Game Thread Marvel Heroes Mafia - Half of You Will Enjoy This

Kyanrute

kyan-rute
You mean for shooting why we did? if so, I already explained earlier that I was going after Ry due to his D1 opportunisticness and being absent before and after the event.

More like what is the command supposed to do, though if someone did not explain themselves before that too would be appreciated.
 
More like what is the command supposed to do, though if someone did not explain themselves before that too would be appreciated.

It's in the ITA rules

You will make your shot by posting the highlighted name of who you want to attempt to kill. No special command is necessary so have fun with it and SLAP: cabot like I do (just don't use the VOTE command, that will still count as a valid vote during this time).

Nothing, just a bit of fun.
 

Kyanrute

kyan-rute
Now that Splinter is no longer with us, who is going to accuse me of shading on one scum mate on day one (super-friend Bear) and then shading another on day two? And then I did not commit to either!

man i am such a obvious scum
 

melonrabbit

The only good kind of melon
This tells me you have something to protect. But given I've seen your unabashed Scum play and how much you love to stir shit up either you are a VERY strong Scum role or you are Town and genuinely did not want this fight to take place. There is a possibility here that you are Neutral and only looked after your own skin and, in which case, good job, but the earnest nature of which you argued against the thunderdome and Melon votes does not give me that view.

Egg on you @Sawneeks
 

EzekelRAGE

*truffleshuffle*
Splinter - This goes to the TD. Im not familiar with the power but it was stated by him that this has to be a scum power. Saying that sort of clears him and melon as town. He also made the post asking for whoever called the TD to out themselves. Then points out how weird it was that it was he and melon that were in the TD.
giphy.gif


Theory 1 - Splinter is scum, didn't want to lynch melon, but decided to "save" melon. Gaining townie points. A couple votes mentioned that as the reason they didn't want to vote Splinter.
Theory 2 - Both melon and Splint are scum and the push for No Lynch was part of the plan the whole time. Also making this power seem like a scum power clears at least one of them, if not both, in the eyes of town.
With splinters flip looks like I was right with at least theory 1. Maybe theory 2.

Sawneeks gave a read of both of them as town based solely on td.
 
Man, Rynam must have some guardian angel right now lol. Bet Splinter would love to have his luck.

(Good job by the way, EzekelRAGE. That totally came out of nowhere.)
 

Alexem

Yeah, I'm town
Come to think of it, if this is what the odds of getting an ITA to work are like, I think we're in for multi-hit nights as the norm if that's what it takes to whittle down the numbers at a reasonable rate.
 

Sorian

Neutral Ascetic 1-Shot BP SK Alignment Cop
Staff member
==== DAY 2 VOTES ====
Day Start

kawl (2 votes)
muffin - #1767
stuart444 - #2024

ynnek7 (2 votes)
sawneeks - #1734 #1739
sawneeks - #1739
heymonkey - #1882

kyanrute (1 votes)
apollo - #2047

rynam (1 votes)
geno - #2245

Post Counts:
stuart444: 85 melonrabbit: 67 verelios: 44 sawneeks: 41 heymonkey: 39 kawl: 29 ynnek7: 20 sorian: 18 geno: 16 kyanrute: 15 muffin: 14 splinter: 14 extreme tactician: 14 stanleypalmtree: 14 faircure: 11 ezekelrage: 10 natiko: 9 swamped: 9 terraforce: 9 gorlak: 7 poltergust: 7 necktochicken: 7 nomad sparkster: 7 alexem: 7 coolestspot: 6 rynam: 6 xbro: 6 apollo: 5 dcpat: 4 oreomunsta: 4 mazre: 4 ferg: 3 nin1000: 3 bladesymphony: 3 briefs_cat: 2 lone_prodigy: 1 zippedpinhead: 1 hecht: 1 hom3land: 1 zubz: 1

Click here to go to the Vote Tool!

Next ITA Phase in:
pur_1530309600.png
 
This does bring to question who started the thunderdome. If it is a scum power, why risk one of their own getting lynched from it, especially since it's so early in the game? Furthermore, why would Splinter not try to get melon lynched instead of opting for a No Lynch?

This reminds me of the gambit used in the last thunderdome I saw, and it didn't work out for that person either.
 

EzekelRAGE

*truffleshuffle*
This does bring to question who started the thunderdome. If it is a scum power, why risk one of their own getting lynched from it, especially since it's so early in the game? Furthermore, why would Splinter not try to get melon lynched instead of opting for a No Lynch?

This reminds me of the gambit used in the last thunderdome I saw, and it didn't work out for that person either.
Both are scum in td
Splint wanted townie pats for saving a possible town melon. We can also load ok at the no lynch bandwagon for the td, which I had a problem with.
 
Both are scum in td
Splint wanted townie pats for saving a possible town melon. We can also load ok at the no lynch bandwagon for the td, which I had a problem with.
Ok bro listen, you hit the shot gj and all you a god but scum doesn't gladiate between scum, if town was smarter and lynched 1 of them they would've lost a member and since we didn't know where the power came from the other person wouldn't even be confirmed town to us.
 
Why you shot at Stuart?

Town makes mistakes, if you don't scumread somebody please don't shoot at him. I would vote for you over this, but I'm pretty sure you going to catch a few more shots next round, that votes on you not really going to matter.
 

Alexem

Yeah, I'm town
Both are scum in td
Splint wanted townie pats for saving a possible town melon. We can also load ok at the no lynch bandwagon for the td, which I had a problem with.
Good point - I never considered the possibility that scum might use a dome for a bus.
 

melonrabbit

The only good kind of melon
There is no way scum would use a Thunderdome such a way and if they did they wouldn't risk a Jack to it. They'd throw in a goon.
 
Splinter might've been the most op thing scum had, look at his abilities, there's no way they will sacrifice him.
 
There is no way scum would use a Thunderdome such a way and if they did they wouldn't risk a Jack to it. They'd throw in a goon.

I have to agree on this, a goon or a less powerful role than a jack would be more likely. Throwing a Jack into it kinda kills the theory that it was scum made.

It's either Neutral, Town or Sorian imo.
 
There is no way scum would use a Thunderdome such a way and if they did they wouldn't risk a Jack to it. They'd throw in a goon.

This. Why would scum throw this TD and then advocate for a no-lynch (as Splinter did)? I don't see this TD coming from scum team.
 

EzekelRAGE

*truffleshuffle*
Ok bro listen, you hit the shot gj and all you a god but scum doesn't gladiate between scum, if town was smarter and lynched 1 of them they would've lost a member and since we didn't know where the power came from the other person wouldn't even be confirmed town to us.
They were town read after td. More than one person used the td as the reason for the town read. I also don’t really care for the scum would never line.
 

melonrabbit

The only good kind of melon
This is getting silly.

The simplest answer is often the truth. I hate Splinter and I Thunderdome'd him. I'm the Town Gladiator.
 
Zeke is convinced that it was two scums and nothing will change his mind I guess.

Yea, probably. But thinking Melon TD'd Splinter as both scum is as likely as Zeke shooting hit teammate Splinter to hope for the 85% chance it wouldn't hit.
Probably even less likely than that.
 
Yea, probably. But thinking Melon TD'd Splinter as both scum is as likely as Zeke shooting hit teammate Splinter to hope for the 85% chance it wouldn't hit.
Probably even less likely than that.

I agree. I'm reading Zeke as Town now thanks to that but I also read Melon as even more townie now because I just can't see Scum doing that with their Jack.
 

EzekelRAGE

*truffleshuffle*
Still mobile, so can’t go back and check posts. But if I don’t see melon calling ba on kawl claim or saying anything to splinter spinning the td as a scum only power. Then that’s my vote.
 
Top Bottom