to go in the game and didn't have a chance to defend myself.

Though, I didn't really expect to be lynch target numero uno.

I'm really curious if my gut on muffis and/or melonrabbit were completely off or not.

Oops. :/
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
My bad. Put myself in the spotlight. Originally I was sincere, then I just kept at it to see who would try to pile on me for no reason.

But then got surprised with an impromptu dinner with friends with 2 hours left to go in the game and didn't have a chance to defend myself.

Though, I didn't really expect to be lynch target numero uno.

I'm really curious if my gut on muffis and/or melonrabbit were completely off or not.

Oops. :/
Gonna make you wait to find out on your gut on those players, but I did want to say it was really unfortunate how it shifted to you at day end when you weren’t around. Hopefully the next time you play you get to stick around a little longer!
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Lol the night actions are shaping up to be a shitshow if they stay as is. Oh man.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Oh shit

Scum are trending towards attempting to recruit Player A, who is deflecting actions to Player B. Player A isn’t recruitable, Player B is. HOWEVER, Player B is who scum are planning to push for a lynch Day 2 and isn’t in the best standing all said. Yikes lol
 
Top Bottom