Scum Thread Game of Thrones Scum Thread - You Win Or You Die

Include

Include

Extreme Tactician said:
Include, who do you think we should kill?
Click to expand...
I think GP is a good kill as he is the only confirmed dude and it may create chaos with no one trusting anyone anymore.

But I have requested a replacement as my real life is too much for me right now to be able to handle playing the game as well.

Ultimately since I may or may not get replaced I would like it to be your choice to make not mine. I am way too disconnected right now for me to be able to think properly.
 
Extreme Tactician

Extreme Tactician

Include said:
I think GP is a good kill as he is the only confirmed dude and it may create chaos with no one trusting anyone anymore.

But I have requested a replacement as my real life is too much for me right now to be able to handle playing the game as well.

Ultimately since I may or may not get replaced I would like it to be your choice to make not mine. I am way too disconnected right now for me to be able to think properly.
Click to expand...
I see.

Ugh, this is so hard. I've never been the lone mafia alive before.
 
Include

Include

Extreme Tactician said:
Well, I've reread the thread. I just think Flatearthpandas is too dangerous alive. He's too active and he spawns discussions.

KILL: Flatearthpandas
Click to expand...
Alright, he is the only one actively pursuing you and if it can help getting him out from the picture for you to be able to have some breathing room then so be it. Though just like meatwad with appolo kill you may get accused of it, so prepare for that.

I hope Fantomas will tunnel nin and Kawl. Kopite will still go after me or the person who replaces me.

That leaves GP, Kawl and nin. Nin wants you out, Kawl has no say for now. So it all comes to GP. Did he ever wants you out or not?
 
dragon mom

dragon mom

Plays the Game of Chairs
Scum have been lynched the past three days, there was a fake red check on splinter that ended up getting two townies lynched, nin and Kawl are the other two new replacements.

Game is in the final days.
 
SweetNicole

SweetNicole

I saw that you were looking at claiming here. It sounds like we'll probably need to claim? I am not sure what would be a good claim at this point. Maybe vanilla? I can play off that I don't want to claim until I have a chance to review the game in more detail, which could let you delay claiming longer.
 
Extreme Tactician

Extreme Tactician

SweetNicole said:
I saw that you were looking at claiming here. It sounds like we'll probably need to claim? I am not sure what would be a good claim at this point. Maybe vanilla? I can play off that I don't want to claim until I have a chance to review the game in more detail, which could let you delay claiming longer.
Click to expand...
Also, I plan on claiming something like vigilante or investigator.
 
SweetNicole

SweetNicole

I think nin or kewl at the obvious safe lynches today, but we absolutely need to kill Fant/Kopite/GP tonight.

Of those, I'd lean towards either Kopite or Fant.

also, I'm going to press you hard later on that town read list you posted @Extreme Tactician
 
SweetNicole

SweetNicole

It will be easy to chain into nin tomorrow.

ET you will need to be active.

The question is does GP have a self-shot or can he shoot others? That makes a difference if we shoot for Kopite or GP. Either way, Fant is the weakest and should be left alive for now.
 
SweetNicole

SweetNicole

nin
Extreme Tatician
SweetNicole
Giant Panda/Kopite
fantomas

Tomorrow is LyLo, they have to lynch either ET or myself or they lose

as we can get a night kill tonight and one of the night kill is someone in the circle of trust that isn't fant, we can win this game easily
 
SweetNicole

SweetNicole

Really just need to figure out if we're shooting Giant Panda or Kopite

On the one hand, killing Giant Panda would leave Kopite free to go after nin. On the other hand, it would be extremely easy to paint Kopite's last post as the reason for killing nin. In which case, we could easily play that nin is scum, and win off of nin.
 
SweetNicole

SweetNicole

I'm a 3-shot protector. I've used two shots. I decided to use 2 of my shots earlier on in the game, so that I'd reduce the chances of me getting killed while I still had spare shots left over. That would be a waste of a strong town ability.

Night 2 I protected Faddy as he was by far the most confirmed town, though I later learned I was really protecting myself due to Faddy's redirect. I've been dropping hints about this for a while, but I think it is much more likely that Faddy was targeted N2 than GoG was or that GoG was the killer. However, this only absolves GoG of the biggest reason for which she's been targeted so far. She could still well be scum, but I think the only convincing case is one that doesn't rely on the N2 jailing. If my theory is right, scum will have been wondering who saved Faddy N2 while at the same time trying to play up the GoG case to try to push an easy lynch.

You'll see in the thread that on day 3 I did briefly entertain the scum GoG theory. I did this because I didn't want to make it obvious that I was the protector, and because GoG wasn't in particular danger of being lynched so I thought there were no harm. Recently though I've had to become more forcibly anti-GoG lynch as it picked up in popularity.

After seeing the deathless N2, I figured I had scared scum off targeting Faddy again. So for N3 I decided to protect the next most town read person, despite me not being as sure: Fantomas. But as we saw scum targeted Faddy again (well probably again).

Night 4, I didn't use my ability because we had more confirmed town or heavily read town, so chances were much lower that I'd pick to protect the same player that scum chose to kill. I figured it was best to save my last shot for the potential late game scenario. Suspicion of me was starting to pick up anyway so I figured I'd be an unlikely scum kill, and if worst came to worst and I became a lynch target, I could claim that day, and then use my last shot on the same night that scum would first know to target me.
Click to expand...
 
Extreme Tactician

Extreme Tactician

SweetNicole said:
@Extreme Tactician It's ok, you're going to have to lay it on thick during the next day phase.
Click to expand...
I'll definitely be more active. I've been relying too much on goodwil from almost being lynched.
SweetNicole said:
Really just need to figure out if we're shooting Giant Panda or Kopite

On the one hand, killing Giant Panda would leave Kopite free to go after nin. On the other hand, it would be extremely easy to paint Kopite's last post as the reason for killing nin. In which case, we could easily play that nin is scum, and win off of nin.
Click to expand...
I think Giant Panda is more dangerous, and I don't think He would have used her ability yesterday. Yes, he had a confirmed role, but at the same time he didn't have a lot of posts contributing to discussion.
 
SweetNicole

SweetNicole

He claimed that ability on day five. That means they were would have been four nights prior for them to use it. Are we sure they didn't use it on night five? night six? night seven? night eight?

I'd say we kill Giant Panda either way
 
Extreme Tactician

Extreme Tactician

SweetNicole said:
He claimed that ability on day five. That means they were would have been four nights prior for them to use it. Are we sure they didn't use it on night five? night six? night seven? night eight?

I'd say we kill Giant Panda either way
Click to expand...
Well, if he was paranoid he would have used the ability way before.
At this point, if we fail the kill, it'll be so much harder to win. But if we succeed...
We win.
I'm ok with your plan.
 
SweetNicole

SweetNicole

@Extreme Tactician the general plan is we get one of the other town players to vote for someone, and then we immediately hammer

so if kopite, fant, or nin vote for someone that isn't us, we immediately hammer that person and win
 
SweetNicole

SweetNicole

If we see someone do this, wait to follow up until we're both free

if one of us tries to hammer and the other doesn't we're fucked
 
SweetNicole

SweetNicole

so gameplan:
  • throw suspicion at everyone
  • wait for one of them to vote for another player that isn't us
  • check here to make sure we're both free
  • once we both are, hammer back to back
 
SweetNicole

SweetNicole

Kopite said:
Lets just do it then
Vote: nin

If Nicole is scum though i think we've lost unfortunately.
Click to expand...

giphy.gif
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom