Spectator Thread The Command Center

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
Those are still a secret in here, actually. Buuuuuuuut you should totally post the guesses anyway!

Welcome btw, there's gonna be a lot of people shocked to find out you were Zordon. Including Kimberly.
I was VERY purposely trying to not be myself, which I had some practice doing after my first game at Mafia Universe. I think here it led to not-great play but hey, it was an adventure!
 

Sawneeks

little green dog
Zordon scum!

Man, not looking good for scum. 2 nights with no kills and 2 scum dead.
Scum is in a baaaad spot. They were shaky before this Day Phase but the second the Cop sent in the command for Zordon they were just in an even worse position.

Still think one of the Scum Players is in a relatively safe position actually. The other will likely be voted off the island at some point but it's not totally lost? Just...gonna be a hell of a time getting back. Which, while it sucks for Scum, has been interesting to watch from a Town side of things. Normally games are super one-side for Scum so having it turn out this way has been amazing. o:
 

Faddy

of, having, or involving transitory whims
I was VERY purposely trying to not be myself, which I had some practice doing after my first game at Mafia Universe. I think here it led to not-great play but hey, it was an adventure!

Has you MU game started? I checked the other day and didn't see your name in the active games.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
Scum is in a baaaad spot. They were shaky before this Day Phase but the second the Cop sent in the command for Zordon they were just in an even worse position.

Still think one of the Scum Players is in a relatively safe position actually. The other will likely be voted off the island at some point but it's not totally lost? Just...gonna be a hell of a time getting back. Which, while it sucks for Scum, has been interesting to watch from a Town side of things. Normally games are super one-side for Scum so having it turn out this way has been amazing. o:
Yeah, sadly I think town has this one in the bag. But scum will go down fighting!

Has you MU game started? I checked the other day and didn't see your name in the active games.
No, I start June 4, but I played a practice game, also as scum. RNG has been terrible to me lately.
 

Franconp

Frank
I see I was wrong on some since people are here but this was my list:

The ones I feel confidentish guessing-

4. [f] Rita Repulsa - Sophia

6. [m] Blue Ranger - Fran

7. [m] Green Ranger - empressdonna

10. [m] Bulk - Fran

11. [f] Trini - Ketkat

12. [m] Black Ranger - Apollo

14. [f] Kimberly - Gotham

15. [They/Them] Zack - Verelios or Brazil


17. [They/Them] Yellow Ranger - Kalor

19. [m] White Ranger original was cornbro

Goldar - LP

Pink Ranger Faddy

I'm there twice?

I thought I was really obvious. Who else would create a conspiracy theory D1 besides me and Lifeline?
 

Sawneeks

little green dog
I was VERY purposely trying to not be myself, which I had some practice doing after my first game at Mafia Universe. I think here it led to not-great play but hey, it was an adventure!
You did a really good job at that! Think I had one person get close to guessing who you were but that was about it, no one got you dead-on.

You played pretty good overall but something started to change around the end of Day 2. The play started to become disconnected almost, like you were less invested in it. Couple that with the very 'passive' style you had and it ended up turning around on you. Think that trio of Rita-Black Ranger-You really hurt as well.
 

Faddy

of, having, or involving transitory whims
Can I ask what was the reason for killing me. I felt in a REALLY bad spot after Jason flipped scum. Was fearing a lynch much more than a night kill at that point.
 
Scum is in a baaaad spot. They were shaky before this Day Phase but the second the Cop sent in the command for Zordon they were just in an even worse position.

Still think one of the Scum Players is in a relatively safe position actually. The other will likely be voted off the island at some point but it's not totally lost? Just...gonna be a hell of a time getting back. Which, while it sucks for Scum, has been interesting to watch from a Town side of things. Normally games are super one-side for Scum so having it turn out this way has been amazing. o:

Town is in an even better position when you think that this has effectively cleared 3 people on top of rac.

Kimberly checked Zordon but also said they have cleared Trini (?) and Green

So all 3 plus rac are basically as good as confirmed and gives Town other places to look at.
 

Faddy

of, having, or involving transitory whims
Town is in an even better position when you think that this has effectively cleared 3 people on top of rac.

Kimberly checked Zordon but also said they have cleared Trini (?) and Green

So all 3 plus rac are basically as good as confirmed and gives Town other places to look at.

One of those players could be a mafia godfather.
 
I wonder where they will begin looking next. Rita was close to being lynched the other day. But Kimberly's claim has taken the spotlight away from her. hmm...
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
ok, monkey could be black ranger. As much as she hates meta, she loves talking about meta.


Yeah, when you see this come at me, sis.
YOU DUMDUM

Meta is stupid unless it's necessary.

Sorry I went so hard on you, though, Stuart, it's just 'cause I was mafia. <3

You did a really good job at that! Think I had one person get close to guessing who you were but that was about it, no one got you dead-on.

You played pretty good overall but something started to change around the end of Day 2. The play started to become disconnected almost, like you were less invested in it. Couple that with the very 'passive' style you had and it ended up turning around on you. Think that trio of Rita-Black Ranger-You really hurt as well.
I'm in the middle of a big project and I have two articles due too so I guess it showed. :(

Can I ask what was the reason for killing me. I felt in a REALLY bad spot after Jason flipped scum. Was fearing a lynch much more than a night kill at that point.
You were Goldar? Someone thought you were a PR and we figured it would cause some chaos.
 
You were Goldar? Someone thought you were a PR and we figured it would cause some chaos.

Don't you mean finster? Since Goldar was lynched and Finster was the "WHY?"

Also Finster was Donna XD.

I did laugh at people not being able to guess me at the start. Though Rita I'm pretty sure could guess me based on her comment about Monopoly Mafia later on.
 

Faddy

of, having, or involving transitory whims
You were Goldar? Someone thought you were a PR and we figured it would cause some chaos.

I was Pink.

You tried to kill me night 2 but my amazing neutral powers got me the win. I called Jason scum on day 1 then switched off him, preventing his lynch then didn't vote for him on day 2.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
It's fine <3 I just didn't know how to deal with being under pressure hahaha.

It's all good
You got a good lesson XD

Don't you mean finster? Since Goldar was lynched and Finster was the "WHY?"

Also Finster was Donna XD.

I did laugh at people not being able to guess me at the start. Though Rita I'm pretty sure could guess me based on her comment about Monopoly Mafia later on.
Oh lord I got all twisted up. Yes, Finster was the one was thought might be a PR. Faddy, who were you?
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
I was Pink.

You tried to kill me night 2 but my amazing neutral powers got me the win. I called Jason scum on day 1 then switched off him, preventing his lynch then didn't vote for him on day 2.
YOU WROTE THE FEBE GUIDELINES! Nice job. We thought you wouldn't be covered and would be a safe target and also you were smart. Thought it might also throw suspicion on a few specific people.
 

Sawneeks

little green dog
Wondering if Scum will get lynched today though. Depending on how deep people went in on researching Zordon's posts one of them miiiiight get caught. Knowing Town though they'll throw it on a Townie and get stubborn about it. :p
 

Sawneeks

little green dog
Welcome rac <3

Surprised you lived so long to be honest. You are the best Red Ranger though, let nobody tell you otherwise.

Hmm...

Besides Zordon and Jason. Tommy and Yellow Ranger?

(I assume since it's speculation, no spoiler tags needed)

Or maybe Yellow and Blue.

Yellow is a sticking point right now without knowing who scum is lol.

All good guesses. o:

The Scum players here can reveal their partners if they want to, my lips will stay sealed. :3
 
n_n

how so?

Asking it right away like that makes me feel like he was scum and wanted to keep Kimberly around for later. (ie if one of the two remaining is a Godfather).

idk, just suspicious with how quickly he asked that (also annoyed me cause it's not hard to read back and see the whole 3 shot thing aka no more shots left)

i thought monkey was black too

Sorry to disappoint :P
 

rac

whatever
rac this is for you later

why'd you pick the day when melon and i are both busy

u boob
i have no idea how people jumped on me like that and i got spooked

i guess i couldve tried to hold onto it but i was sure that scum was in there somewhere

also im disappointed i misspelt waste, ill blame my phone
 
Oh yeah. Another thought for who is scum:

Alpha 5 and Yellow

I forgot, I had thought Alpha 5 for a while and nothing has changed to make me consider otherwise.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
Okay, that's fair.

It was SUPER WEIRD using dude pronouns by the way. I kept having to remind myself not to yell at people.
 

Sawneeks

little green dog
i have no idea how people jumped on me like that and i got spooked

i guess i couldve tried to hold onto it but i was sure that scum was in there somewhere

also im disappointed i misspelt waste, ill blame my phone

nah, I'm just giving you shit. :>

It was weird how fast people jumped on you though. You essentially walked in the door just to be dogpilled by everyone.

is this only because i hammered last day?
did people save me?

also yes. because people should've hammered that and i'm glad someone did.
you were protected one Night but you were not the Kill target.
 
I'm kinda on Tommys side on this. His replacement can't do much against stuff his predecessor did so it seems unfair to judge him on that.
 

cabot

Why.
Nah, replacing into a scummy player is on you to fix, it's part of what to expect when signing up as a sub.

This game is a little different in that no one can work off who the players are, which means they only have to go with what's in the thread. Makes it a little bit more difficult.


Far as I can see, Tommy replacement hasn't done much to quell fears from his suspicious predecessor.
 

Sawneeks

little green dog
Is Zack role playing today?

I'd guess yes but I have no idea as who.

Nah, replacing into a scummy player is on you to fix, it's part of what to expect when signing up as a sub.

Def agree that it's just part of being a sub unfortunately. Not sure if it's really on the replacement to fix though, there's almost nothing they can do about the person they replaced and how they played.
 

cabot

Why.
I'd guess yes but I have no idea as who.



Def agree that it's just part of being a sub unfortunately. Not sure if it's really on the replacement to fix though, there's almost nothing they can do about the person they replaced and how they played.

they can fix it by not being scummy themselves.
 

Faddy

of, having, or involving transitory whims
I'd guess yes but I have no idea as who.



Def agree that it's just part of being a sub unfortunately. Not sure if it's really on the replacement to fix though, there's almost nothing they can do about the person they replaced and how they played.

They are cosplaying as you Sawneeks :3

Dunno how you missed it.
 

Sawneeks

little green dog
I know I thought Zack was scum earlier but his recent days have made me think Town. His latest post included...

If he really is cosplaying as me.....gonna brand the Official Sawneeks Town Style (patent pending) for all your townie point needs. Works for Scum or Town!

they can fix it by not being scummy themselves.

Easier said than done, friendo.

They are cosplaying as you Sawneeks :3

Dunno how you missed it.

It didn't hit me until this:

They actually never finished typing their Yellow read, which is something I've done once or twice during my loooooong (>.>) streak of games as Scum when I'd be extremely carefully choosin' my words of a read on a teammate.

Do...do i really use ':3' that much??
 

rac

whatever
what i dont get is why i was killed, not like i was playing great

there is also 2 other people that are cleared, and even then id kill zack before anybody else

unless that means zack is scum
 

cabot

Why.
killing the other two cleared further cements Kimberly as Town. There still is a lingering doubt there currently.

As for killing Zack before any semi-confirmed players, after the no kill nights, they really had to cut down on the players town could trust.
 

Faddy

of, having, or involving transitory whims
Is Rita actually BP?

cause her role smelled of BS when I remember it being brought up.

You're just tilted because Nicole told the exact same story in Buffy.

I did not get a vest night 1, but I was also blocked in some way.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
What I love right now is
that Zack in particular is unpacking all sorts of seeds I did not purposely leave and I hope some of them bear fruit.
 
Heymonkey, are you as impressed as I am with how scum team is working through today and getting their gameplan on for future days?
 

Faddy

of, having, or involving transitory whims
you sure were, buddy

I would have been more mad but you guys killed Finster who I was trying to check and they were then confirmed not Fireblend so I didn't lose info.

If it happened 2 nights in a row I would have been tilted.
 
Last edited:

Sawneeks

little green dog
Welcome Yellow Ranger! Maybe Town will one day realize that being defensive is not always a scumtell..

Is Rita actually BP?

cause her role smelled of BS when I remember it being brought up.

You're just tilted because Nicole told the exact same story in Buffy.

I did not get a vest night 1, but I was also blocked in some way.

You did get a vest, actually. Part of Rita's role is the recipient is unaware they are now BP.
 

Sawneeks

little green dog
Also keep flip-flopping on this but I love how this game hasn't been one-sided. Mafia has lost people, Town has lost people, it hasn't been a clean sweep for one side the entire game. Half the time I'm either expecting Town to win and the other, like now, I'm expecting Scum to pull through with a crazy win.

it's GREAT
 

Sawneeks

little green dog
Also to go back on what I said much earlier in this thread, Town's play has been a bit rocky but they have been pulling through with some solid work.

One thing I've definitely noticed is that Scum don't typically do something out-right Scummy. Take Yellow Ranger for instance, everyone called the defense scummy and he ended up Town. Scum usually hide in the Not-Quite-Scummy-But-Not-Town area and their actions reflect that. They are just don't feel Town despite the amount of posts but aren't doing something blatantly scummy either. They care more about their reputation/persona than Town does and likely won't be making big shows of themselves.
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
Also to go back on what I said much earlier in this thread, Town's play has been a bit rocky but they have been pulling through with some solid work.

One thing I've definitely noticed is that Scum don't typically do something out-right Scummy. Take Yellow Ranger for instance, everyone called the defense scummy and he ended up Town. Scum usually hide in the Not-Quite-Scummy-But-Not-Town area and their actions reflect that. They are just don't feel Town despite the amount of posts but aren't doing something blatantly scummy either. They care more about their reputation/persona than Town does and likely won't be making big shows of themselves.
Yep, same thing I said to you in chat, too - town doesn't KNOW so is also more likely to make stupid votes or stupid moves. Scum KNOWS, so is less likely to do the weird thing. It's why I'm always taken aback when someone says being uncertain is scummy.
 

Faddy

of, having, or involving transitory whims
Welcome Yellow Ranger! Maybe Town will one day realize that being defensive is not always a scumtell..

You did get a vest, actually. Part of Rita's role is the recipient is unaware they are now BP.

Oh god. I really was top town on Day 1. Protected by town, blocked by mafia.
 

Sawneeks

little green dog
Yep, same thing I said to you in chat, too - town doesn't KNOW so is also more likely to make stupid votes or stupid moves. Scum KNOWS, so is less likely to do the weird thing. It's why I'm always taken aback when someone says being uncertain is scummy.

There is a bit of an issue where being uncertain is a scumtell....if it comes to reading your teammates. Seen a good amount of Scum make very flip-floppy reads on teammates because they always want to be ready to bus at any point.

Oh god. I really was top town on Day 1. Protected by town, blocked by mafia.

You were very popular. :p
 

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
There is a bit of an issue where being uncertain is a scumtell....if it comes to reading your teammates. Seen a good amount of Scum make very flip-floppy reads on teammates because they always want to be ready to bus at any point.
blah blah blah blah
 

Jason

Costume Account
Totally logged in to check out day start and forgot that I’m a time zone over this week... another 50 minutes to wait
 

Faddy

of, having, or involving transitory whims
They didn't try to kill the Doctor... huh.

Mafia don't know if doctor can self protect.

If I had to guess the unclaimed night 1 is a self save, or it at least brings up the possibility. Mafia might feel the restriction is that the doctor can't protect the same person on consecutive nights. And they have green checks to lynch in Trini to lynch.

Mafia is never going to get a mislynch on Tommy, especially with two deathless nights.

Who is Zack today? Hecht maybe?
 
Billy isn't scum right?

Because him being scum is the only reason I can see someone push for a Doctor lynch.

If they lynch the Doctor then scum deserves to win.
 

cabot

Why.
Yep, same thing I said to you in chat, too - town doesn't KNOW so is also more likely to make stupid votes or stupid moves. Scum KNOWS, so is less likely to do the weird thing. It's why I'm always taken aback when someone says being uncertain is scummy.

being uncertain is definitely scummy because people can clam up when they know they're mislynching.


It's not a be-all end all scumtell, but its not nothing either.
 

cabot

Why.
I'm generally against lynching doctors since about 90% of mafia games have one, so this is frustrating to read. No counter claim means it's likely true.


Tommy gave too much info regarding his protections. That's about the most powerful thing a doctor has when scum don't have a counter anymore.
 
Top Bottom