Costume Party |OT| The Mafia Mash

Banana

Costume Account
I don't really see much with Prisoner to really indicate one way or another. Most of his posts seem pretty neutral, and aside from the whole "the 2nd vote is always suspicious" thing early on nothing has raised my eyebrows. I guess you could say he seems to possibly be playing things a bit too quiet and safe and I wouldn't argue with that too much.
 

Cereal Killer

Costume Account
On the off chance Bob isn't scum, his elimination might give us some clues as many players have strong opinions on him
scummy post tbh and while I"m here I don't like your list or the fact you were gone for an hour but posted again immediately when prodded but I doubt anyone is up for your wagon today
 

Prisoner

Costume Account
Okay I'm back.
I'll have to look into Banana and Zombie it seems.

I wouldn't be against a Bob lunch if Clown isn't an option.
 

Spider-Man

Costume Account
scummy post tbh and while I"m here I don't like your list or the fact you were gone for an hour but posted again immediately when prodded but I doubt anyone is up for your wagon today
Was it that immediate? I came back and saw I'd been @ed so did what was polite and replied. That's not the only thing I came back for though.
 

Barney

Costume Account
I feel like Scum is happy to let the Drac wagon go on
Eh, I won't call it a Wagon, its pretty close, could go either way. I still feel a bit iffy about prisoner, so I'll vote there.
Vote: Prisoner

Between Dracula, Banana and Zombie, I think Banana is town, Dracula had that slip but I still feel that was pretty meaningless, and Zombie is the one I feel worst about, but I'll probably stay on the pris.
 

Banana

Costume Account
Eh, I won't call it a Wagon, its pretty close, could go either way. I still feel a bit iffy about prisoner, so I'll vote there.
Vote: Prisoner

Between Dracula, Banana and Zombie, I think Banana is town, Dracula had that slip but I still feel that was pretty meaningless, and Zombie is the one I feel worst about, but I'll probably stay on the pris.

Welcome back! Why Prisoner?
 

Barney

Costume Account
Welcome back! Why Prisoner?
Mostly the second vote comment, there really is not a long to go with this day since it reads like air to me, but that second vote comment in particular jumped at me as scum trying to pre-justify a future mislunch. Really obvious stuff and something that everyone else has agreed with, and not really that original, but I am willing to vote there and see that flip.
 

Witch

Costume Account
Dracula at 4 votes; Prisoner, Banana, and Zombie at 3 votes.

The Prisoner surge at the last minute is making me uncomfortable, but I guess I was part of the Banana surge so...
 

Daenerys Targaryen

Costume Account
Mostly the second vote comment, there really is not a long to go with this day since it reads like air to me, but that second vote comment in particular jumped at me as scum trying to pre-justify a future mislunch. Really obvious stuff and something that everyone else has agreed with, and not really that original, but I am willing to vote there and see that flip.
That feels quite weak. I'm 95% sure the second vote thing is just a tool Prisoner uses to get the ball running, regardless of what their alignment is here.
 

Barney

Costume Account
How lucky we are that Prisoner has other posts with their thoughts that we can read to try and deduce their real motivations.
Yeah, you have the option to decide to follow a player who has strong motivations and posts behind their actions, or me who just has a weak hunch and no clue whatsoever on who might be scum, nor a strong case.
 

Prisoner

Costume Account
That reread of Banana and Zombie wasn't all that helpful.
I think I'd slightly prefer a Banana lunch though, just because I think it's a little bit more likely for them to be on a team with Bob who is a stronger Scum lean than both of them.
 

Daenerys Targaryen

Costume Account
That reread of Banana and Zombie wasn't all that helpful.
I think I'd slightly prefer a Banana lunch though, just because I think it's a little bit more likely for them to be on a team with Bob who is a stronger Scum lean than both of them.
I don't wanna lunch any of them, but if both are town I think Zombie is more likely to be mislunch later on.
 

Daenerys Targaryen

Costume Account
what makes you say that ? your stomach ?
He's quite abrasive while Banana has been doing some work that could make him more town over time.

It's sorta an old theory that it's better to get rid of the people that are gonna be questionable in the future early instead of being stuck with them.
 

Clown

Costume Account
Scum slippin ?

Wanna explain the witch vote before the day is called? See below:

Is it bold because nobody really is entertaining this option or what makes this move bold in your opinion? Why do you think nobody is considering Witch? Why are you considering Witch / why should we consider Witch? What do you think about Witch's top three targets?
 

Bob Ross

Costume Account
If I get lynched out of nowhere fuck this, I won't get a chance to claim and I clearly said make up your minds so I can claim if needed.
 

Cereal Killer

Costume Account
I like the ppl on Banana's wagons but honestly banana was funny lol

we need more funny because there is too much handwringing panic in here
 

Banana

Costume Account
I like the ppl on Banana's wagons but honestly banana was funny lol

we need more funny because there is too much handwringing panic in here

My kids would beg to differ with that statement.

I would like to hear Kool Aid's Witch read before the day ends.
 

Kool-Aid Man

Costume Account
m78wy8ehsmb41.jpg
 

Clown

Costume Account
Talk to me about Banana @Clown

He is clear, Witch I think is the only other that has shown similar behavior but not in similar amounts. I did not originally agree with Witch's comment about how he seems like the sane man in the asylum, was more into the idea that he seemed to be playing from a distance, but I came around and I get that vibe too now or at least hints of it. The posts have the hints of being written by scum: too clear, too certain, as in the opinions came from a POV that knows more than the rest do.

His cases today are you (accuses you of playing too seriously for town points, in my opinion his view was false - you were serious already before that), Dracula (the slip and as far as I remember he is the clearest origin for the idea that Dracula panicked a bit after the joke - don't agree with the whole thing, compared him against Zombie and I feel Zombie was more genuine about how he handled the same experience with similar reasoning) and Witch (hints of OMGUS and IMO unnecessary shade). I don't agree with the targets, I read all of the three at least as a close null at least and I find the reasoning behind each case weak or disagreeable.

I think you were the one you said early early game that he should do more than mechanics, I remember getting a similar desire back then too. Minor, but could be something in the 1st context.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
==== DAY 1 VOTES ====
Day Start

Bob Ross (4 votes)
Daenerys Targaryen - 0 0
Spider-Man - 0
Dracula - 0 0
Daenerys Targaryen - 0
Prisoner - 0
Cereal Killer - 0

Dracula (4 votes)
Cereal Killer - 0 0
Banana - 0
Zombie - 0
Bob Ross - 0
Rey - 0

Prisoner (3 votes)
Barack Obama - 0
Minecraft Steve - 0
Barney - 0

Banana (3 votes)
Witch - 0 0
Dracula - 0
Witch - 0
Clown - 0

Zombie (2 votes)
Baby - 0
Jack Sparrow - 0
Witch - 0 0
Cereal Killer - 0 0

Witch (1 votes)
Kool-Aid Man - 0

Daenerys Targaryen (0 votes)
Prisoner - 0 0
Rey - 0 0

Spider-Man (0 votes)
Cereal Killer - 0 0

Minecraft Steve (0 votes)
Daenerys Targaryen - 0 0

Cereal Killer (0 votes)
Spider-Man - 0 0
Dracula - 0 0

Barack Obama (0 votes)
Cereal Killer - 0 0

Clown (0 votes)
Prisoner - 0 0

Not voting: Cinderella

Post Counts:
Daenerys Targaryen: 86 Cereal Killer: 64 Witch: 57 Dracula: 55 Bob Ross: 42 Banana: 35 Clown: 35 Rey: 34 Spider-Man: 27 Barney: 25 Baby: 22 Kool-Aid Man: 20 Prisoner: 20 Zombie: 17 Jack Sparrow: 16 Cinderella: 14 Minecraft Steve: 13 Barack Obama: 10

Current Countdown:
lq2vquya8u



Click here to go to the Vote Tool!
 

Daenerys Targaryen

Costume Account
I think you were the one you said early early game that he should do more than mechanics, I remember getting a similar desire back then too. Minor, but could be something in the 1st context.
I didn't have much of a read of him when I made that so I wanted to make our little feud into a read at least, but it kinda fizzled after that.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
==== DAY 1 VOTES ====
Day Start

Prisoner (5 votes)
Barack Obama - 0
Minecraft Steve - 0
Barney - 0
Witch - 0
Cinderella - 0

Bob Ross (4 votes)
Daenerys Targaryen - 0 0
Spider-Man - 0
Dracula - 0 0
Daenerys Targaryen - 0
Prisoner - 0
Cereal Killer - 0

Dracula (4 votes)
Cereal Killer - 0 0
Banana - 0
Zombie - 0
Bob Ross - 0
Rey - 0

Banana (2 votes)
Witch - 0 0
Dracula - 0
Witch - 0 0
Clown - 0

Zombie (2 votes)
Baby - 0
Jack Sparrow - 0
Witch - 0 0
Cereal Killer - 0 0

Witch (1 votes)
Kool-Aid Man - 0

Daenerys Targaryen (0 votes)
Prisoner - 0 0
Rey - 0 0

Spider-Man (0 votes)
Cereal Killer - 0 0

Minecraft Steve (0 votes)
Daenerys Targaryen - 0 0

Cereal Killer (0 votes)
Spider-Man - 0 0
Dracula - 0 0

Barack Obama (0 votes)
Cereal Killer - 0 0

Clown (0 votes)
Prisoner - 0 0

Post Counts:
Daenerys Targaryen: 90 Cereal Killer: 66 Witch: 60 Dracula: 55 Bob Ross: 42 Banana: 35 Clown: 35 Rey: 34 Spider-Man: 27 Barney: 25 Kool-Aid Man: 23 Baby: 22 Prisoner: 21 Zombie: 17 Jack Sparrow: 16 Cinderella: 15 Minecraft Steve: 13 Barack Obama: 10

Current Countdown:
lq2vquya8u



Click here to go to the Vote Tool!
 

Spider-Man

Costume Account
Prisoner is in the lead? Just my luck, I haven't really engaged with him at all so don't have a good read. But I feel like Drac is town. I'll stay on Bob.
 

Banana

Costume Account
I really don't see the Prisoner calls unless you think they are just playing too quiet and safe.
 

Clown

Costume Account
Kool, please avoid the demoralizing attempt to be the dumbest townie ever and ruining everything for everyone.
 

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
==== DAY 1 VOTES ====
Day Start

Prisoner (5 votes)
Barack Obama - 0
Minecraft Steve - 0
Barney - 0
Witch - 0
Cinderella - 0

Dracula (5 votes)
Cereal Killer - 0 0
Banana - 0
Zombie - 0
Bob Ross - 0
Rey - 0
Prisoner - 0

Bob Ross (3 votes)
Daenerys Targaryen - 0 0
Spider-Man - 0
Dracula - 0 0
Daenerys Targaryen - 0
Prisoner - 0 0
Cereal Killer - 0

Banana (2 votes)
Witch - 0 0
Dracula - 0
Witch - 0 0
Clown - 0

Zombie (2 votes)
Baby - 0
Jack Sparrow - 0
Witch - 0 0
Cereal Killer - 0 0

Witch (1 votes)
Kool-Aid Man - 0

Daenerys Targaryen (0 votes)
Prisoner - 0 0
Rey - 0 0

Spider-Man (0 votes)
Cereal Killer - 0 0

Minecraft Steve (0 votes)
Daenerys Targaryen - 0 0

Cereal Killer (0 votes)
Spider-Man - 0 0
Dracula - 0 0

Barack Obama (0 votes)
Cereal Killer - 0 0

Clown (0 votes)
Prisoner - 0 0

Post Counts:
Daenerys Targaryen: 91 Cereal Killer: 66 Witch: 61 Dracula: 55 Bob Ross: 42 Banana: 35 Clown: 35 Rey: 34 Spider-Man: 29 Barney: 25 Kool-Aid Man: 23 Prisoner: 22 Baby: 22 Zombie: 17 Jack Sparrow: 16 Cinderella: 15 Minecraft Steve: 14 Barack Obama: 10

Current Countdown:
lq2vquya8u



Click here to go to the Vote Tool!
 
Top Bottom