OK, but how do we feel about melon?EzekelRAGE said:I am strongly against lynching Zeke specifically.
I think they believe the lies
Can the next MafiEra game have a role called 'Fantomas the Immortal'?
this shocks me considering who is scum. They talk about it a lot that they won't fall for him again...
Immortal innocent child, surely? The ULTIMATE confirmed townie!Can the next MafiEra game have a role called 'Fantomas the Immortal'?
Well, Natiko is who is more convinced by Sorian, Monkey kinda reluctantly agrees/follows, LP is concerned with surviving D8 somehow
What happens if a townie is night killed the same night it is recruited?
Is their flip striked?
Do they win with town or cult?
It would be hilarious if that happens to blarg
I'm recruiting for 2nd Town who wants in
Scum reads for the Cult are all over the place. They've basically deduced monkey is Scum at this point but only one of them thinks it's Nat and the other thinks it's LP. Recruit hasn't been discussed too much yet but the target that was put forward would end badly for them so fingers crossed it changes...
??uhh?
why would a target be bad for them? As long as they skip scum and FB they would recruit successfully
They could be hitting scum tonight
the way I understood it I thought she said they think the scumteam is Monkey + Natiko or LP, so they would avoid those 3 altogether
At this point I think Sorian could claim 'Cultmaster' and people still wouldn't lynch him.
This has been a bad day phase
Please cut the players some slack. Have you ever been wrong in mafia? Have you believed his lies before?
Why?That line should give him away immediately.
Why?
So he lied about getting info from Grizzly. How does _that_ make him cult? He could still be neutral trying to save his ass with lies. We just know he isn't.
I think it's now both cult and scum interest to let febe win - that would push D8 to nine players.
Yes, but we are long past this point. Monkey's shielding during the Brazil shizzle helped him tremendously. Again, he wanted to lynch Brazil/Fandorin for the lulz/quicker endgame. That's your lynch reason right there. It's just everyone believes him. No one looked back since.But they really should have caught Sorian by now - this is town hooker level.
Nah, that doesn't include every scenario. 4 cult, 2 scum and 1 town can still result in a scum win.What is the cults wincon btw? same as Scum? Hold majority voting power?
He deserves it!.
What is the cults wincon btw? same as Scum? Hold majority voting power?
Yes, but we are long past this point. Monkey's shielding during the Brazil shizzle helped him tremendously. Again, he wanted to lynch Brazil/Fandorin for the lulz/quicker endgame. That's your lynch reason right there. It's just everyone believes him. No one looked back since.
Saying he has revealed himself now isn't true though.
Hold majority and have scum killed.
That said, if it becomes apparent scum has no way of winning (4 cult vs 2 scum for example) I'll end it earlier.
It's more about thinking logically - would the game have three neutral factions, one of them potentially causing multiple kills and one being the cult? Nah, somebody haw to be lying, and febe isn't cult for sure after killing malus.
Game might pass the HvV post count
Town has been done for quite some time now. Even if they had avoided the malus “lynch” last phase and Febe shot scum too, town would still need to get 5 lynches right to wipe both the cult and mafia out. That if they didn’t pick any modifier that gave more shots to the cult, like it just happened.Watching town die a slow death is always rough. This is giving me Conspiracy mafia vibes
I was thinking with endgame discussion after there might be a chance but I guess yeah maybe not.Nah, never going to happen. The game is in the endgame now (I expect it to end by the end of D9), and it's still lagging like over 65 pages behind.
Town has been done for quite some time now. Even if they had avoided the malus “lynch” last phase and Febe shot scum too, town would still need to get 5 lynches right to wipe both the cult and mafia out. That if they didn’t pick any modifier that gave more shots to the cult, like it just happened.
Barring some cult members getting NK’ed, for town to win we would have to go to at least D11.
Because there is enough WIFOM already to die several times from alcoholic poisoning
rac said:alright fanto let me help you out
Fantomas listen here, don't get distracted by everyone elserac said:t this point i would either go after monkey or lp
Is there any indication that the modifiers have helped the cult? They have bought Sorian's fake claim, don't think they could connect the dots on that.Why is nobody considering the idea of modifiers being connected to the cult?
Listen to this man!Blargonaut said:If anyone is the goddamn Cult Leader it's Sorian
what monkey and maybe natiko will attempt could backfire spectacularly if dark souls is chosen...
Please cut the players some slack. Have you ever been wrong in mafia? Have you believed his lies before?
From their POV everyone could be cult, no? Yes, yes mistakes were made, certain lynches not chosen, but it is what it is. And after weeks in this madhouse a hidden agenda is revealed. So sitting here and pointing fingers is easy, but being in the game is not. We've all been there. Crawling back is very time consuming, throwing your entire readlist out the window is hard. You can see the frustration with certain peeps, and more than half the players are _not_ trying to solve the game. Try to symphatize a bit more.
We've all been wrong. We've all been down the rabbithole. Let's cherish the people we love to watch/play with.
PS: Kudos to Blarg. He's blatantly trying to be converted there ;)
It would backfire 100% the moment players decide to actually test the claim.
Sorian claimed Grizzly, who is Kyan?
Depending on how this all ends I think Scum are going to need a hug tooI think every Townie here needs a long hug from the community after the game is over.
you might need to go into hiding when that happens :pInstead they are stuck on the idea cult recruits only vanillas. I assume I will be eaten alive once Flux is revealed
Hmmmm, Cult are debating the recruitment shot for tonight but I'm gonna keep that a secret for now. It'll be fun. :p
MmmHecht
Mmm
Retro was fakeclaimed by faddy, monkey, Pedro, sawneeks are either flipped already or scum fakeclaims
Who else could be a "game reviewer who hates bastard games" if kyan flips but grizzly/sorian?
Maybe cult should had been given 2 fakeclaims