Spectator Thread Greed Island GM control room

Faddy

of, having, or involving transitory whims
My review. Too many chats. Not enough stopping town getting murdered.

The scum roles are super strong. (maybe too strong... ability to make a team mate unlynchable and give a double kill... yeesh). Really good job on those roles. I thought you guys played really well and co-ordinated things brilliantly.

Town went for more fun roles, more interaction but nothing really helpful in stopping the math of being outnumbered by scum.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
That was both a fun and frustrating game. Wish I got to stick around longer but I wasn't expecting to meet my condition even if I did live longer.

I was genuine with everything I posted near the end or even during the whole game, which I understand why people in the thread are dismissing it now but still a bummer. Even my desire for people to vote is something I feel I always do, even if people don't notice it. I do think this game was my breaking point just in terms of meta. Being scumread from the same people and it never changing from game to game is just incredibly frustrating at this point. Then it happened with other people like Sorians death being entirely due to meta and nothing to do with the game. I don't know. I definitely had a moment on day 1 where I felt like I was done with the community because it's basically every game where people try to throw meta reads onto me that I know are inaccurate.

It is great to see the bomb work at least. I thought that was going to be a bad choice but the ITAs and people holding back their votes meant today would have been tough anyway.

Also at least like three people saying I shot Stu when I clearly shot Zipped. And I'm the one who was apparently not reading the thread.
I hate to hear this Kalor - I like playing with you, hopefully you come back some more :(

You. Funny thing, scum actually targeted Nin first and both of you would have survived, but then they swapped to you. And no, they didn't know that you were loved.



Everyone is Thresh in this game.



I will say the same thing that I said in the scum chat. This game really tired me. I had fun with all the roles and all but running it is a lot of work, a lot more work than a regular game. I had to deal with a looooot of things, had to check a whole lot of others and answer a thousand questions and everyone complains about every little change or decision that I took. I don't know if I will run another one of this. The role creation rules definitely need some work so there are more stricts rules for creating roles and less confusion. I love the concept so I may run another but definitely not any time soon.

BTW, big spoiler:

We will miss you Monkey.
You did a great job Fran. I know I asked a trillion questions and didn’t make it easy, but I think you did a tremendous job juggling everything. A+ job would play again.

It was a bad post... I should have been clearer about specifically talking about comparing Star Trek episodes and Code of Honor while indeed racist is not really any more racist than a whole bunch of other episodes. Which I think is a valid point when discussing which episode is the most reprehensible...

...Live and learn.



I think it is really strange. It could be a power to commute for the day. Otherwise it is very bad manners by Dubs to just ignore the game/mod for a whole day phase but I guess you can never really know what someone's IRL circumstances are.
Three months?! Damn, that sucks.

LOL I was telling Fran we should call this game "Chats the game," considering how many we have had. Wonder if we'll have anymore.

Also on @Muffin (please read this when you enter spec chat.)

He's really beating himself up but he has actually protected town twice now. He would have probs done it a 3rd time??? if someone hadn't stopped another night. XD So great job Muffin, scum is actually really scared of you.
Yeah Muffin almost saved the game for town with his role.

Hello spec chat ;___;

Haha waking up to my death made me cry/laugh.

It hurts having been right on kyan in the first place and then changing my mind XD ahhh
I’m sorry :( You were on the right trail at the end, just couldn’t put the words together to convince anyone fast enough to hold their votes is all.
 
Top Bottom