Spectator Thread Spectator chat
- Thread starter Geno
- Start date
Nah, Sorian's role is op. He'll get triple vote, making it four all together.
The Bear
Obligatory Gay Bear of the Society
Scum still needs to kill muffin before muffin kills them. And if muffin dies... Lol.
Faddy
of, having, or involving transitory whims
They have already flipped 2 or 3 godfathers and a miller. I don't think now is the time to be questioning checks with so many of those type of roles flipped.
I like Terra's play. He is never winning as an SK. May as well ride with town. 2 Mafia and 4 SKs out the game. Town is looking pretty good from that pespective.
Stan gets his triple vote from the mega stone, sorian will get a 1 shot commute
Faddy
of, having, or involving transitory whims
It is a hard game. They want to work out Includios vs Stan. Both seem town but logically one of them probably isn't. Lynching outside that is tricky because no one has a totally solid read. I guess my thoughts on the multi votes is that 3 votes vs 3 votes. One of them is definitely town and can counter the other. If one of them was mafia and they pick incorrectly...
I'm glad Natiko just got janitored out of existence. Oh wait they saw the flip and no one has said a word.
Btw when I typed m Sorian/Spinter mafia thing I hadn't looked at the spoilers. Surprised when it was both of them. Hecht was the other player I was doubting; and Monkey too but the reasons were mean.
Yeah, but people talk him out of it :(
---
What in the world made Splinter come up with this...? :D
Faddy
of, having, or involving transitory whims
The basic gist of what I was going to post was about her trust of Sorian.
Dr. Monkey said:
Monkey please re-evaluate.
Wut
Did Sorian just throw
Did Sorian just throw
Faddy
of, having, or involving transitory whims
He was in a tough situation. He doesn't vote Splinter then he is outed as his partner. If he does his secret double vote is outed and he is scum.
This has actually worked out perfectly for town because the alternative is that Muffin has the double vote.
The alternative was to tunnel on Hecht with Monkey. He didn't have a good option.
Faddy
of, having, or involving transitory whims
How is LP's night survival being counted here?
He has survived 2 nights, does he need another 2 after being revived? It seems unlikely he will turn before the game ends.
The Bear
Obligatory Gay Bear of the Society
I don't know, actually. That question is for Geno.
He has already turned inside Muffin, Night 4 has passed and that's what he needed.
Faddy
of, having, or involving transitory whims
The Bear
Obligatory Gay Bear of the Society
If it happens, I will post luigi wins by doing absolutely nothing gif.
can you update the night actions? :D
The Bear
Obligatory Gay Bear of the Society
Muffin is going to shoot includious. That's all we know for now iirc.
Faddy
of, having, or involving transitory whims
What is the deal with the Tardis right now. Does Stan have it? If he knows Hecht gave it to him then he can be sure Hecht is town. And in a thunderdome situation he always votes Sorian.
Hecht has it right now.
Faddy
of, having, or involving transitory whims
Monkey's basically love letter to Sorian is a tough read. Ohh he is soooo Town <3
It is pretty much impossible to go back and read the full thread but I don't remember a damn thing he has done as town. He never shared, confirmed his item. He spent forever dodging giving a specific power, he claimed something waaaaay back at the start of the game but hasn't openly accounted his actions like everyone else.
She has been in his pocket for the full game. Which is fine but she needs to re-evaluate and her reads can't just be I read him as town early so he is town now forever.
It is pretty much impossible to go back and read the full thread but I don't remember a damn thing he has done as town. He never shared, confirmed his item. He spent forever dodging giving a specific power, he claimed something waaaaay back at the start of the game but hasn't openly accounted his actions like everyone else.
She has been in his pocket for the full game. Which is fine but she needs to re-evaluate and her reads can't just be I read him as town early so he is town now forever.
Monkey's reads and plays are so bad it hurts.
Fran said:
Nah, everyone will rightfully blame everyone but Hecht.
Faddy
of, having, or involving transitory whims
I don't think that was a smart play by Hecht, the lynch is on a knife edge here. For me it seems like Faircure and Fran are waiting for Monkey to make a decision.
Stan might just come in and Burn Blast everyone though. He is unpredictable in my experience.
Stan might just come in and Burn Blast everyone though. He is unpredictable in my experience.
Fran and Fairview are definitely following not leading. I don't understand why confirmed town Fran is so passive.
The hecht play was desperation. I think it was probably trying to appeal to Stan, who is the wildcard here.
Faddy
of, having, or involving transitory whims
But Stan isn't reading the thread though. He will come in soon I think.
Monkey was reconsidering and was suggesting that in a Sorian vs Hecht thunderdome she would go for Sorian. The kindest thing that can be said about the Hecht play was it is an attempt to force the lynch to be between 2 people. Like there is definitely the possibility monkey doesn't make a choice between them and goes for Muffin.
Kind of yeah.
Faddy
of, having, or involving transitory whims
Ugh Fran! I definitely did not see a strong push on Monkey. More like he was refusing to make a decision and Monkey was his fall back.
Hecht is dead. Not an issue if they just follow what he said instead of the previous lynches where everyone just had a case of amnesia.
Hecht is dead. Not an issue if they just follow what he said instead of the previous lynches where everyone just had a case of amnesia.
Yeah... admittedly, I knew Sorian's alignment early on, but the stuff he's been posting wasn't towny. It feels like he gets townreads no matter what he's doing.
"I know this looks scummy, but post all the info you have town"
"gee, this might look suspicious, but I have to ask you to claim right now"
"come on, everyone tell me what you did at night"
"me? NAH, no way I'm telling you anything about me"
"nope, not going to claim" (when 90% already claimed)
and he keeps getting away with it.
Unfortunately Hecht made it easy today :( He scumread Sorian's behaviour since a few phases, but only tunneled on mechanics the others didn't believe in. Instead of delivering this shit show, which Sorian gladly took part in, Hecht should have justified his read from ingame stuff.
It felt like Hecht did have a good reason, but tried to justify only through mechanics to convince others. It was so frustrating to see everyone talking against Hecht.
How Hecht ended up with Sorian through exclusion was okay. Only the constant bickering between the two made everyone go nah, he's mad, that can't be right.
Like what was the reason for scum!Hecht to go all in today? He wasn't exactly strongly scumread before, even though he did scummy shit like passing the item to Splinter.
Why would scum!Hecht implode like this today? He'd never make it this easy :/
mmmhh...
I'm aware I saw this from the outside, so I don't want to be too hard on anyone. Who knows how I would've reacted.
These town players deserve each other.
Fran, Monkey, Crimson, Stan
And I thought the town at the end of Buffy was bad for lynching me and the turboing to end the game. They look like savants right now lol
Fran, Monkey, Crimson, Stan
And I thought the town at the end of Buffy was bad for lynching me and the turboing to end the game. They look like savants right now lol
Faddy
of, having, or involving transitory whims
Agreed Gorlak.
However NO ONE has said in this hour that Hecht was probably right. In fact Hecht hasn't been mentioned by name, just as "he". Come on town.
No you lied for no reason. And you weren't even close to solving the game either.
However NO ONE has said in this hour that Hecht was probably right. In fact Hecht hasn't been mentioned by name, just as "he". Come on town.
No you lied for no reason. And you weren't even close to solving the game either.
Faddy
of, having, or involving transitory whims
HAHAHAHA. You made a gambit, then got countered, then backed off. Like what was the point of lying if you weren't going to hold the lie?
And then you threw a tantrum and self voted. Good town play there.
And actually you did similar in this game too.
You are forgetting that if Muffin dies 2 more townies come back though, including a tracker.
Faddy
of, having, or involving transitory whims
@SweetNicole So do I have to WIFOM which gif is the joke gif. Or are both just heavy deflection tactics which is stupid because we are here to talk about mafia strategy and plays.
Faddy
of, having, or involving transitory whims
So did he kill Stan? Because that is a better kill imo.
He and Muffin both killed Stan
Damn, good catch, I don't think they will notice thoughCongrats Muffin you just played yourself
"What's more, if the neutral tries to kill scum with a NK early, he's outnumbered by town quite a bit. He doesn't necessarily need to go for scum first"
The 2 unconfirmed town are female.
Faddy
of, having, or involving transitory whims
I mean it isn't a smoking gun but it is a tell that Muffin is not thinking outwardly about a neutral.
Why?
Nah, its flavor, plus myotismon isnt in the game
Monkey is getting closer. Her resignation from the start was really frustrating especially after Hecht lynch. Just giving up is the worst :/
But she's pinned it down and rightfully called Sorian out for what he did the last phase with Hecht. Even now he's deflecting and can't talk against scum never touching him. This should be the main argument to take him down.
In all of this game with all the abilities we've seen... they still trust mechanics and checks which is ridiculous. Why does Fran want to look at faircure but not Sorian?
Why is no one checking when Sorian got his item? Huh? Was it the night when he was checked? Yeah. Could there be anything? Yes. But nobody bothers so far. Look back at the circumstances, how did that check happen?
You are losing the game by giving Sorian a free pass too easily. And this is without considering his behaviour at all.
But she's pinned it down and rightfully called Sorian out for what he did the last phase with Hecht. Even now he's deflecting and can't talk against scum never touching him. This should be the main argument to take him down.
In all of this game with all the abilities we've seen... they still trust mechanics and checks which is ridiculous. Why does Fran want to look at faircure but not Sorian?
Why is no one checking when Sorian got his item? Huh? Was it the night when he was checked? Yeah. Could there be anything? Yes. But nobody bothers so far. Look back at the circumstances, how did that check happen?
You are losing the game by giving Sorian a free pass too easily. And this is without considering his behaviour at all.
Am I completely off?
I don't see why you would question one "green check" and don't even look into the other... it's a bad omission, that will lead to a loss.
Muffin only defends himself (too much the last phases btw, if he'd been able to further hunt scum, his chances would be way better)
Monkey has a self-defeating attitude, but it seems like she might be the only hope to figure things out.
Faircure and Crimson cruise along, not pulling their weight :(
Fran is trying, but chose the wrong path phases ago.
And Sorian laughs and can totally townielike complain about the quietness.
If it was not for the absortion mechanic this would definitely go to scum here.
I don't see why you would question one "green check" and don't even look into the other... it's a bad omission, that will lead to a loss.
Muffin only defends himself (too much the last phases btw, if he'd been able to further hunt scum, his chances would be way better)
Monkey has a self-defeating attitude, but it seems like she might be the only hope to figure things out.
Faircure and Crimson cruise along, not pulling their weight :(
Fran is trying, but chose the wrong path phases ago.
And Sorian laughs and can totally townielike complain about the quietness.
If it was not for the absortion mechanic this would definitely go to scum here.
Faddy
of, having, or involving transitory whims
You are on the right track Gorlak. But the game has been going on for a while and it is dragging. Not surprised Fran just wants to Turbo, there isn't much discussion happening so why not just vote?
I mean it is still at least 3 phases before this game is over.
I mean it is still at least 3 phases before this game is over.
Last edited:
Muffin is a literal town pinata
And town gonna town lol
I had a moment reading this of "Oh my god, that would be amazing."
Then I remembered this game. lol
Faddy
of, having, or involving transitory whims
Sneaky Fran and his lack of commitment.
Looks like the B team just arrived :)
Faddy
of, having, or involving transitory whims
I saw some people get hyped for the spec thread so here is some spice.
I'm going to trash Fran for a second here, birthday or not. He has been hammering, too strong, muttering away that something is wrong with monkey's claim for 3 phases now. For me it is classic hedging. He isn't doing any work to prove his theory but wants it out there just in case he is right.
Well Fran you are wrong and bad.
I'm going to trash Fran for a second here, birthday or not. He has been hammering, too strong, muttering away that something is wrong with monkey's claim for 3 phases now. For me it is classic hedging. He isn't doing any work to prove his theory but wants it out there just in case he is right.
Well Fran you are wrong and bad.
Faddy
of, having, or involving transitory whims
If they get Sorian today it is basically game over. There will be no night kills. With 4 town alive they have enough to lynch both Sawneeks and L_P before the game ends.
Town has actually played really well in this game. They never got too tricky with their lynches and have hit 6/8 so far and might go 8/10.
Day 1: Silky 3rd party
Day 2: Nicole 3rd party
Day 3: Nin (there was a weird revive thing happening here too)
Day 4: Kalor 3rd party
Day 5: Natiko 3rd party
Day 6: *Splinter Mafia
Day 7: Hecht (a genuine mislynch)
Day 8: Muffin 3rd party
My favourite play was Terraforce outing to stay on Town and get his victory later. Good assessment on his own position and Town's position in the game.
I'm actually looking forward to the mafia thread. Seeing how well they understood what they were doing, if they had a plan etc.
@Geno can you say what happened on night 1, why did all those actions fail?
Town has actually played really well in this game. They never got too tricky with their lynches and have hit 6/8 so far and might go 8/10.
Day 1: Silky 3rd party
Day 2: Nicole 3rd party
Day 3: Nin (there was a weird revive thing happening here too)
Day 4: Kalor 3rd party
Day 5: Natiko 3rd party
Day 6: *Splinter Mafia
Day 7: Hecht (a genuine mislynch)
Day 8: Muffin 3rd party
My favourite play was Terraforce outing to stay on Town and get his victory later. Good assessment on his own position and Town's position in the game.
I'm actually looking forward to the mafia thread. Seeing how well they understood what they were doing, if they had a plan etc.
@Geno can you say what happened on night 1, why did all those actions fail?
Blargonaut
SCUM UP!
nigh on two hundred motherfucking pages
ebook this
Amazon it
goddamn
ebook this
Amazon it
goddamn