Spectator Thread Doctor Who This Ain't - Spectator Thread

Faddy

of, having, or involving transitory whims
This game was interesting but it is a shame Sorian is going to be modkilled for dissing Carly Rae Jepsen.
 

turmoil7

Imperial Corps Commander Who Cheers the Army
Now is the moment for ceecee to reveal he was actually telling the truth about the 3 shots
 

turmoil7

Imperial Corps Commander Who Cheers the Army
this shocks me considering who is scum. They talk about it a lot that they won't fall for him again...
Well, Natiko is who is more convinced by Sorian, Monkey kinda reluctantly agrees/follows, LP is concerned with surviving D8 somehow
 

turmoil7

Imperial Corps Commander Who Cheers the Army
What happens if a townie is night killed the same night it is recruited?

Is their flip striked?

Do they win with town or cult?

It would be hilarious if that happens to blarg
 

The Bear

Obligatory Gay Bear of the Society
What happens if a townie is night killed the same night it is recruited?

Is their flip striked?

Do they win with town or cult?

It would be hilarious if that happens to blarg

Recruit is the last thing to happen during night. So they would flip as town.
 

Chuggernaut

HONK HONK MF
If I was still in this game I think I would start pretending to be a cultist just to see what Blarg would actually do if a cultist came forward lol
 

turmoil7

Imperial Corps Commander Who Cheers the Army
laughjnk1m.gif
 

Sawneeks

little green dog
Scum reads for the Cult are all over the place. They've basically deduced monkey is Scum at this point but only one of them thinks it's Nat and the other thinks it's LP. Recruit hasn't been discussed too much yet but the target that was put forward would end badly for them so fingers crossed it changes...
 

turmoil7

Imperial Corps Commander Who Cheers the Army
Scum reads for the Cult are all over the place. They've basically deduced monkey is Scum at this point but only one of them thinks it's Nat and the other thinks it's LP. Recruit hasn't been discussed too much yet but the target that was put forward would end badly for them so fingers crossed it changes...
uhh?
 

Sawneeks

little green dog
the way I understood it I thought she said they think the scumteam is Monkey + Natiko or LP, so they would avoid those 3 altogether
That's right but they only think there is two scum left, not 3. Someone is trying to push Nat as a recruit target after his tunnel on me 'likely wasn't scum drive'. :p
 

The Bear

Obligatory Gay Bear of the Society
So judging by all threads what's going to happen is:

The game lynches town.
The scum nightkills town.
The cult tries to recruit scum and fails.

Everybody loses!
 
Please cut the players some slack. Have you ever been wrong in mafia? Have you believed his lies before?

From their POV everyone could be cult, no? Yes, yes mistakes were made, certain lynches not chosen, but it is what it is. And after weeks in this madhouse a hidden agenda is revealed. So sitting here and pointing fingers is easy, but being in the game is not. We've all been there. Crawling back is very time consuming, throwing your entire readlist out the window is hard. You can see the frustration with certain peeps, and more than half the players are _not_ trying to solve the game. Try to symphatize a bit more.

We've all been wrong. We've all been down the rabbithole. Let's cherish the people we love to watch/play with.

PS: Kudos to Blarg. He's blatantly trying to be converted there ;)
 
Please cut the players some slack. Have you ever been wrong in mafia? Have you believed his lies before?

I'm going to go with no on this.

Before finding out about the cult, sure.

But today, this day phase.

Where he has said "I asked bear privately and he said neutrals can't be recruited"

No. That line should give him away immediately.
 

Why would the gamerunner give away crucial mechanic details about someone else's role to someone who is unrelated to said role.

That's bastard levels, especially when Bear has said in the thread that he can't answer stuff like that when asked publicly. Giving away info like that to a player privately would be unfair.
 
So he lied about getting info from Grizzly. How does _that_ make him cult? He could still be neutral trying to save his ass with lies. We just know he isn't.
 
So he lied about getting info from Grizzly. How does _that_ make him cult? He could still be neutral trying to save his ass with lies. We just know he isn't.

Liars get lynched, especially when they are going against the interests of town.

Hell I'd argue it'd be worth policy lynching him for that but how dedicated he is to the lie would make me think either scum or neutral. Not town.
 

The Bear

Obligatory Gay Bear of the Society
I think it's now both cult and scum interest to let febe win - that would push D8 to nine players.
 
Also is Fanto finally going to be put out of his misery?

I kinda want to see him alive tomorrow just for the lols :P (Sorry Fanto :P )
 
But they really should have caught Sorian by now - this is town hooker level.
Yes, but we are long past this point. Monkey's shielding during the Brazil shizzle helped him tremendously. Again, he wanted to lynch Brazil/Fandorin for the lulz/quicker endgame. That's your lynch reason right there. It's just everyone believes him. No one looked back since.

Saying he has revealed himself now isn't true though.
 

The Bear

Obligatory Gay Bear of the Society
He deserves it!.

What is the cults wincon btw? same as Scum? Hold majority voting power?

Hold majority and have scum killed.

That said, if it becomes apparent scum has no way of winning (4 cult vs 2 scum for example) I'll end it earlier.
 

The Bear

Obligatory Gay Bear of the Society
Yes, but we are long past this point. Monkey's shielding during the Brazil shizzle helped him tremendously. Again, he wanted to lynch Brazil/Fandorin for the lulz/quicker endgame. That's your lynch reason right there. It's just everyone believes him. No one looked back since.

Saying he has revealed himself now isn't true though.

It's more about thinking logically - would the game have three neutral factions, one of them potentially causing multiple kills and one being the cult? Nah, somebody haw to be lying, and febe isn't cult for sure after killing malus.
 
Hold majority and have scum killed.

That said, if it becomes apparent scum has no way of winning (4 cult vs 2 scum for example) I'll end it earlier.

Cool. Sounds good.

It's more about thinking logically - would the game have three neutral factions, one of them potentially causing multiple kills and one being the cult? Nah, somebody haw to be lying, and febe isn't cult for sure after killing malus.

Killing malus and causing Saw to be revealed revealing the cult's existence.

As nice as it may have been for Febe to hit scum, this at least revealed the cult. I can only imagine how freaked people would be if it was revealed much later haha.
 

weemadarthur

Mad as in angry, or mad as in crazy?
I’m surprised to see mafia that big with fireblend’s role also in.

Now febe is the one cult hunting lol. Maybe he’ll put some work in and guide some other team to victory and then still lose? Aww.
 
Watching town die a slow death is always rough. This is giving me Conspiracy mafia vibes
Town has been done for quite some time now. Even if they had avoided the malus “lynch” last phase and Febe shot scum too, town would still need to get 5 lynches right to wipe both the cult and mafia out. That if they didn’t pick any modifier that gave more shots to the cult, like it just happened.

Barring some cult members getting NK’ed, for town to win we would have to go to at least D11.
 
Nah, never going to happen. The game is in the endgame now (I expect it to end by the end of D9), and it's still lagging like over 65 pages behind.
I was thinking with endgame discussion after there might be a chance but I guess yeah maybe not.
 

The Bear

Obligatory Gay Bear of the Society
Town has been done for quite some time now. Even if they had avoided the malus “lynch” last phase and Febe shot scum too, town would still need to get 5 lynches right to wipe both the cult and mafia out. That if they didn’t pick any modifier that gave more shots to the cult, like it just happened.

Barring some cult members getting NK’ed, for town to win we would have to go to at least D11.

Scum needs to start to NK cult if they want to win.
 

Alexem

Yeah, I'm town
So this is the way the game ends - not with a bang, but with a *truffleshuffle*. (Also- yikes at Monkey's place. Hope all's going OK there.)
 

saenima

Not Aeleus
The cult revelation really broke Town, especially Fantomas :( i feel his pain.

That being said, them not even looking Sorian's way is really weird. Only thing he has is a very flimsy and unprovable claim, while the existence of so many 'special' neutrals makes no sense, from what i understand. He should be cult suspect number 1, period.

At least Blarg was looking at him, even if half his posts make no sense lol
 

Verelios

Were-elios
I tried to think of how town could possibly win and I'm coming up with nothing barring successive failures by scum and cult. That's a damn shame.
 

turmoil7

Imperial Corps Commander Who Cheers the Army
"If anyone is the goddamn Cult Leader it's Sorian, absbro fuckin' rumbled him as a PR"

thanksyou.gif
 

turmoil7

Imperial Corps Commander Who Cheers the Army
what monkey and maybe natiko will attempt could backfire spectacularly if dark souls is chosen...
 

Chuggernaut

HONK HONK MF
Please cut the players some slack. Have you ever been wrong in mafia? Have you believed his lies before?

From their POV everyone could be cult, no? Yes, yes mistakes were made, certain lynches not chosen, but it is what it is. And after weeks in this madhouse a hidden agenda is revealed. So sitting here and pointing fingers is easy, but being in the game is not. We've all been there. Crawling back is very time consuming, throwing your entire readlist out the window is hard. You can see the frustration with certain peeps, and more than half the players are _not_ trying to solve the game. Try to symphatize a bit more.

We've all been wrong. We've all been down the rabbithole. Let's cherish the people we love to watch/play with.

PS: Kudos to Blarg. He's blatantly trying to be converted there ;)

Trust me, I get it. Most of them are super lost and I do feel for that. I am still baffled by how they aren’t lynching Sorian, but I can see where they’re coming from with most of their reads. It’s still hard to watch them slowly plummet towards death though.
 

turmoil7

Imperial Corps Commander Who Cheers the Army
Not posted yet in the game thread

Monkey has asked if anyone but her received a pm by grizzly on star wars

they will probably claim loved and hated modifiers
 

Sawneeks

little green dog
Hmmmm, Cult are debating the recruitment shot for tonight but I'm gonna keep that a secret for now. It'll be fun. :p
 

Sawneeks

little green dog
If LP gets flipped it should be obvious Monkey is Scum at this point, she's blatantly ignoring him from being in the running.
 

turmoil7

Imperial Corps Commander Who Cheers the Army
Mmm

Retro was fakeclaimed by faddy, monkey, Pedro, sawneeks are either flipped already or scum fakeclaims

Who else could be a "game reviewer who hates bastard games" if kyan flips but grizzly/sorian?

Maybe cult should had been given 2 fakeclaims
 

The Bear

Obligatory Gay Bear of the Society
Mmm

Retro was fakeclaimed by faddy, monkey, Pedro, sawneeks are either flipped already or scum fakeclaims

Who else could be a "game reviewer who hates bastard games" if kyan flips but grizzly/sorian?

Maybe cult should had been given 2 fakeclaims

There's at least Palmer and Rover as possible reviewers.
 
Top Bottom