Spectator Thread Doctor Who This Ain't - Spectator Thread

Fanto

Confirmed Town
Ok, I'm going to go off and check out the Scum Thread, the Cult Thread (oh boy lol) and all of those Love Boats.

Y'all should go read the Mason Thread and Boat 7 when you get the chance if you haven't already as well.
 

Chuggernaut

HONK HONK MF
Ok, I'm going to go off and check out the Scum Thread, the Cult Thread (oh boy lol) and all of those Love Boats.

Y'all should go read the Mason Thread and Boat 7 when you get the chance if you haven't already as well.

Mason thread is great. Would strongly recommend
 
Don't feel bad Fanto, you played well and I probably couldn't have put in as much effort as you did into the game if I'd tried. The cards were just badly stacked against you.
 

rac

whatever
I really needed rac to not stop fucking posting. I was kidding when I told him stop because of his post count being higher than mine, and now I fear that he didn't want to post because I said that.
nah i just couldn't do it anymore
 

turmoil7

Imperial Corps Commander Who Cheers the Army
@Fantomas

The "mostantitownplayer.jpg" was aimed at Ceecee self voting during Ceecee/Flux

By using your town cred I meant leading the way towards turboing someone on Double Lynch Day rather than waiting for the time to run off and lynching twice at once. That is the best town play because it gives + info for the second lynch. Everyone scum was really worried of LP being done if the first lynch was Cult so they would had loved to sleepwalk into a Ceecee + Flux EoD
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
Scum Chat, whole bunch of the Scummiest Scums who ever Scummed. Made me sick.

Cult Chat? Whole bunch of wannabe Scums trying to figure out what the fuck to do. Amateur hour up in there, especially that Sorian guy.
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
Ok, I still haven't gone through all those Boats, don't know if I ever will honestly.

I'll try to get some more full thoughts about the game down in here now that I've cooled down a bit.
 

Faddy

of, having, or involving transitory whims
Ok, I still haven't gone through all those Boats, don't know if I ever will honestly.

I'll try to get some more full thoughts about the game down in here now that I've cooled down a bit.

The Brazil/Fandorin boat (1) is good. Especially the part about Brazil never doing pre-typed posts but then on his death he come in here with his dissertation on the game at the ready.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
I chuckled when the rng results came in.
I REFUSE TO BELIEVE THAT WAS ONE ROLL lol

@Natiko will be back in a month telling you how bad he is at this game. There's a lie you shouldn't believe :P
Man, it was SO HARD to not play into that after all my “scum reads” were wrong. Really got saved by Saw flipping cult and using that to rile up town to focus on cult exclusively.

Ok, I still haven't gone through all those Boats, don't know if I ever will honestly.

I'll try to get some more full thoughts about the game down in here now that I've cooled down a bit.
You really are too hard on yourself. You’re so much better at this game than I was that early into my Mafia days. Losses will happen. I think half my games have been losses. Several have been squarely my fault. Don’t let it shake your confidence, you’ll continue to get better.
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
Day 1
NOT CONFIRMED TOWN

I enter the game thinking I'm hot shit.

Within like 12 hours or so I realize I am completely outclassed by the majority of the players.

I was convinced that both Ketkat and Chugg were Scum for sure.

Monkey's "weathervane" comment. Scummiest comment ever, should have tunneled her for the rest of the game over that shit.

Day 1.5
NOT CONFIRMED TOWN

RIP Stan.

Lol at me and Terraforce being partners because I had a shitty D1 Meta Read on him. Sick Read Brazil.

Day 2
NOT CONFIRMED TOWN

I am getting way too many scum reads by this point and am worried that me and Cabot will need to claim.

Cabot panics and tells the thread not to shoot me. I was worried Scum would pick up on that. Of course, they talked all about it in their thread. They figured it was more likely Cabot was a Cop though than us being Masons lol.

Rest of D2 turned into a shitshow, we all know how that went down now. Scum Thread is the panic I expected to see.

Day 3
CONFIRMED TOWN

Now I feel no worries at all. Oh, what was that? People were scum reading me? Not anymore! BEGONE FOUL SCUM READS!

LOL at Scum Chat. "Let's Power Wolf Fantomas today you guys!" they all said to each other on N2. Yeah, how did that one turn out after you guys decided to kill Cabot The Cop before he could give his Green Check on me? LOL owned.

Faddy became my top target because there was no way I could get scum read for going after the sickest read I had coming out of D2.

Of course, I was right. Faddy was Scum. As fuck.

Day 4
STILL CONFIRMED TOWN

Called out FluxWaveZ as a Neutral.

Beginning of the end for me.

I decide to go hard on Fandorin. Bad idea. He was Town. I fucked that one allllllllll up.

Day 5
SHOULD HAVE DIED
STILL CONFIRMED TOWN

Pirate Bae...

Day 6
SHOULD HAVE DIED
STILL CONFIRMED TOWN

I knew the Malus lynch was too easy. Especially once things went quiet when I voted there.

Switched my vote to Saw, who turned out to be a Cultist. Nice.

Day 7
SHOULD HAVE DIED
NO LONGER CONFIRMED TOWN BECAUSE OF CULT BUT DEFINITELY NOT SCUM STILL

Both Scum and Cult ran with my Zeke read all the way to the bank.

Hence why I knew that was a bad choice and voted for Kyan, who we now know was an actual Cultist.

Day 8
SHOULD HAVE DIED
NO LONGER CONFIRMED TOWN BECAUSE OF CULT BUT DEFINITELY NOT SCUM STILL

Don't believe his lies.

Finally. FluxWaveZ. My white whale of the game.

As soon as he put out that read list with me as "Possible Cult, Former Town Mason" I knew I would be voting for him and it would be easy to get others to go with me.

And of course, he was Cult! HAHAHAHAAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!!!! SICKEST READ!!!! NEUTRAL FLUX!!!!

Day 8.5
NO LONGER CONFIRMED TOWN BECAUSE OF CULT BUT DEFINITELY NOT SCUM STILL

This is where I fucked it all up.

I should have realized we needed to kill Scum instead.

I thought there were only 2 Scum left because that seemed to make the most sense considering we had 5 Neutrals running around during this game.

But no, I was stupid. There were still 3.

We lost because I am a terrible Town Leader in the later days.

The same reason we lost in GoT.

--------------------------------------------------

More detailed thoughts and random paranoia that I had about Dr. Monkey throughout the game can be found in the Mason Thread.
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
Lessons learned:

1. Being Confirmed Town feels good.

2. Always lynch Sorian on D1.

3. Never sign up for a game if Dr. Monkey is also signing up.

4. I should always be suspicious when players who are better than me agree with me for no good reason, especially when they wanted nothing to do with my "weathervane" opinions earlier in the game.
 

Pedro

The Last Airbender is actually a great movie
Lessons learned:

1. Being Confirmed Town feels good.

2. Always lynch Sorian on D1.

3. Never sign up for a game if Dr. Monkey is also signing up.

4. I should always be suspicious when players who are better than me agree with me for no good reason, especially when they wanted nothing to do with my "weathervane" opinions earlier in the game.

Fanto, I understand your frustration, but you have been doing too many digs at other players in all of the chats here in OM and on Era, and it's starting to really not be cool. Take some time off, and please listen to what everyone is saying: you are being too hard on yourself, and sometimes you will unfortunately lose a game and get lied to; that's the nature of Mafia. Don't take anything personally because at the end of the day it's all a game.
 

rac

whatever
Ok, I still haven't gone through all those Boats, don't know if I ever will honestly.

I'll try to get some more full thoughts about the game down in here now that I've cooled down a bit.
the fuck are you doing extra credit for you don't get shit i mean i barely read the thread fuck are you doing
 

rac

whatever
Being an asshole obviously.
fanto you were the one bring me back into the game and i just want to thank you

also know that i now have my phone recognizing fanto

also also i would say you are a top tier player and shouldn't stop
 

Sorian

Neutral Ascetic 1-Shot BP SK Alignment Cop
Staff member
fanto you were the one bring me back into the game and i just want to thank you

also know that i now have my phone recognizing fanto

also also i would say you are a top tier player and shouldn't stop

I had an argument with my phone yesterday because it kept trying to auto correct Fando to Fanto so that's a thing now.

Edit: My phone also automatically always capitalizing Fire because of @Fireblend
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
I disagree.

But yes, I'll stay away.

I probably shouldn't play this game.
All the praise for your play in GOT wasn’t because you suck. All the praise over your play in Conspiracy wasn’t because you suck. I flubbed a mafia championship game horribly, let Sorian and Saw get away with Town Hooker, and was told I was the worst mafia player ever in PPM but here I am. Most people don’t think I suck just because I haven’t nailed every game.
 

rac

whatever
side note: if you are ever scum again keep changing what you call people in the thread (ex. fan, fand, fando, fandorin)
it would make it much harder to search the thread later

quoting this here in spec from boat 7 so everyone keeps me honest
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
fanto you were the one bring me back into the game and i just want to thank you

also know that i now have my phone recognizing fanto

also also i would say you are a top tier player and shouldn't stop
<3<3<3
quoting this here in spec from boat 7 so everyone keeps me honest
I can't stress enough how much people should read Boat 7 if you read any boat lol.

Not for my content, that shit is boring. Go for the Rac content. It is top tier.
 

rac

whatever
secondary thought refer to people as emojis or heiroglyphics or some shit to really fuck with everyone
 

Verelios

Were-elios
Lessons learned:

1. Being Confirmed Town feels good.

2. Always lynch Sorian on D1.

3. Never sign up for a game if Dr. Monkey is also signing up.

4. I should always be suspicious when players who are better than me agree with me for no good reason, especially when they wanted nothing to do with my "weathervane" opinions earlier in the game.
Brah, my first game was scum (Bloodborne) and I was already known, by name, by a neutral whose WC was to get me lynched. It showed. That was a nasty 3 day implosion that ended with a slugfest between cult and scum to throw heat off with town ultimately winning. This is good in comparison, you're goochie.

All I can say is that when you're feeling your own hype and someone stands up to say YOU ARE THE HYPE, they probably don't mean that, they're suss.
 
I had an argument with my phone yesterday because it kept trying to auto correct Fando to Fanto so that's a thing now.

Edit: My phone also automatically always capitalizing Fire because of @Fireblend
<3 yeah my phone knows way too many Mafiera player names :P

And don't feel bad @Fantomas , I was pretty frustrated coming out of Conspiracy Mafia, I'm regularly outclassed by plenty of players in the community both in terms of activity and just being good at the game, and I've had to take time off mafia before, but in the end I love this community too much to stay mad at people and I know I'm not a star player so I'm ok with just trying to have a good time and knowing I did my best.

And still, you played a great game. I don't think coming into D7 many players would have done better than you, I certainly wouldn't. And give Monkey another chance, maybe you'll have the same alignment next time :D
 

Chuggernaut

HONK HONK MF
Ok, I still haven't gone through all those Boats, don't know if I ever will honestly.

I'll try to get some more full thoughts about the game down in here now that I've cooled down a bit.

The Brazil brothers one is pretty fun. Sorian/Monkey is kind of fun just knowing how everything shook out. I think my boat with Neeks is kind of hilarious just by Neeks reaction when I blow up. Everyone else's are pretty quick reads
 

Chuggernaut

HONK HONK MF
Day 1
NOT CONFIRMED TOWN

I enter the game thinking I'm hot shit.

Within like 12 hours or so I realize I am completely outclassed by the majority of the players.

I was convinced that both Ketkat and Chugg were Scum for sure.

Monkey's "weathervane" comment. Scummiest comment ever, should have tunneled her for the rest of the game over that shit.

This was basically my day 1. I came in there like "This is my third game, I got this shit down." and then I realized I was in there with a who's who of good players and that I was in way over my head. And then you Fran tagged teamed me for that whole super long day phase :(
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
Oh! @Fandorin, I just wanted to offer you a virtual handshake. I got kinda boxed in by my own strategy and had to keep going after you but I have nothing but love for you, man.
 

rac

whatever
wait what the fuck how did i forget chug of course i was purposefully ignoring all your posts because i knew i was gonna scum read you
 

Sawneeks

little green dog
And give Monkey another chance, maybe you'll have the same alignment next time :D

@Fantomas or just lynch her on sight like Sorian, it's a win-win. :D

The Brazil brothers one is pretty fun. Sorian/Monkey is kind of fun just knowing how everything shook out. I think my boat with Neeks is kind of hilarious just by Neeks reaction when I blow up. Everyone else's are pretty quick reads
my heart is still broken after you were taken away from us so early. ;;;
 

Sawneeks

little green dog
<3<3<3

I can't stress enough how much people should read Boat 7 if you read any boat lol.

Not for my content, that shit is boring. Go for the Rac content. It is top tier.
You were right, that was a great read lol.

"fanto can you just lynch me tomorrow please"

and rac shush about not knowing what to do. you called out something being up about bae before she got counterclaimed on her Cop claim. considering everyone believed her that's pretty good, you just gotta follow that gut feel.
 

Stantastic

Our Badminton Stanpion
@Fantomas it really cant be said enough that whether you end up on the winning team or not, whether you accurately figured out most of the players, or even whether you just survived is very rarely a good indicator of your performance in this game.

The sheer probabilty of this game dictates that you are probably going to fail more than you succeed, and ending up on the winning or losing team is fairly superfluous.

The only real way you can judge yourself is by looking at yourself, look at each choice you made throughout the game with thought to the (usually terribly uninformed) context you were in at the time, and asking yourself honestly if what you did was unreasonable, if it was then thats just something to learn from and if it wasnt then thats just the bullshit that is this wonderfully chaotic game that we all have learned to roll with.

This is by design a difficult and unfair game, expecting anything even clise to perfection from yourself will just drive you crazy, because even if you somehow reached it you can still lose.

Exibit A: fucking me on day 1.
 
One of these days I'm going to figure out how to make it through early game without having to fight off getting mislynched
I feel like I'm on the precipice of getting lynched in every game I play, but there's not enough to get me kicked completely off. And scum don't kill me, either. So I end up surviving for a while with people mainly side-eyeing me. I think I talk too much (and also not with enough actual analysis).
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
This was basically my day 1. I came in there like "This is my third game, I got this shit down." and then I realized I was in there with a who's who of good players and that I was in way over my head. And then you Fran tagged teamed me for that whole super long day phase :(
Yeah, I felt bad. I really felt bad about Ketkat though, that Mason thread has some real paranoia in it lol we convinced each other. Having 100+ hours of nothing but D1 bullshit to go off of is not healthy.
We almost did it, too.
If Sorian didn't die and you guys had recruited me, we would have won.

I also would have hard bussed one of you guys though for the cred lol. Probably Kyan. (Sorry Kyaaaaa)
One of these days I'm going to figure out how to make it through early game without having to fight off getting mislynched
If I ever find myself not scum reading you in the early game, I'll probably think you are Scum lol.

On a more serious note, I need to work on figuring out how to not lash out at any mention of me not being the Townest Town who ever Towned regardless of my alignment.
You were right, that was a great read lol.

"fanto can you just lynch me tomorrow please"
My personal favorite is still "never show your work" lol.
Exibit A: fucking me on day 1.
I've settled down now, but yeah, your death was perhaps the most amazingly shitty thing I've ever seen so far, and I actually expected much more anger in here than there was lol.
 
The Brazil/Fandorin boat (1) is good. Especially the part about Brazil never doing pre-typed posts but then on his death he come in here with his dissertation on the game at the ready.
Hahahaha, I'd forgotten about that. More proof that I should've stuck to my principles.
 

Fanto

Confirmed Town
yo fanto i never got a for my eyes only, the hell
FOR RAC'S EYES AND USE ONLY
hfo1xVS.gif

X0L6xPu.gif

w8tFSGM.gif
 
  • Like
Reactions: rac

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
Finally got to Brazil's big posts. I definitely stand by wanting that kill! Bullets dodged. It's amazing to me how right on that was in terms of targets while being off for reasons - I think there's a lesson to be learned there that while we might not ever know what's happening in the game until it happens, following those trails really can lead to discoveries.
 
Top Bottom