Muffin
is being held hostage by Sammi
No shit, but the entire argument that it's a lazy lynch hinges on that. If I think that is one of the most obvious scummy actions so far, then that's not lazy.
Game Thread Marvel Heroes Mafia - Half of You Will Enjoy This
- Thread starter Sorian
- Start date
VOTE: Grizzly
Work phone flipping out, my bad
Work phone flipping out, my bad
Fair enough, sorry my comment was a bit dickish
I just think that one action can easily happen to most and to jump on lynching sends dangerous precedent for rest of this game
The Bear
Obligatory Gay Bear of the Society
I'm tempting yet there is nothing that would make people vote at me? Weird wishy-washyness here.
Help us make the change you want to see in the world then
The action on it's own wasn't even extremely scummy though. Like I previously said we didn't know if the penalty was death, so if he was scum why would he randomly pop up to join some event that could lead him to his death? I'm not saying he can't be scum, but that on it's own is not enough to judge him.
Splinter
Lord of Volcano Island
Vere was vote leader before the dome and vote leader after the dome. He's still the vote leader now.
I did wonder at the time if the thunderdome would derail the Vere train. But whether that was intended or not it clearly hasn't happened.
You good enough at trending the line but not fully jumping over the fence here
Tempting because I don't see you as Town. Monopoly is still fresh in my mind. You were town read by so many people and got taken out by a shot from a townie. It's hard not to think that you're just playing the same way but this time you're not being town read so easily but you remind me very much of Monopoly.
I also wouldn't mind you seeing past N2 this time :P
The Bear
Obligatory Gay Bear of the Society
Seems weird to say that I'm "good trending the line" while at the same time Faddy says "nobody thinks he is town" eh :P.
The Bear
Obligatory Gay Bear of the Society
If you don't see me as town, then put your vote where your mouth is.
Yeah, I'm not so sure if the thunderdome was really done to Verelios's benefit. He was only in the lead by 3 votes. We still had a good part of the day for voting once the event happened, and the only thing the thunderdome did was provide a temporary distraction from the main portion of the day. It's not like this "Rynam this, Verelios" that discussion was suddenly forgotten about.
This does bring to question why the thunderdome happened at all, but considering how weird this game is it is highly likely it was compulsory. I honestly wonder if this will be the last we will see of it.
This does bring to question why the thunderdome happened at all, but considering how weird this game is it is highly likely it was compulsory. I honestly wonder if this will be the last we will see of it.
I mean that you haven't said anything that would flash like a bright sun, which players need here to vote. Some are still stuck on someone for one move they made at the event and hung up on that.
Simply put man, most players let things slide unless it hits them in the face. But I think you're easy walk on the line you still tripped up and signaled us
You know... I'll give you that, I said something similar in PR I think to someone else "Put your vote where your mouth is" so I'll do just that then
Vote: Grizzly
Yeah they should vote you instead of hinting at things at this point
Choices to be made, flips need to happen, Yada yada
The Bear
Obligatory Gay Bear of the Society
I'm not that worried about getting lynched today. It's 50 player game, mislynch at D1 is not going to ruin the world.
I'm more interested in how this push on me would change the vote leader dynamics now and in the last hour - there are quite a few players at lead now.
I'm more interested in how this push on me would change the vote leader dynamics now and in the last hour - there are quite a few players at lead now.
What happens if votes tie by the way?
I'm still rereading and I was about to change my vote because I don't want to end the day with Rynam if he's just going to be a no show, but the Grizzly train is ramping up for some reason? Guess I better catch up in full before I see if I'll stick with my initial shift.
Vote: Grizzly
I still think Vere isn't scum right now so I think I'm interested in seeing this flip. At this point, Ry is probably going to be ITAed by several players tomorrow so we'll find out more from Grizzly's flip than we would from Ry I'd say.
I still think Vere isn't scum right now so I think I'm interested in seeing this flip. At this point, Ry is probably going to be ITAed by several players tomorrow so we'll find out more from Grizzly's flip than we would from Ry I'd say.
The Bear
Obligatory Gay Bear of the Society
I assume no lynch. Not acceptable end result.
No Lynch then.
Agreed on that front
Don't see him as Town, was told to put my vote where my mouth is which I'm doing.
Between Grizzly and Vere, I'd go with Grizzly as being more likely scum.
@Kyanrute I know you're asleep, but here:
#714 is your case against Vere? His initial explanaton is in #649. After consideration I don't buy it. Even see some narration from you in there (he mentioned that he panicked before). It's basically boils down to: "I knew he had a lot of votes" vs. "he was at the top of the list" - which do not negate each other.
the aftertaste of panic is strange though, that is true. surely someone to look out for, but another lynch would be more interesting probably. thus is my verdict.
#714 is your case against Vere? His initial explanaton is in #649. After consideration I don't buy it. Even see some narration from you in there (he mentioned that he panicked before). It's basically boils down to: "I knew he had a lot of votes" vs. "he was at the top of the list" - which do not negate each other.
the aftertaste of panic is strange though, that is true. surely someone to look out for, but another lynch would be more interesting probably. thus is my verdict.
Is this serious or joking because of the accusation earlier on?
The Bear
Obligatory Gay Bear of the Society
It's not really last minute, we still have over an hour.
Splinter
Lord of Volcano Island
Alexem
Yeah, I'm town
Two obvious questions, then: how and why?
The Bear
Obligatory Gay Bear of the Society
Why Splinter and Melon as choices? Assuming you are telling the truth.
Finally someone with logic.
Faddy
of, having, or involving transitory whims
Agreed Kawl.
Faddy
of, having, or involving transitory whims
No, the only reason for him to come out and admit it as scum is reverse psychology.
It was a day command pmd to Sorian. I have no clue how many crazy ass powers are flying around and how many people might get got tonight so I sure as hell wasnt leaving a power unused.
Melon was Uber talkative figured it would be interesting to see who broke which way on her regardless of alignment. Splinter was because I’m still not over spirit island.
Melon was Uber talkative figured it would be interesting to see who broke which way on her regardless of alignment. Splinter was because I’m still not over spirit island.
The Bear
Obligatory Gay Bear of the Society
Nah, Rynam and Verelios are lot more delicious.
same potential conspiracy popped into my head.
Really curious to see Gorlak's reaction to this, considering.
Yeah not messing with this yet. Just like...what. What response do they want? Is this scum trying to kill a no power player to save someone who could do something tonight? Like...what?
Verelios
Were-elios
@EzekelRAGE Where is your god now?
The Bear
Obligatory Gay Bear of the Society
both these potential lynches are gross
Rynam is a WASTED lynch; he's gonna get got.
The Verelios stuff is a stretch.
The only thing I ask from you is that you die. And you couldn’t even do that right
EzekelRAGE
*truffleshuffle*
This is also my problem with the TD, the no lynch. It atleast would've given us something to go on.
Anyway my read of the situation or w/e.
My vote today was gonna be on Cool Vere or Splinter.
Cool - for his power role/claim shenigans earlier in the game. May be that he misplayed, but idk. Seemed scummy
Vere - as I pointed out earlier. He benefited from the TD. Doesn't matter how much time was left in the day, he was the topic of discussion and seems to have skated by after the TD.
Splinter - This goes to the TD. Im not familiar with the power but it was stated by him that this has to be a scum power. Saying that sort of clears him and melon as town. He also made the post asking for whoever called the TD to out themselves. Then points out how weird it was that it was he and melon that were in the TD.
Theory 1 - Splinter is scum, didn't want to lynch melon, but decided to "save" melon. Gaining townie points. A couple votes mentioned that as the reason they didn't want to vote Splinter.
Theory 2 - Both melon and Splint are scum and the push for No Lynch was part of the plan the whole time. Also making this power seem like a scum power clears at least one of them, if not both, in the eyes of town.
Vere is the best vote for us imo. Some ppl linked a vere scum flip to more answers in the event. Also with the recent posters pointing out why they don't want to vote for vere, could shed some light on that as well.
The Bear
Obligatory Gay Bear of the Society
So who do you want to lynch? Gorlak isn't going to happen.
Uhh looks like we agree on something here
Splinter
Lord of Volcano Island
^
Honestly I dunno how you can pretend a Rynam lynch is "delicious". Is he even playing?
Are most powers mini games? Wtf are we in for
EzekelRAGE
*truffleshuffle*
Welp.lol
I know Gorlak's not gonna happen. I'm thinking, though. When I know who I wanna lynch, I'll vote.
Nah, Splinter and Kawl aren't in the same team that knew of a dome. They could both be town though. Still think Kawl is baiting
that timing! perfect
The Bear
Obligatory Gay Bear of the Society
Verelios is like a tasty ice cream, you just know you are going to get scum flavor when you order it
Rynam is like a eastern surprise candy - you never know what is inside, but you just want to find out
Are you actually basically rolling over and shitposting now?Verelios is like a tasty ice cream, you just know you are going to get scum flavor when you order it
Rynam is like a eastern surprise candy - you never know what is inside, but you just want to find out
It happens sometimes.
Yeah, possibly, but I wanna know what you think of the potential of the power, alignment-wise, reactions here, etc. Just in case Kawl isn't.
Splinter
Lord of Volcano Island
Seriously? If you were gonna thunderdome you'd look at melon and say "hmm yes, this is a player I wouldn't mind randomly losing today"
He sprung a midnight thunderdome on two active (ok I was a bit afk yesterday) players and didn't even make a post, much less vote in it.
He can't even justify it. His reason for picking melon (one of the most active and townread players at the time) was "to see which way people would go".
The thing is Geno doesn't know how to handle being a lynch contender and continues to aggressively go against others which only makes them more inclined to vote him. That happened in a previous game as well.
And this is why him lurking and not posting (at least a short while ago) is only mildly suspicious to me.
How does everyone feel about @Hecht?
And this is why him lurking and not posting (at least a short while ago) is only mildly suspicious to me.
How does everyone feel about @Hecht?
This might be one of my most favourite comparisons now XD.
Kinda wish I had a Kinder Surprise now but considering the heat here, it'd melt so quickly :(
They know it's over and just trying to not change tide, I guess
Huh, okay so looks like the Grizzly train just built up all of a sudden. I had him as a town read in my notes earlier in the day, and nothing in particular has stuck out to me, so this is an interesting choice of a lynch. I don't want to remain on Rynam, but prior to an all out reread I town read both Vere and Grizzly.
It's late in the day (wish I were here to post earlier >_>) but we'll see where this goes.
VOTE: Geno
I've been playing with Geno for like 4 years (with several breaks in between, but still). But I wouldn't say any of that in particular is indicative of anything different from the town behavior I'm used to seeing from him. What was it, Buck Bumble iirc where I was mafia and pushed for him hard, but he was so painfully the town Geno I was used to. His behavior in this game has hints of that, but I'd expect Geno to at least use more logic and reason behind his actions, which he hasn't done much of until pushed for it. And his clinging to Vere seems like a very easy out, which I'm not liking. There's also him seemingly parrot other players a couple times without putting much effort into his arguments.
It's late in the day (wish I were here to post earlier >_>) but we'll see where this goes.
VOTE: Geno
The Bear
Obligatory Gay Bear of the Society
The main argument against me is a meta point - which is okay, but it also means I can't exactly argue against it. And I've already made my stance on Rynam and Vere clear. So yes, I'm having slight fun.
EzekelRAGE
*truffleshuffle*
Vote: Kawl
With the reveal, his flip gives us information. Especially since its believed its a scum power. He flips town, puts hole in my splinter/TD theory and Vere being saved by scum teammate theory. Besides it seems his power is all gone now anyway?
With the reveal, his flip gives us information. Especially since its believed its a scum power. He flips town, puts hole in my splinter/TD theory and Vere being saved by scum teammate theory. Besides it seems his power is all gone now anyway?
Faddy
of, having, or involving transitory whims
Good with Hecht. I like how he got straight down to business of finding some people to push on.
Yeah, why do you think Kawl is town and how would you answer Splinter there?
Btw I noticed that every single time you said something like "This is not how Geno usually plays", you are always scum. Which did not happen in Berserk even though I played the exact same way, I'm fairly certain you rolled scum this time as well.
Verelios
Were-elios
He's constantly failing upwards in every game, much to my disappointment.
Hey Coolest, you're a Cool kid. Vote Geno with me.
Power could be any alignment. No lynch option to nerf a free mislynch for scum, or balance a dumb townie going wild. Kawl isn't believable to me, Splinter "called it", melon is absent. Nothing much to glean from other reactions so far.
Noteable was that Faddy is here, but he lets the day play out how it is instead of taking a more leading role.
Disregarding how bad of an idea it is to try to lynch someone based off of prior games (especially before anything has happened), you yourself should've tried to sway the thunderdome vote by actually participating in it and proclaiming that you were the one who started it. At least then your power would have been less likely to have gone to waste.
(Assuming you can only do this once.)
Hecht is being very Hecht. Probably town. He'll look scummy from time to time, lack in thread impact, push people without great reasons and huff when no one follows his invisible logic. Would not even consider lynching today.
There's meta - which some people are leaning on here, sure - and then there's you being smart enough to not have pushed on Stuart like that the way you did. It felt like a set up. You were baiting him. And I don't buy your overexplaining reasoning in response. And since, you look like you're playing purposely against your meta, which just further reinforces your self awareness.
You'll see my post a few pages back bout why I ain't doing that.
I had him most of today but now I think he best saved for tomorrow unless "crazy shit" goes down
Going to need ample citations for this one. Pretty sure I didn't say it in Buck, and 100% sure I didn't in that last game with played on FAQs where you were scum and died day one.
I'll do that day 2 if I survive. When I find all the evidence don't be surprised if I use my ITA on you ok?
And you did NOT act this way in Berserk, which is my entire point. You were one of the more active players (especially after you thought you were mr. smart guy with your scan of me), and you didn't do half as much lurking as you have done in this game. So I call bs.
Yeah what the heck is that post, I been in most reset era games with you two and that's a nope nope nope reasoning from geno
Almost changed my reasoning last second
Is that how he normally is? His first posts stuck out to me as odd and his whole posting style has seemed odd to me so I'm not great on him but if that's just the way he is in games, I guess I'm null on him?