Puppet Mafia | Everyone's wearing socks

[Jeff Tracy]

I'd also be wary of those that amped up their solving to hone in on a potential neutral and not because we flipped scum. Grogu and Triumph come to mind, with Grogu seeming very focused on Kermit.

 

[Pinocchio]

I've seen at least one other person mention the timing of Kutaru's vote on Piggy. Can you elaborate what it is about their timing that alarms you?


I think all normal logic around a question like this has to be thrown away when scum have two accounts. Scum is willing to bus and lose teammates when there's only one life on the table. Throw two into the mix and we're in brand new territory.

Kermit's reaction today just throws me for a loop after this from yesterday:

But now I'm in an awkward position of not wanting to stoke a fire so I dunno. Just gonna step away for a bit and be back later.

Kutaros vote came at a point when the day had been all but decided already, so it wasn't hard to bus at that point.

I don't think Scum having two accounts changes the approach too drastically. There's still the same number of Scum accounts as there would be in a normal game, so losing one still is a detriment.

 

[Randomless]

==== DAY 3 VOTES ====
Day Start

Kermit the Frog (3 votes)
Triumph the Comic Dog - #679
Grogu - #844
Fozzie Bear - #964

Triumph the Comic Dog (1 votes)
Abby Cadabby - #686

Mr. Mew (1 votes)
Lamb Chop - #647

Lamb Chop (1 votes)
Mr. Mew - #634

Grogu (0 votes)
Fozzie Bear - #720 #964
Howdy Doody - #771 #955

Not voting: Kutaro, Jeff Tracy, Kermit the Frog, Charlie McCarthy, Pinocchio, Elmo, Oscar the Grouch, Bert

Post Counts:
Fozzie Bear: 117 Bert: 111 Kermit the Frog: 46 Oscar the Grouch: 39 Abby Cadabby: 36 Jeff Tracy: 25 Howdy Doody: 23 Mr. Mew: 21 Grogu: 20 Lamb Chop: 17 Triumph the Comic Dog: 15 Kutaro: 11 Pinocchio: 7 Elmo: 6 Charlie McCarthy: 3

Current Countdown:

Click here to go to the Vote Tool!

 

[Bert]

I feel particularly good about Jeff, just making good posts. Abby sometimes feels too good to me, but it's going to be a while until I actually suspect Abby.

Pinnoccio finally posted some but not much seems particularly new to the table.

I still want more from Kutaro but I can give them the benefit of the doubt.

I am sorry if your frustration is genuine Kermit, but it's not just the misread, is everything around it that paints the picture.

Vote: Kermit the Frog

 

[Mr. Mew]

Mr. Mew is still my top pick among those names. He defended the Dynamite votes D1 when we now know there was Scum:Miss Piggy on it and also stayed quite while the whole claim debacle happened. Looks to me he was observing which way the wind would go before getting involved.
While I don't really agree with Fozzies play style, I'm not ready to put them in the Scum pile just yet.
Abby was pushing Mew last day phase, so I don't see them being partnered.
I didn't like Kutaro voting me as a prod vote, and only later declaring me as sus to justify it. There was also some soft defending of Miss Piggy D2. Probably number 2 after Mr. Mew for me.

Pinocchio gets bonus points for putting some actual effort in their read of me even if I don't agree. Where did I defend votes on Headdy? For Piggy, I didn't have a lotta time so when I did get here I was focused on Lamb. Then Bert and Fozzie happened :-/

Again:

In a world where I'm scum that needs the heat taken off, Piggy isn't going after the one person yesterday who argued in my favor.

 

[Triumph the Comic Dog]

@Oscar @Charlie @Bert outside of Kermit, who would you vote for?

@Mr. Mew what are your thoughts on Fozzie?

I guess it's pretty clear that Fozzie town reads Mew

Because if both Mr Mew and Fozzie are town, there was only 1 scum (miss Piggy) on Dyna :/

 

[Triumph the Comic Dog]

Sorry, was out for a bit and just saw the kermit stuff. That's *way* too convenient if Kermit can just stop the poisoning. How would that work? If kermit claims he is a 1 shot poisoner than can un-poison a target does that make any sense? I don't think so. I'm liking Bert's ideas more and more

I think I want to vote Kermit

A Kermit that can cure doesn't say this. It's a lie.

So now howdy is just going to be ok, i guess.
VOTE: Kermit the Frog
Smells fishy to me, personally. I believe Howdy

A smattering of reactions to Kermit's gambit

I think Grogu's is the most opportunistic

Let's start another train

VOTE: Grogu

 

[Triumph the Comic Dog]

Kutaro's reaction is also a little like he's waiting for others to vote first

 

[Mr. Mew]

@Oscar @Charlie @Bert outside of Kermit, who would you vote for?

@Mr. Mew what are your thoughts on Fozzie?

I guess it's pretty clear that Fozzie town reads Mew

Because if both Mr Mew and Fozzie are town, there was only 1 scum (miss Piggy) on Dyna :/

Do I lose town points if I say I zoned out on most of Bert and Fozzie yesterday?

Fozzie is trying to solve the game. That's more than some accounts. Players might be solving on their alts in which case you all need to spread out. Fozzie could be scum, I don't think they are, but that's not a flip I'm interested in anytime soon and I'll likely be dead by the time we get to.

 

[Grogu]

A smattering of reactions to Kermit's gambit

I think Grogu's is the most opportunistic

Let's start another train

VOTE: Grogu

When I flip town, who would you think is Scum?

 

[Mr. Mew]

Kutaro's reaction is also a little like he's waiting for others to vote first

Kutaro reads like someone afraid to go against the grain so they test the waters until they know they can swim safely. Lots of gauging other's reactions. This I find interesting

#747

Looking at the wagons currently I like lamb and triumph for scum over the other three.

Still think Pinnochio deserves more attention tho.

#935

Kermit and lamb both seem like good options

@Kutaro Where did Triumph go?

 

[Charlie McCarthy]

@Oscar @Charlie @Bert outside of Kermit, who would you vote for?

@Mr. Mew what are your thoughts on Fozzie?

I guess it's pretty clear that Fozzie town reads Mew

Because if both Mr Mew and Fozzie are town, there was only 1 scum (miss Piggy) on Dyna :/

I'd like to look into Grogu and Kutaro once I have some time.

Also I don't really agree with the Kermit votes and it feels like we're just sleepwalking into a miselimination.

 

[Bert]

@Oscar @Charlie @Bert outside of Kermit, who would you vote for?

@Mr. Mew what are your thoughts on Fozzie?

I guess it's pretty clear that Fozzie town reads Mew

Because if both Mr Mew and Fozzie are town, there was only 1 scum (miss Piggy) on Dyna :/

I feel Fozzie and mew are connected,but for some reason I don't think mew is scum, at least not right now.

It's clear Fozzie and me are always going to be at odds, and I still feel Fozzie has been constantly trying to support Piggy until that didn't work, and then let Kermit live until that didn't work. If we flip Kermit and Kermit is scum I'll be pretty convinced Fozzie is scum too, but that's all getting way ahead of myself and even if Kermit is not scum I'll be sideyeing Fozzie until he is gone, sadly.

But I do admit our fights do bring forward interesting info.

Lamb Chop is dangerous and I wish I could articulate why. The outburst on Oscar in particular read to me like scum getting angry at town clearing people with their roles and using the double account mechanics to their advantage. Dunno, people say Grogu has been opportunistic but I feel that way more about lamb chop.

I 100% agree with the idea that Kutaro reads like they are trying to go with town and agree with as much people as possible.

This is a fun game.

 

[Kutaro]

Kutaro reads like someone afraid to go against the grain so they test the waters until they know they can swim safely. Lots of gauging other's reactions. This I find interesting

#747

#935

@Kutaro Where did Triumph go?

Triumph is a fine vote too. Chances are not all three are scum.

 

[Kutaro]

I'm not sure where people are getting this about me, I feel I've been pretty consistent in who I haven't liked.

 

[Bert]

I'm not sure where people are getting this about me, I feel I've been pretty consistent in who I haven't liked.

Do you mind making a list in a single post?

 

[Kutaro]

Do you mind making a list in a single post?

Sure, I don't like Pinnochio, lamb, triumph. I'm pretty sure there is scum in one of those names.


I'm unsure what to make of Kermit. Honestly the more I think about the timing of his claim it feels like the only alignment that would have reason to claim then is scum. In some weird bid to legitimise piggy's claim.

I also don't like how initially the claim was just kind of thrown out without much commentary and now it's been marketed as Kermit caught scum.

 

[Oscar the Grouch]

vote: Kutaro
I think voting Kermit today is a bad idea. Kutaro is being universally looked at as scummy and I’m not feeling a triumph vote either.

I might miss day end, but I will reread how everything ends up today as soon as possible afterwards

 

[Bert]

Sure, I don't like Pinnochio, lamb, triumph. I'm pretty sure there is scum in one of those names.


I'm unsure what to make of Kermit. Honestly the more I think about the timing of his claim it feels like the only alignment that would have reason to claim then is scum. In some weird bid to legitimise piggy's claim.

I also don't like how initially the claim was just kind of thrown out without much commentary and now it's been marketed as Kermit caught scum.

There was a loooot of commentary about Kermit’s claim and how it related to Piggy, what are you talking about?

 

[Lamb Chop]

I'm still thinking Mr. Mew or Grogu is where scum is tbh.

 

[Charlie McCarthy]

There was a lot of discussion around the claim but Kermit himself was relatively passive in that.

 

[Charlie McCarthy]

Sure, I don't like Pinnochio, lamb, triumph. I'm pretty sure there is scum in one of those names.


I'm unsure what to make of Kermit. Honestly the more I think about the timing of his claim it feels like the only alignment that would have reason to claim then is scum. In some weird bid to legitimise piggy's claim.

I also don't like how initially the claim was just kind of thrown out without much commentary and now it's been marketed as Kermit caught scum.

If Kermit is Scum, why would Scum have a poisoner and a poison mirror?

This whole post reads to me like you want to keep the attention on potential Scum:Kermit to avoid other wagons forming.

vote: Kutaro

 

[Elmo]

There was a loooot of commentary about Kermit’s claim and how it related to Piggy, what are you talking about?

I'm not sure I understand what you're saying?

 

[Elmo]

What Elmo means is Elmo isnt sure what you're saying here and how it relates to what kutaro said. Elmo also struggled with all the back and forth between you and fozzie. Lots of posts about something doesn't mean it's easy to parse everything

 

[Bert]

What Elmo means is Elmo isnt sure what you're saying here and how it relates to what kutaro said. Elmo also struggled with all the back and forth between you and fozzie. Lots of posts about something doesn't mean it's easy to parse everything

There was a lot of discussion around the claim but Kermit himself was relatively passive in that.

I see what you mean, and I assume you read Kutaro's post:

I also don't like how initially the claim was just kind of thrown out without much commentary and now it's been marketed as Kermit caught scum.

As Kutaro doesn't like how Kermit throw the comment and then marketed as Kermit themselves caught scum.

But I read it as Kutaro doesn't like Town didn't comment on it and town marketed it as kermit caught scum.

So I want some clarification from Kutaro.

 

[Jeff Tracy]

Reading over things, I think I want to go with Pinocchio here.
Was calling the Piggy and Dynamite tie as dead air dead villager with 7 mins left, then brings Oscar up as a viable alternative near the end. It's true that they could have gone Dynamite and broken the tie but at the same time I wonder if the pair dynamic made scum more cautious about using one half to save the other with the risk of both going down.
Then early on day 2 they attribute the Piggy wagon as pure - it seems like it most likely was but I wonder if Charlie was obvious at that point?
Then nothing until Piggy's claim, which they cast doubt on the existence of the poisoner/mirror. Since scum would know the poisoner is real, this would be easy position to walk out and once Kermit claims they apply more pressure there than they had to Piggy.
Vote: Pinocchio

 

[Triumph the Comic Dog]

 

[Triumph the Comic Dog]

Man something about Jeff really pings my scumdar

The statement about scum not having both accounts on one vote totally makes sense. But I never thought about it from that perspective. Maybe it gives more credence to the rest of scum being totally off wagon too

 

[Fozzie Bear]

I’m reading the day still but purposely staying out of it (another scum tell I’m sure). I’ve taken up a lot of the day already and I’m appreciating others coming forward now.

The couple things I want to say is: I really don’t like the Kermit vote but it is the best option today. We don’t know 100% that he is a poisoner (only other option is a day vig) but if he is, there is literally no chance he is partnered with Piggy. A lot of his attitudes today also lower his chances of being town and unfortunately, that means he is a neutral and due to how spiteful he is going to feel towards Bert (and now me), I can’t really write off on keeping him alive because he’s just going to kill town again.

Someone did bring up a good point that I saw this morning though. A potential neutral Kermit can’t be a SK that has to survive until final 2 or whatever. His other account has to be able to win as well, they aren’t going to design this game where a single player has to play their two accounts against each other. So he probably does leave early somehow or is actually town which…..man I hope he didn’t play it like this and is town. And don’t anyone start with something dumb like Kermit’s alt is Shang. That would be very bad balance as Kermit could just poison Dynamite and be done with the game on the Shang account.

I also want to comment on Jeff as he has a lot of good articulate posts. I’m town reading him only because he clearly is reading the game and thinking through things but it is perfect enough that I am mildly concerned about it being a false town leader type play. I’m not anywhere near ready to think about that world but it niggles at the back of my mind.

Also people have made ok points about how Kutaro probably isn’t Piggy but I still don’t really buy it. It feels right to me.

 

[Mr. Mew]

Triumph is a fine vote too. Chances are not all three are scum.

Why did Triumph disappear? Who do you think is most likely and least likely scum out of those three?

 

[Mr. Mew]

I see what you mean, and I assume you read Kutaro's post:

As Kutaro doesn't like how Kermit throw the comment and then marketed as Kermit themselves caught scum.

But I read it as Kutaro doesn't like Town didn't comment on it and town marketed it as kermit caught scum.

So I want some clarification from Kutaro.

I read it as Kutaro not liking this from Kermit:

I poisoned N1, Howdy is dying afaik, shot was not refunded. But you know what this is an insane game, Bert, Oscar, Kutaro, Grogu want me out, I'm sorry I caught scum y'all, won't happen again I promise. Like if you all are town then you are playing for the enemy team straight up.

 

[Mr. Mew]

I feel Fozzie and mew are connected,but for some reason I don't think mew is scum, at least not right now.

It's clear Fozzie and me are always going to be at odds, and I still feel Fozzie has been constantly trying to support Piggy until that didn't work, and then let Kermit live until that didn't work. If we flip Kermit and Kermit is scum I'll be pretty convinced Fozzie is scum too, but that's all getting way ahead of myself and even if Kermit is not scum I'll be sideyeing Fozzie until he is gone, sadly.

But I do admit our fights do bring forward interesting info.

Lamb Chop is dangerous and I wish I could articulate why. The outburst on Oscar in particular read to me like scum getting angry at town clearing people with their roles and using the double account mechanics to their advantage. Dunno, people say Grogu has been opportunistic but I feel that way more about lamb chop.

I 100% agree with the idea that Kutaro reads like they are trying to go with town and agree with as much people as possible.

This is a fun game.

I think we saw a genuine scum reaction from Lamb Chop.

 

[Lamb Chop]

I think we saw a genuine scum reaction from Lamb Chop.

Lowkey no matter what I say is a scumtell for you.

 

[Kutaro]

I see what you mean, and I assume you read Kutaro's post:

As Kutaro doesn't like how Kermit throw the comment and then marketed as Kermit themselves caught scum.

But I read it as Kutaro doesn't like Town didn't comment on it and town marketed it as kermit caught scum.

So I want some clarification from Kutaro.

What I meant was the first one. Kermit didn't post his claim like he was actively catching scum. If anything it felt more like trying to give piggy credibility. But now when people have put votes down Kermit is framing it like how can you vote for me I caught scum

 

[Kutaro]

Why did Triumph disappear? Who do you think is most likely and least likely scum out of those three?

Probably because at the time i was thinking more about lamb and kermit. I also think Pinnochio might be scum too. Again I feel like I've been pretty consistent in that even if I haven't listed them every time I've listed people I'm thinking about voting for.

 

[Abby Cadabby]

Reading over things, I think I want to go with Pinocchio here.
Was calling the Piggy and Dynamite tie as dead air dead villager with 7 mins left, then brings Oscar up as a viable alternative near the end. It's true that they could have gone Dynamite and broken the tie but at the same time I wonder if the pair dynamic made scum more cautious about using one half to save the other with the risk of both going down.
Then early on day 2 they attribute the Piggy wagon as pure - it seems like it most likely was but I wonder if Charlie was obvious at that point?
Then nothing until Piggy's claim, which they cast doubt on the existence of the poisoner/mirror. Since scum would know the poisoner is real, this would be easy position to walk out and once Kermit claims they apply more pressure there than they had to Piggy.
Vote: Pinocchio

This seems intriguing, but nothing that yanks me away from our other potential votes for the day. Again though, Pinocchio is a blind spot and at this point it's pure laziness on my part.

Also people have made ok points about how Kutaro probably isn’t Piggy but I still don’t really buy it. It feels right to me.

My Triumph case seems to be held up by a weak belief they are Piggy, which no one else seems to agree with so maybe I need to take the blinders off....But I still fail to see the Kutaro connection. I'm willing to eat my shoe if I'm wrong. Only one of them though.

 

[Abby Cadabby]

I think we saw a genuine scum reaction from Lamb Chop.

I dunno. I should just stfu instead of defending someone I have on my "possibly scum" list but I was also posting worried about the rules in regards to what went down.

What I meant was the first one. Kermit didn't post his claim like he was actively catching scum. If anything it felt more like trying to give piggy credibility. But now when people have put votes down Kermit is framing it like how can you vote for me I caught scum

To Kermit's credit, they did help us catch scum. The fact Kermit's initial post didn't say, "I GOT YOU PIGGY!" -bam counterclaim- doesn't change what their play did. And their posts today don't read to me as if they're trying to frame it that way either. In the heat of the game, Kermit was lashing out at town with what I translate to be: "I help you all out by catching scum and this is how you repay me."

 

[Abby Cadabby]

I'm not swaying anyone with my current vote on Triumph, I find myself nodding with Fozzie's post above, and it's two hours until end of day. I'm sorry, Kermit.

Vote: Kermit the Frog

Not sure I'm going to be back today. I'll try and hang out for another 10-20 if anyone has anything to chat about.

 

[Kutaro]

I dunno. I should just stfu instead of defending someone I have on my "possibly scum" list but I was also posting worried about the rules in regards to what went down.

To Kermit's credit, they did help us catch scum. The fact Kermit's initial post didn't say, "I GOT YOU PIGGY!" -bam counterclaim- doesn't change what their play did. And their posts today don't read to me as if they're trying to frame it that way either. In the heat of the game, Kermit was lashing out at town with what I translate to be: "I help you all out by catching scum and this is how you repay me."

I feel like there was a tonal shift, but yeah it absolutely could just be frustration from town. I get it myself too when people are commenting about the timing of my vote meaning anything. I guess what I keep coming back too is I just don't understand why he claimed there.

 

[Bert]

What I meant was the first one. Kermit didn't post his claim like he was actively catching scum. If anything it felt more like trying to give piggy credibility. But now when people have put votes down Kermit is framing it like how can you vote for me I caught scum

We agree then, OK.

 

[Kermit the Frog]

I'm here but don't care enough to convince anyone to vote elsewhere.

 

[Elmo]

I'm here but don't care enough to convince anyone to vote elsewhere.

Elmo wants to know where you think we should vote?

 

[Charlie McCarthy]

Everybody who votes for Kermit: What do you think their win condition is?

I just really don't see how killing Kermit today helps us when their other account is probably Town and so they would be working towards that win condition as well.

 

[Kutaro]

Everybody who votes for Kermit: What do you think their win condition is?

I just really don't see how killing Kermit today helps us when their other account is probably Town and so they would be working towards that win condition as well.

Well I can tell you that you currently have your vote on town. So if me and Kermit were off the table were would you vote?

 

[Charlie McCarthy]

Well I can tell you that you currently have your vote on town. So if me and Kermit were off the table were would you vote?

Probably Mr. Mew.

Same question to you: If Kermit were off the table, who would you vote for?

 

[Pinocchio]

Reading over things, I think I want to go with Pinocchio here.
Was calling the Piggy and Dynamite tie as dead air dead villager with 7 mins left, then brings Oscar up as a viable alternative near the end. It's true that they could have gone Dynamite and broken the tie but at the same time I wonder if the pair dynamic made scum more cautious about using one half to save the other with the risk of both going down.
Then early on day 2 they attribute the Piggy wagon as pure - it seems like it most likely was but I wonder if Charlie was obvious at that point?
Then nothing until Piggy's claim, which they cast doubt on the existence of the poisoner/mirror. Since scum would know the poisoner is real, this would be easy position to walk out and once Kermit claims they apply more pressure there than they had to Piggy.
Vote: Pinocchio

Tbh, I was entertaining the idea that both Piggy and Kermit were Scum locked in some gambit gone horribly wrong at the time.

 

[Kutaro]

Probably Mr. Mew.

Same question to you: If Kermit were off the table, who would you vote for?

Probably lamb or Pinnochio

 

[Grogu]

Grogu will keep his vote where it is and probably not change by EOD because Grogu is currently moving into new apartment

 

[Bert]

If we are truly considering another train I'll be willing to go for lamb.

 

[Pinocchio]

I'd rather go for Mr. Mew, but I'll take Kutaro as a second

vote: Kutaro

 

[Charlie McCarthy]

I'm not sure where people are getting this about me, I feel I've been pretty consistent in who I haven't liked.

While it is okay to be consistent, Scum is usually more concerned about conserving consistency.

Sure, I don't like Pinnochio, lamb, triumph. I'm pretty sure there is scum in one of those names.


I'm unsure what to make of Kermit. Honestly the more I think about the timing of his claim it feels like the only alignment that would have reason to claim then is scum. In some weird bid to legitimise piggy's claim.

I also don't like how initially the claim was just kind of thrown out without much commentary and now it's been marketed as Kermit caught scum.

This is definitely not a serious post. We've gone over it before, There is no world where Kermit is Scum.

Kutaro has been playing from the sidelines, never rocking the boat. And now again he's pushing for the wagon that's already there without really committing to it.
I am now convinced that this is a fake Puppet.

 

[Lamb Chop]

From Kutaro and Kermit I'd vote Kutaro, at least Kermit was vocal about who they didn't like, Kutaro is much more sneaky.

 

[Pinocchio]

@Fozzie Bear who do you think is Scum in this game?

 

[Fozzie Bear]

Everybody who votes for Kermit: What do you think their win condition is?

I just really don't see how killing Kermit today helps us when their other account is probably Town and so they would be working towards that win condition as well.

Has to be something numbers based. Just a certain amount of players overall or a set number of town and scum. Or just the 10% chance I have him at being town now.

That said though, it is a good shout that he probably doesn’t just kill Bert since his other account has to be town or neutral too (his other account also can’t be scum because of Piggy being a poison mirror).

Bah I keep forgetting to take other accounts into account. I really don’t like Kermit here.

VOTE: Kutaro

Lamb is fine too since they are just a blind spot to me but this is where I live.

 

[Elmo]

From Kutaro and Kermit I'd vote Kutaro, at least Kermit was vocal about who they didn't like, Kutaro is much more sneaky.

I've disliked you very consistently. You've done nothing all game.

 

[Lamb Chop]

I've disliked you very consistently. You've done nothing all game.

List me the things you've done.

 

[Fozzie Bear]

@Fozzie Bear who do you think is Scum in this game?

My thoughts are well worn territory. Asking me again won’t yield a different answer than what I said 24 hours ago.

 

[Bert]

@Fozzie Bear who do you think is Scum in this game?

Why ask Fozzie instead of the tons of other players with far less posts?

 

[Kermit the Frog]

Doing a self preservation vote here and heading to sleep
Vote: Kutaro

 

[Randomless]

==== DAY 3 VOTES ====
Day Start

Kutaro (5 votes)
Oscar the Grouch - #1,018
Charlie McCarthy - #1,022
Pinocchio - #1,050
Fozzie Bear - #1,054
Kermit the Frog - #1,059

Kermit the Frog (3 votes)
Triumph the Comic Dog - #679 #1,007
Grogu - #844
Fozzie Bear - #964 #1,054
Bert - #1,004
Abby Cadabby - #1,038

Mr. Mew (1 votes)
Lamb Chop - #647

Lamb Chop (1 votes)
Mr. Mew - #634

Pinocchio (1 votes)
Jeff Tracy - #1,026

Grogu (1 votes)
Fozzie Bear - #720 #964
Howdy Doody - #771 #955
Triumph the Comic Dog - #1,007

Triumph the Comic Dog (0 votes)
Abby Cadabby - #686 #1,038

Not voting: Kutaro, Elmo

Post Counts:
Fozzie Bear: 120 Bert: 119 Kermit the Frog: 48 Oscar the Grouch: 40 Abby Cadabby: 39 Mr. Mew: 27 Jeff Tracy: 26 Howdy Doody: 23 Grogu: 22 Lamb Chop: 21 Triumph the Comic Dog: 20 Kutaro: 19 Elmo: 10 Pinocchio: 10 Charlie McCarthy: 9

Current Countdown:

Click here to go to the Vote Tool!

 

[Charlie McCarthy]

Why ask Fozzie instead of the tons of other players with far less posts?

Because he was very adamant about voting Kermit for being neutral.

 

[Abby Cadabby]

Oh my god. I finally move my vote off Triumph and you all leave me with my dick in my hand on Kermit.

 

[Bert]

I still think Kermit is the better option

 

[Triumph the Comic Dog]

Kutaro is not a bad vote. Not bad at all

 

[Randomless]

==== DAY 3 VOTES ====
Day Start

Kutaro (5 votes)
Oscar the Grouch - #1,018
Charlie McCarthy - #1,022
Pinocchio - #1,050
Fozzie Bear - #1,054
Kermit the Frog - #1,059

Kermit the Frog (3 votes)
Triumph the Comic Dog - #679 #1,007
Grogu - #844
Fozzie Bear - #964 #1,054
Bert - #1,004
Abby Cadabby - #1,038

Mr. Mew (1 votes)
Lamb Chop - #647

Lamb Chop (1 votes)
Mr. Mew - #634

Pinocchio (1 votes)
Jeff Tracy - #1,026

Grogu (1 votes)
Fozzie Bear - #720 #964
Howdy Doody - #771 #955
Triumph the Comic Dog - #1,007

Triumph the Comic Dog (0 votes)
Abby Cadabby - #686 #1,038

Not voting: Kutaro, Elmo

Post Counts:
Fozzie Bear: 120 Bert: 120 Kermit the Frog: 48 Oscar the Grouch: 40 Abby Cadabby: 40 Mr. Mew: 27 Jeff Tracy: 26 Howdy Doody: 23 Grogu: 22 Triumph the Comic Dog: 21 Lamb Chop: 21 Kutaro: 19 Elmo: 10 Pinocchio: 10 Charlie McCarthy: 10

Current Countdown:

Click here to go to the Vote Tool!

 

[Jeff Tracy]

Tbh, I was entertaining the idea that both Piggy and Kermit were Scum locked in some gambit gone horribly wrong at the time.

Hmm and you're less hot on Kermit today because you were expecting Piggy to flip as something other than what she claimed?

 

[Jeff Tracy]

Any takers for Pinocchio? It's lonely on here.
I'd break a close vote between Kermit and Kutaro by voting Kutaro because I don't think Kermit is ever scum. But Kutaro isn't doing a lot to ping me, they are quiet but I haven't had trouble following where they are in comparison to others.

 

[Pinocchio]

Hmm and you're less hot on Kermit today because you were expecting Piggy to flip as something other than what she claimed?

Pretty much, yeah.

 

[Jeff Tracy]

I could go Grogu here, they haven't really taken the opportunity today to give us a lot of insight and feel like they might be hiding behind the distraction of Kermit's claim to avoid much of any solving.

 

[Kutaro]

Any takers for Pinocchio? It's lonely on here.
I'd break a close vote between Kermit and Kutaro by voting Kutaro because I don't think Kermit is ever scum. But Kutaro isn't doing a lot to ping me, they are quiet but I haven't had trouble following where they are in comparison to others.

I would join you as I've made it clear I think Pinnochio could be scum. But I feel like my only option is to vote Kermit. Though you've already said you'll vote Kermit's way so that feels pointless too.

 

[Kutaro]

I'm going to flip as vanilla town.

 

[Jeff Tracy]

It's funny to think some of the players in my PoE are just the less chatty alt of a player I like.
Anyway I think Grogu is worthy of a look here.
Vote: Grogu

 

[Kutaro]

So in that sense I'm not like a big loss and I fully understand why I'm in with the poe, but when I go just make sure to please look at players like Pinnochio or lamb chop or triumph. I bet anything one of them is scum.

 

[Kutaro]

Unless someone else votes Kermit I won't self pres. I think it's better I flip and town can at least look forward tomorrow then we tie and this is all rehashed again.

 

[Randomless]

==== DAY 3 VOTES ====
Day Start

Kutaro (5 votes)
Oscar the Grouch - #1,018
Charlie McCarthy - #1,022
Pinocchio - #1,050
Fozzie Bear - #1,054
Kermit the Frog - #1,059

Kermit the Frog (3 votes)
Triumph the Comic Dog - #679 #1,007
Grogu - #844
Fozzie Bear - #964 #1,054
Bert - #1,004
Abby Cadabby - #1,038

Grogu (2 votes)
Fozzie Bear - #720 #964
Howdy Doody - #771 #955
Triumph the Comic Dog - #1,007
Jeff Tracy - #1,072

Mr. Mew (1 votes)
Lamb Chop - #647

Lamb Chop (1 votes)
Mr. Mew - #634

Triumph the Comic Dog (0 votes)
Abby Cadabby - #686 #1,038

Pinocchio (0 votes)
Jeff Tracy - #1,026 #1,072

Not voting: Kutaro, Elmo

Post Counts:
Fozzie Bear: 120 Bert: 120 Kermit the Frog: 48 Oscar the Grouch: 40 Abby Cadabby: 40 Jeff Tracy: 30 Mr. Mew: 27 Howdy Doody: 23 Kutaro: 22 Grogu: 22 Triumph the Comic Dog: 21 Lamb Chop: 21 Pinocchio: 11 Elmo: 10 Charlie McCarthy: 10

Current Countdown:

Click here to go to the Vote Tool!

 

[Kutaro]

Goodbye town, I hate you.

 

[Kutaro]

Jeffs eod is Sus.

 

[Randomless]

Day 3 Ends

 

[Randomless]

==== DAY 3 VOTES ====
Day Start - Day End

Kutaro (5 votes)
Oscar the Grouch - #1,018
Charlie McCarthy - #1,022
Pinocchio - #1,050
Fozzie Bear - #1,054
Kermit the Frog - #1,059

Kermit the Frog (3 votes)
Triumph the Comic Dog - #679 #1,007
Grogu - #844
Fozzie Bear - #964 #1,054
Bert - #1,004
Abby Cadabby - #1,038

Grogu (2 votes)
Fozzie Bear - #720 #964
Howdy Doody - #771 #955
Triumph the Comic Dog - #1,007
Jeff Tracy - #1,072

Mr. Mew (1 votes)
Lamb Chop - #647

Lamb Chop (1 votes)
Mr. Mew - #634

Triumph the Comic Dog (0 votes)
Abby Cadabby - #686 #1,038

Pinocchio (0 votes)
Jeff Tracy - #1,026 #1,072

Not voting: Kutaro, Elmo

Post Counts:
Fozzie Bear: 120 Bert: 120 Kermit the Frog: 48 Oscar the Grouch: 40 Abby Cadabby: 40 Jeff Tracy: 30 Mr. Mew: 27 Kutaro: 25 Howdy Doody: 23 Grogu: 22 Triumph the Comic Dog: 21 Lamb Chop: 21 Pinocchio: 11 Elmo: 10 Charlie McCarthy: 10

Current Countdown:

Click here to go to the Vote Tool!

 

[Randomless]

Following a heated discussion, the puppets decided who should lose their head next.

Kutaro has died!

He was…

Welcome to Puppet Mafia!

You are Kutaro. You are aligned with the Good Puppets (that is, TOWN).

You are a sometimes headless boy who was turned into a puppet. It appears you’ve misplaced your magical scissors, the Calibrus, so you lack any magical skills. There’s no heads around for you to use, either.

You are Vanilla.

You have the ability to vote.

You win when all threats to the Good Puppets are eliminated.

Costume Name: Kutaro
Costume Password: no
Game thread is here: https://www.outermafia.com/threads/968/

Good luck and have fun!

Please confirm your Role by replying to this PM or posting in the game thread.

Day 4 begins in:

 

[Randomless]

Actions lock in 2 hours

 

[Randomless]

Actions have locked

 

[Randomless]

The dejected group spent another anxious night worrying. When the morning came, their fears were realized as another puppet was slain.

Charlie McCarthy has died!

He was…

Welcome to Puppet Mafia!

You are Charlie McCarthy. You are aligned with the Good Puppets (that is, TOWN).

A wise-cracking ventriloquist dummy, you enjoy misbehaving when you can. You don’t need any special powers to make jokes.

You are Vanilla.

You have the ability to vote.

You win when all threats to the Good Puppets are eliminated.

Costume Name: Charlie McCarthy
Costume Password: shh
Game thread is here: https://www.outermafia.com/threads/968/

Good luck and have fun!

Please confirm your Role by replying to this PM or posting in the game thread.

Day 4 Begins

Day 4 Ends in:

Vote tool: https://vote.fireblend.com/om/968/

 

[Triumph the Comic Dog]

Slow start huh.

 

[Triumph the Comic Dog]

I'm voting Jeff Tracy or Grogu

Pinocchio is likely a vanilla too

@Kermit the Frog so who's dying today

 

[Triumph the Comic Dog]

Scum felt no pressure yesterday is what we know

 

[Triumph the Comic Dog]

Jeff and lamb chop and Mr Mew vote off wagon. Out of them, I think I feel best about Mr Mew

 

[Triumph the Comic Dog]

I fear Kermit is a mislunch

 

[Oscar the Grouch]

I fear Kermit is a mislunch

I’m not voting Kermit today.

im voting Jeff Tracy.

vote: Jeff Tracy

 

[Jeff Tracy]

Don't have a ton of time to play tonight but I'll check back later.

I'm voting Jeff Tracy or Grogu

Pinocchio is likely a vanilla too

@Kermit the Frog so who's dying today

I fear Kermit is a mislunch

How do you think someone else is dying of poison (meaning Kermit lied about their shots) and also think Kermit is a mislelim?

I’m not voting Kermit today.

im voting Jeff Tracy.

vote: Jeff Tracy

Ok, it would be nice to know why?

 

[Triumph the Comic Dog]

Don't have a ton of time to play tonight but I'll check back later.



How do you think someone else is dying of poison (meaning Kermit lied about their shots) and also think Kermit is a mislelim?

Ok, it would be nice to know why?

Well if someone dies halfway through the day I'll definitely vote for Kermit. But Kermit doesn't have too much recourse here to lie

 

[Triumph the Comic Dog]

VOTE: Jeff Tracy

 

[Triumph the Comic Dog]

Elmo is a total blank box to me, but I think town. Has just been too far removed from the action

 

[Triumph the Comic Dog]

I’m not voting Kermit today.

im voting Jeff Tracy.

vote: Jeff Tracy

Nice to see you alive at least. Assuming you hid behind Kermit from this statement?

 

[Triumph the Comic Dog]

I know people could go for lamb chop too, happy to go that way but I feel stronger about my other two reads

 

[Abby Cadabby]

Nice to see you alive at least. Assuming you hid behind Kermit from this statement?

Lord, I hope not. I thought the assumption was Kermit is neutral at worst, so why waste a check there. And if someone drops dead midday, we can't let Kermit go another day.

Elmo is a total blank box to me, but I think town. Has just been too far removed from the action

Elmo and Kutaro are the only two who didn't vote yesterday. Putting Elmo in my, "might be Kutaro" list to dig into later.

 

[Abby Cadabby]

Well if someone dies halfway through the day I'll definitely vote for Kermit. But Kermit doesn't have too much recourse here to lie

And this is why I need to not read posts backwards from newest to oldest......Swear I'm not just copy/pasting your posts.

 

[Triumph the Comic Dog]

And this is why I need to not read posts backwards from newest to oldest......Swear I'm not just copy/pasting your posts.

Well I have a bad habit of reading only the posts that quote me and then forgetting to go back and read the rest lol

 

[Abby Cadabby]

We got Miss Piggy. That's big. I feel like we made the flip and haven't achieved anything with info from that flip yet. So, staying positive and going back in to revisit everyone.

 

[Oscar the Grouch]

Nice to see you alive at least. Assuming you hid behind Kermit from this statement?

I didn’t hide last night.