Costume Party |OT| The Mafia Mash

[Zombie]

This must be a boring game to watch because we’ve kind of killed towns enthusiasm, but making town kill their own town core is fun

 

[Natiko]

Please do not post in the game thread after night ends. I will start locking the thread from now on.

 

[Natiko]

Actions lock in ~70 minutes.

 

[Natiko]

Crowd: Wow... killing a baby..... this got dark. I don't like this party anymore.

Baby has died!

Welcome to Costume Party Mafia!

You are dressed as a Baby, a Jailer.

During the night, you can target a player using the command Jail: <PLAYER NAME> to stop them from performing any action on the same night, while also stopping any action to be performed on them. You can't target yourself, and you can't target the same player in consecutive nights. You also have the ability to vote.

You are aligned with Town and win when all threats to Town have been eliminated.

Game thread is HERE

DAY 4 BEGINS

Day 4 Ends In:

Majority is 7

 

[Barney]

This must be a boring game to watch because we’ve kind of killed towns enthusiasm, but making town kill their own town core is fun

 

[Minecraft Steve]

post stupid things, we find scum.

Vote: ZOmbie

 

[Zombie]

.

 

[Jack Sparrow]

This must be a boring game to watch because we’ve kind of killed towns enthusiasm, but making town kill their own town core is fun

Someone call Arnold because it’s turbo time
Vote: Zombie

 

[Barney]

View attachment 110.

I really needed this today.

 

[Zombie]

Lol what a dumb slip. You fool. You absolute idiot.
Vote: Zombie

 

[Barney]

No need to turbo just yet, but I had a chat with my new friend last night and we agreed that probably Prisoner is the most suspect on the way Day 1 voting happened:

It was Prisoner who decided to start another wagon on Bob Ross.

Prisoner saved himself here: https://www.outermafia.com/index.php?threads/499/page-7#post-86979

Witch voted zombie here: https://www.outermafia.com/index.php?threads/499/page-7#post-86987

And it endedlike this: https://www.outermafia.com/index.php?threads/499/page-8#post-87016

MS and me tried to vote zombie out

That leaves Spider-Man on Bob Ross, Obama and Cinderella on Prisoner, as for people not on any of the drac or zombie wagon.

 

[Bob Ross]

I would've never guessed Zombie. Scum that scum has caught: 2, scum town has caught:0. Ny reads are shit this game.

 

[Minecraft Steve]

rest in peace baby,

@Barney, If today wasn't kinda clear cut, I could have gotten behind a prisoner vote. honestly though I find it hard to believe that day 1 was S v S v S, (despite my pretty clear scum read on prisoner).

 

[Witch]

Are you kidding me Zombie lol

 

[Barney]

rest in peace baby,

@Barney, If today wasn't kinda clear cut, I could have gotten behind a prisoner vote. honestly though I find it hard to believe that day 1 was S v S v S, (despite my pretty clear scum read on prisoner).

Town had a similar discussion about how Day 1 couldn't be S v S yet here we are

Because of how sudden the zombie vote was I don't think Witch is scum, I don't see a scum-witch following another train on a fellow scummate on a whim.

The prisoner train also didn't gain traction, of the four mentioned on my post (Spider, Obama and Cinderella), I think Spider is the most suspect, but I also find it weird just how unwilling prisoner was of voting drak to save himself.

 

[Zombie]

You know what I take it back. I don’t apologize. Yeah, I killed town. You think I did it for fun? No we did it because we were under threat. Because if we didn’t you would kill all of us. I was forced to help kill my own friend just to blend in with you absolute monsters.

We could of lived in peace. All we wanted to do is just be friends with you all, but you’re just so god damn paranoid you’ll kill your own town buddies just to try to get at us.

Dracula was worth 20 of your lives. He sacrificed himself. For me. For his friend. Town wouldn’t dream of doing something like that. You want to kill scum? Look in the motherfucking mirror.

 

[Barney]

Like, as I read the thread, it almost felt like Dracula vs Prisoner was innevitable, until the zombie alternative happened. How could scum react to that? They either double down on the bus on drac or use all their resources to get another train going, because regardless of which one the two trains they join they would gain townie points.

So my guess is that they just didn't react on time, so they didn't move their votes. I guess we'll know more once zombie flips, because if it turns out that zombie has a great scum role it would make perfect sense to sacrifice drac instead.

 

[Minecraft Steve]

You know what I take it back. I don’t apologize. Yeah, I killed town. You think I did it for fun? No we did it because we were under threat. Because if we didn’t you would kill all of us. I was forced to help kill my own friend just to blend in with you absolute monsters.

We could of lived in peace. All we wanted to do is just be friends with you all, but you’re just so god damn paranoid you’ll kill your own town buddies just to try to get at us.

Dracula was worth 20 of your lives. He sacrificed himself. For me. For his friend. Town wouldn’t dream of doing something like that. You want to kill scum? Look in the motherfucking mirror.

 

[Zombie]

Dracula didn’t want to vote me because I’m the bomb

 

[Witch]

Like, as I read the thread, it almost felt like Dracula vs Prisoner was innevitable, until the zombie alternative happened. How could scum react to that? They either double down on the bus on drac or use all their resources to get another train going, because regardless of which one the two trains they join they would gain townie points.

So my guess is that they just didn't react on time, so they didn't move their votes. I guess we'll know more once zombie flips, because if it turns out that zombie has a great scum role it would make perfect sense to sacrifice drac instead.

I had this theory D2, but CK was part of it and once she flipped, it fell apart for me. But I think it’s right now.

 

[Witch]

Dracula didn’t want to vote me because I’m the bomb

Liar

 

[Minecraft Steve]

Dracula didn’t want to vote me because I’m the bomb

 

[Zombie]

Yeah I’m just fucking with you. Please kill me and and end the humiliation

 

[Bob Ross]

You know what I take it back. I don’t apologize. Yeah, I killed town. You think I did it for fun? No we did it because we were under threat. Because if we didn’t you would kill all of us. I was forced to help kill my own friend just to blend in with you absolute monsters.

We could of lived in peace. All we wanted to do is just be friends with you all, but you’re just so god damn paranoid you’ll kill your own town buddies just to try to get at us.

Dracula was worth 20 of your lives. He sacrificed himself. For me. For his friend. Town wouldn’t dream of doing something like that. You want to kill scum? Look in the motherfucking mirror.

Enough crap, give up your scummates or shut up and wait the lynch.

 

[Barney]

You know what I take it back. I don’t apologize. Yeah, I killed town. You think I did it for fun? No we did it because we were under threat. Because if we didn’t you would kill all of us. I was forced to help kill my own friend just to blend in with you absolute monsters.

We could of lived in peace. All we wanted to do is just be friends with you all, but you’re just so god damn paranoid you’ll kill your own town buddies just to try to get at us.

Dracula was worth 20 of your lives. He sacrificed himself. For me. For his friend. Town wouldn’t dream of doing something like that. You want to kill scum? Look in the motherfucking mirror.

Lived in peace? You monsters killed Banana! You monsters killed a BABY! HOW DARE YOU TALK ABOUT SACRIFICE AND FRIENDSHIP WHEN YOU KILLED MY POTASIUM FRIEND!

Dracula didn’t want to vote me because I’m the bomb

You are not the bomb, if you were you wouldn't speak out and would just let town vote you out if you feared KAM vigilante shot negating the bomb.

Unless...

 

[Zombie]

Enough crap, give up your scummates or shut up and wait the lynch.

you can’t make me

 

[Bob Ross]

you can’t make me

Oh yeah?
vote: Zombie

 

[Zombie]

Lived in peace? You monsters killed Banana! You monsters killed a BABY! HOW DARE YOU TALK ABOUT SACRIFICE AND FRIENDSHIP WHEN YOU KILLED MY POTASIUM FRIEND!

THEY DESERVED IT.

 

[Zombie]

Okay town I have a proposal. If you no kill we won’t kill in the night phase anymore. We can do this. We can break the cycle of haterd

 

[Witch]

Hold the phone, folks. Before we turbo him, we need to talk about Barney’s gossip partner before that person dies and then he can’t prove it... or “can’t prove it”.

 

[Minecraft Steve]

Okay town I have a proposal. If you no kill we won’t kill in the night phase anymore. We can do this. We can break the cycle of haterd

 

[Barney]

Hold the phone, folks. Before we turbo him, we need to talk about Barney’s gossip partner before that person dies and then he can’t prove it... or “can’t prove it”.

Yeah my partner survived.

 

[Minecraft Steve]

Yeah my partner survived.

I can get behind waiting until Barney's partner admits to it, or Barney tells us that they have appeared (whenever that is).

 

[Witch]

Yeah my partner survived.

I’d like to ask that person to come forward and share some thoughts.

 

[Zombie]

It was me

 

[Bob Ross]

It's me, I am Barney's partner now, we've talked and decided that Prisoner is likely scum. I've also claimed in our chat, I won't say what I am but Barney knows.

 

[Minecraft Steve]

so Zombie today and Prisoner tomorrow? who else needs to check in?

 

[Barney]

It was me

lol, I wish

It's me, I am Barney's partner now, we've talked and decided that Prisoner is likely scum. I've also claimed in our chat, I won't say what I am but Barney knows.

Yeah I have no issues with having this in the open.

 

[Witch]

It's me, I am Barney's partner now, we've talked and decided that Prisoner is likely scum. I've also claimed in our chat, I won't say what I am but Barney knows.

Is that based on Banana’s input?

 

[Barney]

so Zombie today and Prisoner tomorrow? who else needs to check in?

I'm interested in what obama and spider-man have to say.

 

[Bob Ross]

Is that based on Banana’s input?

Nope, Banana's theory is dead now, he thought Rey is the doctor and that he saved KM who was an obvious night kill target and that Clown died by visiting the then thought scum DT.

 

[Barney]

Yeah, flipping DT was the base of the theory.

 

[Spider-Man]

 

[Spider-Man]

But in all seriousness, zombie was one of my last guesses. I'll look at D1 votes again

 

[Zombie]

And I would have gotten away with it too if it weren’t for these threads looking exactly the god damn same

 

[Barney]

And I would have gotten away with it too if it weren’t for these threads looking exactly the god damn same

Honest moment, yeah I also had the same issue with my chat, I'll write down an answer to banana and realized I was on the wrong chat at the last moment.

It's still on you tho, my brain-crazy friend.

 

[Barney]

Like, any other comment could have been better that what you said. Something like.

"Wow, what a way to end the day."

Or hey:

"This must be a boring game to watch because towns enthusiasm has been killed, but town killing town is still kind of fun"

More wiggle room.

 

[Witch]

Nope, Banana's theory is dead now, he thought Rey is the doctor and that he saved KM who was an obvious night kill target and that Clown died by visiting the then thought scum DT.

Yeah, flipping DT was the base of the theory.

Gotcha.

So, do you both trust each other?

 

[Spider-Man]

I think Prisoner's late vote on Dracula is pretty telling, we should have noticed that /talked about it before. Do any of the prisoner is scum theories come from Zombie accidentally outing himself?

 

[Spider-Man]

And, don't feel bad @Zombie . I've seen worse gaffes in my time. Way way worse lol

 

[Bob Ross]

Gotcha.

So, do you both trust each other?

Yup, fully trust Barney, his role doesn't fit this game and I trusted him as town before I was added to the chat.

 

[Barney]

Gotcha.

So, do you both trust each other?

I think we do, after all he claimed to me.

 

[Jack Sparrow]

I’m willing to believe Barney now after Bob backed it up. I have bob as my top scum read. I want to go back and reread on prisoner before I make a final judgement but whoever has a gat it would be real nice to use it on zombie and we still have a lunch today

 

[Jack Sparrow]

Oh man I meant town instead of scum. One to many beers rn.

 

[Minecraft Steve]

I’m willing to believe Barney now after Bob backed it up. I have bob as my top scum read. I want to go back and reread on prisoner before I make a final judgement but whoever has a gat it would be real nice to use it on zombie and we still have a lunch today

Do you mean top town read?

 

[Barney]

Anyone else notice that both scum players are monsters? Vampire and Zombie.

Also Baby's role was one that stopped players from doing stuff, like how a baby keeps you awake all night.

And Clown as a soft cop, hmm, maybe clown's can know the true identity of people but die when they get with the wrong crowd? lol. Reaching on this one.

As for my role I'm friendly and neighborly, so I'm a gossip.

Could it be that simple to get scum? Because if so...

 

[Zombie]

Good theory and I feel like that makes it really obvious that my scum partner is Natiko

 

[Bob Ross]

Anyone else notice that both scum players are monsters? Vampire and Zombie.

Also Baby's role was one that stopped players from doing stuff, like how a baby keeps you awake all night.

And Clown as a soft cop, hmm, maybe clown's can know the true identity of people but die when they get with the wrong crowd? lol. Reaching on this one.

As for my role I'm friendly and neighborly, so I'm a gossip.

Could it be that simple to get scum? Because if so...

Idk, it says in the opening posts flavor is meaningless.

 

[Barney]

Y

Idk, it says in the opening posts flavor is meaningless.

Yeah it was mostly a joke post, if roles are asigned at random that would make it really funny that two out of x scum roles fell to actual monster disguises.

 

[Spider-Man]

Anyone else notice that both scum players are monsters? Vampire and Zombie.

Also Baby's role was one that stopped players from doing stuff, like how a baby keeps you awake all night.

And Clown as a soft cop, hmm, maybe clown's can know the true identity of people but die when they get with the wrong crowd? lol. Reaching on this one.

As for my role I'm friendly and neighborly, so I'm a gossip.

Could it be that simple to get scum? Because if so...

LOL I love it. But CK wasn't the serial killer :(

 

[Barney]

LOL I love it. But CK wasn't the serial killer :(

Well of course not, CK was just a cereall killing fan.

 

[Zombie]

God I’m so excited to see your reactions when I flip when you realize I’ve infected 2 people and turned them into scum.

 

[Witch]

God I’m so excited to see your reactions when I flip when you realize I’ve infected 2 people and turned them into scum.

 

[Zombie]

Oh and I don’t mean to sound alarmist but my role PM does strongly imply that there’s a cult so good luck with all that

 

[Barney]

Oh and I don’t mean to sound alarmist but my role PM does strongly imply that there’s a cult so good luck with all that

Well if that's the case might as well help your scum buddies by helping us find said cult leader~

 

[Minecraft Steve]

@Natiko can we have a vote count?

is Barack Obama the only player who hasn’t checked in?

 

[Minecraft Steve]

Has @Prisoner checked in today?

 

[Natiko]

Vote Count:

Zombie - 4
Minecraft Steve - Post #1,806
Jack Sparrow - Post #1,808
Zombie - Post #1,810
Bob Ross - Post #1,827

 

[Zombie]

Barney I think we're good. Don't think anyone is going to believe we're scum together

 

[Zombie]

Oh oops wrong thread

 

[Witch]

Barney I think we're good. Don't think anyone is going to believe we're scum together

Ooh ooh, do me next

 

[Barney]

Barney I think we're good. Don't think anyone is going to believe we're scum together

I know mate, sorry you had to screw up on the main chat =(, but don't worry, I got this 100% covered and no one suspects I'm actually a cult leader and I already culted Natiko.

 

[Zombie]

I know mate, sorry you had to screw up on the main chat =(, but don't worry, I got this 100% covered and no one suspects I'm actually a cult leader and I already culted Natiko.

It's alright it happens. Just keep playing it safe and we can still win this

 

[Zombie]

for the love of god kill me and end the pain

 

[Zombie]

What do you actually expect anyone to add here

“Ah yeah we should probably kill Zombie”

 

[Barney]

for the love of god kill me and end the pain

 

[Zombie]

I just want to die

 

[Zombie]

Existence is pain

 

[Zombie]

I’m a zombie! Life if not a thing we’re into

 

[Zombie]

Except for eating it, but after that’s done you’re just left with sense of emptiness and sorrow

 

[Zombie]

I hope the rest of my team takes like 48 hours to enter the last night kill when they win

 

[Zombie]

I will get myself modkilled I swear to god

 

[Zombie]

No I won’t I’m pretty sure that’ll fuck up my priority

 

[Zombie]

But I’ll do it in spirit

 

[Zombie]

What do you think we should do today

 

[Zombie]

I don’t know probably kill that Zombie guy, he seems pretty scummy

 

[Zombie]

Yeah, that’s what I’m thinking too, but what if that’s just what he wants us to think

 

[Zombie]

Like what if he just posted that to cover up for another scum mate because his power was that important

 

[Zombie]

I don’t know seems pretty far fetched. Are you scum with him?

 

[Zombie]

Oh come on. I’m just speculating. You have to keep an open mind in mafia

 

[Zombie]

I don’t buy that at all. It just looks like you’re trying to steer us away from voting scum

 

[Zombie]

That’s just a bad faith reading of what I’m saying. I’m not saying we shouldn’t kill Zombie but we can’t just blindly go for him today. Honestly this is making me get some scummy vibes about you. That’s just so clearly not what I’m saying.

 

[Zombie]

Lmao. Do you have nothing else except some bad OMGUS? You just seem like you’re flailing now

 

[Zombie]

Vote: Zombie

This is ridiculous. You’re doing exactly what you’re accusing me of doing. Just going to play my vote here for now.

 

[Zombie]

Wooooooow. Of course you would vote for me instead of Zombie. Why am I not surprised.

 

[Zombie]

Look town if you can’t see what this dude is doing then I don’t know what to tell you. We need to kill Zombie and then Zombie. Then we win the game

 

[Zombie]

I don't know. This just seems like town v town to me. I'm not really convinced

 

[Zombie]

Really? You don't think he's scum from these?

Yeah, that’s what I’m thinking too, but what if that’s just what he wants us to think

Like what if he just posted that to cover up for another scum mate because his power was that important

He makes a play here to steer us away from his scum mate, Zombie.

Oh come on. I’m just speculating. You have to keep an open mind in mafia

Defends himself with this weak shit.

That’s just a bad faith reading of what I’m saying. I’m not saying we shouldn’t kill Zombie but we can’t just blindly go for him today. Honestly this is making me get some scummy vibes about you. That’s just so clearly not what I’m saying.

Here he is saying he still wants to kill Zombie.

Vote: Zombie

This is ridiculous. You’re doing exactly what you’re accusing me of doing. Just going to play my vote here for now.

Then he puts a vote on me instead? It's so insanely transparent I don't know how you can see anything different

 

[Zombie]

Really? You don't think he's scum from these?




He makes a play here to steer us away from his scum mate, Zombie.



Defends himself with this weak shit.



Here he is saying he still wants to kill Zombie.



Then he puts a vote on me instead? It's so insanely transparent I don't know how you can see anything different

Look that's nice and all, but do you really think scum would this be obvious about it? The goal of scum is usually not to get caught. This just looks like some not great town play

 

[Zombie]

That's some WIFOM bullshit and I know you know better