Game Thread Marvel Heroes Mafia - Half of You Will Enjoy This

Muffin

Muffin

is being held hostage by Sammi
Geno said:
Shooting Blarg is good too, he is part of the triangle and can give us good info on death. But if you believe he is town then don't shoot him.
Click to expand...
Well I don't have much arguments for it to be honest. His claim isn't enough when there was an item faker out there. It's more of a gut read.
 
Sawneeks

Sawneeks

little green dog
Also googling Adrenaline Junkie is giving me nothing, it's the first time I've ever heard of the role so I have no clue how common it is alignment wise.
 
Ynnek7

Ynnek7

OH MY GOD, THEY LYNCHED YNNEK
Gah! Been following along and unable to post. About to leave work, but

Moon Healing Escalation!: Blargonaut
 
Muffin

Muffin

is being held hostage by Sammi
You know what, fuck it:

GALICK GUN...FIIIIIIIIIIIIRE!: Blargonaut

tenor.gif
 
Sorian

Sorian

Neutral Ascetic 1-Shot BP SK Alignment Cop
Staff member
melon's Role:

Welcome melonrabbit,

You are Prince Namor. True Identity Namor McKenzie.

Your role is Town Gladiator. During day 1 ONLY, you may use the command THUNDERDOME: <playername> to begin an alternate vote for six hours. During that time, only votes made on you or the player of your choice will count and at the end of the six hours, the vote leader will be lynched. You may not claim or hint at your role before or during the use of your power. Once the thunderdome ends, day 1 will continue as normal. This power must be used at least eight hours before day end.

You win when all threats to town are eliminated.
Click to expand...
 
Geno

Geno

I don't get you guys sometimes. There was no way she would flip scum. Anyway, we still miles ahead.
Vote:Sawneeks
 
Sawneeks

Sawneeks

little green dog
Geno said:
I don't get you guys sometimes. There was no way she would flip scum. Anyway, we still miles ahead.
Vote:Sawneeks
Click to expand...
Just like there was 'no way I'm gonna flip Town', right?

I already said so earlier but we have 4 Kills per Night PLUS a Day Kill outside of ITAs. This game is going to get real small, REAL fast.
 
K

Kawl

Owner of the Gun Show
Geno said:
I don't get you guys sometimes. There was no way she would flip scum. Anyway, we still miles ahead.
Vote:Sawneeks
Click to expand...
I was paranoid that blarg was scum and playing us with the convienent revelation that he chose rage and that melon lost her bp. But on the off chance he isn’t I’d rather have town bp giver hanging around, ergo shoot melon to cut the gordian knot
 
Blargonaut

Blargonaut

SCUM UP!
Kawl said:
I’m not even 100% on his claim. He could be pigging backing off of my basically revealed information and the one melon got was fake item giver or Melon is scum mates with blarg and lying, especially with his claim that he gave today’s to rage
Click to expand...
That is a lot of coincidence
 
Sawneeks

Sawneeks

little green dog
So what is the reasons for the votes on me? Is it JUST because of the fact that Adrenaline Junkie is typically Scum even though Melon just said she'd seen a Town variant?
 
Geno

Geno

Kawl said:
I was paranoid that blarg was scum and playing us with the convienent revelation that he chose rage and that melon lost her bp. But on the off chance he isn’t I’d rather have town bp giver hanging around, ergo shoot melon to cut the gordian knot
Click to expand...
I can understand the logic behind this at least. At the very least I think we all agree Sawneeks is the best lynch here.
 
Geno

Geno

Brazil said:
Geno, explain to me why melon/Blarg/Saw was a triangle.
Click to expand...
It was probably more than a triangle. You can add Kawl in there to make it a square. Thing is these 3 were arguing with each other a lot. We needed something to point us to a direction.
 
Muffin

Muffin

is being held hostage by Sammi
Sawneeks said:
So what is the reasons for the votes on me? Is it JUST because of the fact that Adrenaline Junkie is typically Scum even though Melon just said she'd seen a Town variant?
Click to expand...
Why are you and Kalor before acting like this makes the whole thing invalid? This sounds like an argument "Town"-Hooker Sorian would make. Though granted, there is a different degree of needing to be scum for those two roles.

I also think you haven't played like usual. You made those reads lists a few times you said because of your role, but besides that, your usual presence just isn't there. It's weirding me out.
 
Brazil

Brazil

Geno said:
It was probably more than a triangle. You can add Kawl in there to make it a square. Thing is these 3 were arguing with each other a lot. We needed something to point us to a direction.
Click to expand...
Hmm :/

Gorlak, Zeke and melon were arguing between themselves a lot too. I dunno.

For now my strongest scumread is Swamped, and it's based on her own behavior. I'll reread Saw.
 
Geno

Geno

Brazil said:
Hmm :/

Gorlak, Zeke and melon were arguing between themselves a lot too. I dunno.

For now my strongest scumread is Swamped, and it's based on her own behavior. I'll reread Saw.
Click to expand...
I was only speaking about the people alive now. The outcome of this was less than ideal. Swamped low on the priority list. However I still think she's town.
 
Brazil

Brazil

Geno said:
I was only speaking about the people alive now. The outcome of this was less than ideal. Swamped low on the priority list. However I still think she's town.
Click to expand...
I know. What I meant is that the fact that the three were arguing isn't necessarily alignment-indicative.

Why do you think Swamped is town?
 
Sawneeks

Sawneeks

little green dog
Geno said:
It was probably more than a triangle. You can add Kawl in there to make it a square. Thing is these 3 were arguing with each other a lot. We needed something to point us to a direction.
Click to expand...

Geno are you sure you aren't Scum? Pigeonholing Town like this is terrible, you're setting up chain lynches and blocking out like most of the game.

Muffin said:
Why are you and Kalor before acting like this makes the whole thing invalid? This sounds like an argument "Town"-Hooker Sorian would make. Though granted, there is a different degree of needing to be scum for those two roles.

I also think you haven't played like usual. You made those reads lists a few times you said because of your role, but besides that, your usual presence just isn't there. It's weirding me out.
Click to expand...

Because I want hard reasons down for every single vote on me. Not many here are looking back but when I flip Town I want people to be able to look back to see the reasons why people voted against me.

Also because if that's your only argument it's a weak one. While I'd love to be saying I'm pulling another Town Hooker here I'm not, it's my actual role.

And yes, I know I haven't played my normal. It falls into IRL reasons for that and I'm more disappointed n myself for not being able to put more into this.
 
Kalor

Kalor

Kay-lor? Kah-lor?
I really don't see the Saw case. Nothing she's done has really rang alarm bells for and with some of the recent arguments, I feel like the only sane one. The fact that Geno lied about having information to get a claim is insane and I can't believe no-one is actually calling him out for it. Now he's setting up chains of people to flip depending on how Saw flips and it just feels like I missed something. If Sawneeks is town, I am shooting Geno tomorrow because I don't care how many scum he's found, he's probably the most anti town person right now and he is going to lead town to their death with his arrogance.
 
Sawneeks

Sawneeks

little green dog
Kalor said:
I really don't see the Saw case. Nothing she's done has really rang alarm bells for and with some of the recent arguments, I feel like the only sane one. The fact that Geno lied about having information to get a claim is insane and I can't believe no-one is actually calling him out for it. Now he's setting up chains of people to flip depending on how Saw flips and it just feels like I missed something. If Sawneeks is town, I am shooting Geno tomorrow because I don't care how many scum he's found, he's probably the most anti town person right now and he is going to lead town to their death with his arrogance.
Click to expand...

THANK YOU
 
Muffin

Muffin

is being held hostage by Sammi
I mean I am wondering how Geno is still alive after being responsible for so many scum deaths.
 
Geno

Geno

You guys are acting as if I will be town's doom. There's no chains of people getting lynched. We lynch one, we see flips and night deaths and plan accordingly. If anything you should be calling out people shooting Melon and obvious townies.
 
Sawneeks

Sawneeks

little green dog
Muffin said:
Kawl got directly greenchecked by Stuart and Ynnek though and Stuart flipped town.
Click to expand...

I know, but I'm still shocked he is alive. Doubt Scum has 2 Godfathers but I still find it odd.

Geno said:
You guys are acting as if I will be town's doom. There's no chains of people getting lynched. We lynch one, we see flips and night deaths and plan accordingly. If anything you should be calling out people shooting Melon and obvious townies.
Click to expand...

You named a Triangle of 3 people, one of these people has already flipped and yet you are still calling for my death.

I'll flip Town and you'll be right on Blarg, watch.
 
Sawneeks

Sawneeks

little green dog
Okay, I'm done slamming my head against a Geno shaped wall for a bit. Gonna focus on work and pop in later on.
 
Geno

Geno

Sawneeks how can you say that after I killed 2 of the most undercover scums? I'm not acting like I'm some kind of leader like you and Kalor make me out to be. I will say what I think, people can follow my ideas or dismiss them.
 
Blargonaut

Blargonaut

SCUM UP!
Geno said:
Sawneeks how can you say that after I killed 2 of the most undercover scums? I'm not acting like I'm some kind of leader like you and Kalor make me out to be. I will say what I think, people can follow my ideas or dismiss them.
Click to expand...
names
 
Muffin

Muffin

is being held hostage by Sammi
Blargonaut said:
Geno killed multiple scum? Prove it
Click to expand...
He killed Natiko with his shot today.

You can look at Event 4 and see that he had the antidote and gave it Kawl, which resulted in Apollo, another scum, dying.

That's two. There are other cases where he pushed a scum lynch, dunno if he directly shot scum before that, can't remember.
 
K

Kawl

Owner of the Gun Show
Oh yea I mean geno is town but also a bit off his rocker similar to rage.

His view carries a bit of weight but not enough to really shape my shit or anything.
 
Sorian

Sorian

Neutral Ascetic 1-Shot BP SK Alignment Cop
Staff member
==== DAY 4 VOTES ====
Day Start

sawneeks (2 votes)
geno - #6439
muffin - #6452

lone_prodigy (1 votes)
stanleypalmtree - #5862

extreme tactician (1 votes)
rac - #6190

muffin (1 votes)
natiko - #5824

blargonaut (1 votes)
zubz - #5811

kalor (1 votes)
kawl - #6458

briefs_cat (1 votes)
kalor - #6197
luxcommander - #6199 #6201

natiko (0 votes)
bladesymphony - #5893 #6125

Post Counts:
muffin: 78 blargonaut: 75 melonrabbit: 56 brazil: 51 heymonkey: 48 sawneeks: 48 geno: 42 sorian: 34 kalor: 33 ezekelrage: 33 fandorin: 33 poltergust: 23 kawl: 23 extreme tactician: 23 rac: 22 natiko: 21 luxcommander: 15 zubz: 13 coolestspot: 13 stanleypalmtree: 13 faircure: 12 oreomunsta: 10 bladesymphony: 9 lone_prodigy: 7 swamped: 5 briefs_cat: 4 necktochicken: 3 grizzly: 1 ynnek7: 1 gorlak: 1

Click here to go to the Vote Tool!
 
Muffin

Muffin

is being held hostage by Sammi
Sorian said:
Post Counts:
muffin: 78 blargonaut: 75 melonrabbit: 56 brazil: 51 heymonkey: 48 sawneeks: 48 geno: 42 sorian: 34 kalor: 33 ezekelrage: 33 fandorin: 33 poltergust: 23 kawl: 23 extreme tactician: 23 rac: 22 natiko: 21 luxcommander: 15 zubz: 13 coolestspot: 13 stanleypalmtree: 13 faircure: 12 oreomunsta: 10 bladesymphony: 9 lone_prodigy: 7 swamped: 5 briefs_cat: 4 necktochicken: 3 grizzly: 1 ynnek7: 1 gorlak: 1
Click to expand...
I am post count leader???! The fuck

Also over have the game posts less than the Gamerunner, sad
 
faircure

faircure

if we're talking about sawneeks now can someone actually engage on me on what I was posting about last night about saw passing the antidote to DC in event 4:
faircure said:
The reversal of reads could be notable? It does seem like a lot of the material that she was scumreading on came from d3 not d2 though, and DC wasn't really under fire or anything. Maybe DC was so cautious of creating connections because Saw had already risked passing to him as his teammate? So if he passed to Apollo it'd be a long thread of just all scum?
Click to expand...
the reads I was talking about, first one is right before the event and the second is from last phase:
Sawneeks said:
DCPat (he/him; CEST) - Very short answers and posts in general. However I really like a lot of his logic he presents like pointing out Mazre couldn't see Zipped as Scum but shot him anyway, feeling Stuart is Town due to Ry's actions, and his reasons for townreading Zeke. Likely Town.
Click to expand...

Sawneeks said:
DCPat: Went and read all of his posts. Relatively dislike how he brought up that late votes for the No Lynch in the TD were potentially scum (1025) but never, ever follows up on this idea even though he brought it up again as a semi-defense in a post this Phase (4286). Also gives a very weird and convoluted reason to vote against Faircure, the person he gave the antidote to during the Event (4804) when he says he had zero reason to pick her over Geno, Kawl, or Apollo. It's odd, he's here but not really. Scummy.
Click to expand...

do you all think this is genuine? if not, what reason/motivation would she even have to switch on DC like that?

I feel like talking this out could help me figure out my read.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom