Puppet Mafia | Everyone's wearing socks

Triumph the Comic Dog

Triumph the Comic Dog

Costume
I still don't want to believe that Abby is scum, but going back to a theory I proposed way back, it's hard to believe that the Oscar train from D1 is totally pure, which means Abby is scum (the reason I pulled back from this theory was because I started focusing on the off wagon voters from D1)
 
Fozzie Bear

Fozzie Bear

Costume
It's only been like 15 minutes but I shouldn't need to state the obvious that we are now in territory where scum can immediately end the game unless at least 1 of: Fozzie, Abby, or Jeff are scum.
 
Randomless

Randomless

==== DAY 7 VOTES ====
Day Start

Abby Cadabby (2 votes)
Fozzie Bear - #1,641
Jeff Tracy - #1,701

Fozzie Bear (1 votes)
Abby Cadabby - #1,645

Not voting: Lamb Chop, Elmo, Triumph the Comic Dog

Post Counts:
Triumph the Comic Dog: 21 Fozzie Bear: 18 Abby Cadabby: 14 Jeff Tracy: 11 Elmo: 9 Lamb Chop: 5

Current Countdown:
4vhm3s5p4g



Click here to go to the Vote Tool!
 
Jeff Tracy

Jeff Tracy

Costume
I won't lie I had an unvote lined up and had been refreshing every few minutes in case the 3rd vote and 4th vote came in too quick but I'm tired now and this looks right.
 
Randomless

Randomless

The puppets finally discovered the true perpetrator, the one in charge of organizing it all…

Abby Cadabby has died!

He was…
Welcome to Puppet Mafia!

You are Master Hand. You are aligned with the Bad Puppets (that is, MAFIA).

Your team-mates are [REDACTED]. You share a chat with them and may talk with them at any time.

A self-described master of puppets, you are the mastermind behind the organization of the Bad Puppets. You have many abilities that will come in handy as you pick off the goodie two-shoes.

You are a Jack-of-all-Trades (JOAT). You have three 1-shot skills:

1-Shot Ninja Kill: During the Night Phase, you may use the command Ninja Kill: <player> to perform a ninja kill instead of the regular factional kill. This action will take the place of the factional kill for that Night Phase.

1-Shot Strong Kill: During the Night Phase, you may use the command Strong Kill: <player> to perform a strong kill instead of the regular factional kill. This action will take the place of the factional kill for that Night Phase.

1-Shot Roleblock: During the Night Phase, you may use the command Roleblock: <player> to roleblock your target.

You can also use the standard Mafia factional kill.

You may only use one skill per Night Phase. You cannot Roleblock and perform the factional kill on the same night, unless you are the only member of the Bad Puppets still left alive.

You have the ability to vote.

You can use the fake role name of Abby Cadabby, as well as the Abby Cadabby costume account.

You win when the Bad Puppets control 50% of the votes.

Costume Name: Abby Cadabby
Costume Password: na-uh
Game thread is here: https://www.outermafia.com/threads/968/
Scum thread is here: no

Good luck and have fun!

Please confirm your Role by replying to this PM or posting in the game thread.
Click to expand...
MH-dead.webp


Two separate questions for the remaining players:
1. Would you like to skip this night phase and start the day immediately upon confirmation of actions?
2. Would you like to switch to 24 hour days?

You can reply to me in private or in the thread. If you don't answer I will take it as a no.
 
Last edited:
Randomless

Randomless

Another successful day for the Good Puppets, but another deadly night from the Bad Puppets. This grand show was finally drawing to a close…

Fozzie Bear has died!

They were…
Welcome to Puppet Mafia!

You are Fozzie Bear. You are aligned with the Good Puppets (that is, TOWN).

You are an ineffective stand-up comedian who is infamous within the Muppet world. Your “abilities”, if you can even call them that, are a bit of a joke. Wocka wocka!

You are Vanilla.

You have the ability to vote.

You win when all threats to the Good Puppets are eliminated.

Costume Name: Fozzie Bear
Costume Password: excusez-moi
Game thread is here: https://www.outermafia.com/threads/968/

Good luck and have fun!

Please confirm your Role by replying to this PM or posting in the game thread.
Click to expand...

Day 8 Begins

Day 8 Ends in:
3z1izwlgef


Vote tool: https://vote.fireblend.com/om/968/
 
Triumph the Comic Dog

Triumph the Comic Dog

Costume
I can only conclude that I'm alive because I can't decide. Fozzie was pretty clear on lamb chop being scum looking at their posts from yesterday. I will probably vote there but want to wait for everyone to check in
 
Elmo

Elmo

Costume
Triumph the Comic Dog said:
Man I'm really thinking Jeff but still not sure between him and lamb chop. I do think elmo is town though
Click to expand...

There is no way I'm not voting lamb. I absolutely believe scum were trying to protect each other. Abby's insistence that lamb was town and the vote had to be one of me, Jeff or fozzie, combined with lambs weird gotcha attempt on me just all adds up. If lamb was town there was absolutely no reason to take the tone and approach they did yesterday. By all means let's let everyone check in but I'm 100% sold on lamb and if it's you or Jeff then fair play.
 
Jeff Tracy

Jeff Tracy

Costume
Lamb makes the most sense to me too. Abby going along with Elmo's case on Fozzie didn't feel like something you would do with a team mate yesterday.
Triumph is more vibes for me than anything else, the way she's put her thoughts down all game feels real.
 
Triumph the Comic Dog

Triumph the Comic Dog

Costume
I do think it's a fantastic play with lamb and mew voting each other all game. I reread those parts and I do think those could have been manufactured.

Alright then

VOTE: Lamb Chop
 
Randomless

Randomless

The puppets, weary and tired, gathered one last time to choose their final victim.

Lamb Chop has died!

He was...
Welcome to Puppet Mafia!

You are Lamb Chop. You are aligned with the Good Puppets (that is, TOWN).

Very intuitive and feisty, you’ve been in the puppet game for a long time. You starred in your own show and won five Emmy’s before some of these other puppets had even been born. You don’t need any special skills to get the job done.

You are Vanilla.

You have the ability to vote.

You win when all threats to the Good Puppets are eliminated.

Costume Name: Lamb Chop
Costume Password:
Game thread is here: https://www.outermafia.com/threads/968/

Good luck and have fun!

Please confirm your Role by replying to this PM or posting in the game thread.
Click to expand...

Day 9 begins when actions are in
 
Randomless

Randomless

Just then, Jeff Tracy began to laugh. Not just any laugh, but a maniacal, terrifying laugh.

"We did it my brethren! We rid the world of these loathsome puppets."

Elmo has died!

She was...
Welcome to Puppet Mafia!

You are Elmo. You are aligned with nobody (that is, NEUTRAL).

You are Mr. Bigtime himself, headlining your own show that brings in the dough. You don’t need any of these other puppets, you can handle things yourself.

You are a Survivor. You win if you survive to the end of the game.

You have the ability to vote.

Costume Name: Elmo
Costume Password:
Game thread is here: https://www.outermafia.com/threads/968/

Good luck and have fun!

Please confirm your Role by replying to this PM or posting in the game thread.
Click to expand...
elmo-beating.gif


Jeff Tracy has won!

He was...
Welcome to Puppet Mafia!

You are Jigsaw. You are aligned with the Bad Puppets (that is, MAFIA).

Your team-mates are [REDACTED]. You share a chat with them and may talk with them at any time.

When the Bad Puppets invited you along to torture some folks, you just couldn’t turn them down. You’re sure to have an explosively good time.

You are a Vote Bomb. If you are voted out during the Day Phase, the final voter on your wagon is also killed. The vote does not need to be a majority.

You can use the standard Mafia factional kill.

You have the ability to vote.

You can use the fake role name of Jeff Tracy, as well as the Jeff Tracy costume account.

You win when the Bad Puppets control 50% of the votes.

Costume Name: Jeff Tracy
Costume Password:
Game thread is here: https://www.outermafia.com/threads/968/
Scum thread is here: not a chance

Good luck and have fun!

Please confirm your Role by replying to this PM or posting in the game thread.
Click to expand...
im-here-jigsaw.gif


Triumph the Comic Dog has died!

She was...
Welcome to Puppet Mafia!

You are Triumph the Insult Comic Dog. You are aligned with the Good Puppets (that is, TOWN).

You love telling jokes and insulting people, but you don’t have any particular skills otherwise.

You are Vanilla.

You have the ability to vote.

You win when all threats to the Good Puppets are eliminated.

Costume Name: Triumph the Insult Comic Dog
Costume Password:
Game thread is here: https://www.outermafia.com/threads/968/

Good luck and have fun!

Please confirm your Role by replying to this PM or posting in the game thread.
Click to expand...

The Bad Puppets have won!
 
Randomless

Randomless

Congratulations to scum and to Shang for winning! Drumroll please, here's the big reveal of the pairs and the real accounts:

Lamb Chop & Kermit the Frog - Geno
Topo Gigio & Oscar the Grouch - Zippedpinhead
Triumph the Insult Comic Dog & Howdy Doody - Swamped
Charlie McCarthy & Pinocchio - malus
Dynamite Headdy & Grogu - Zookfoodle
Kutaro & Elmo - AllThingsPurple
Fozzie Bear & Shang Bu Huan (aka Sha Wu Sheng) - Sorian
Bert & Ernie - SalvaPot
Abby Cadabby (aka Master Hand) & Mr. Mew (aka Cait Sith) - VincentAlexander
Jeff Tracy (aka Jigsaw) & Miss Piggy (aka Puppet Ganon) - The Wizard
 
Last edited:
Donnie

Donnie

Mafia, pocketed, or dead N1
Chuggernaut said:
*pulls off Sam Eagle head*

Boards should be open now
Click to expand...

*also pulls off Sam Eagle Head*

Damn, it was stuffy in there together. Very fun game to watch over lol so sad Elmo fell so close to victory!! Well done scum, hard luck town! And congrats on such a cool design Random! And congrats for your neutral win Sorian!
 
Shang Bu Huan

Shang Bu Huan

Costume
Abby Cadabby said:
Oh my god. Bert and Ernie really was the same player!
Click to expand...
Salva was not my guess but he also qualifies for someone that will always hate me regardless of if I'm in costume or not lol

------


I didn't bother trying to guess anyone either. Did anyone try to guess who I was impersonating day 1 on Fozzie?
 
Chuggernaut

Chuggernaut

HONK HONK MF
Shang Bu Huan said:
Salva was not my guess but he also qualifies for someone that will always hate me regardless of if I'm in costume or not lol

------


I didn't bother trying to guess anyone either. Did anyone try to guess who I was impersonating day 1 on Fozzie?
Click to expand...

is that f8shirou i'm seeing
 
Abby Cadabby

Abby Cadabby

Costume
Jeff/Wiz: it was a delight. I loved having a scummate who put up with my silly and nonsense. You were a great partner for getting down to business with overnight analysis on who we should kill because I was mostly pulling my choices out of my rearend. Couldn't have done it without you and your smart choices. My only regret is we didn't get to watch you go boom.

Also: I take the blame for the poison flub. It worked out well with the confusion it caused, but yeah....that was on me lol

Chuggernaut said:
*pulls off Sam Eagle head*

Boards should be open now
Click to expand...
Donnie said:
*also pulls off Sam Eagle Head*

Damn, it was stuffy in there together. Very fun game to watch over lol so sad Elmo fell so close to victory!! Well done scum, hard luck town! And congrats on such a cool design Random! And congrats for your neutral win Sorian!
Click to expand...
Sam Eagle is lucky my teammate showed you two mercy.
 
Abby Cadabby

Abby Cadabby

Costume
Shang Bu Huan said:
Vincent knows the exact way to pull my heartstrings, I had no idea
Click to expand...
I try to play scum like I would as town as much as possible, and I latched onto you the most because I really jelled with all your posts. It's weird being scum, reading a player you know is town, and thinking, "ooh. That's a bit scummy." But with Shang, Charlie, and Fozzie I was digging their vibe thinkin, "oh yeah. These people are town" so I went with it. (Not that I didn't like other posts). But you yoinked me in. If Abby were town, she'd have been with you all the way to the grave.

But truly, a lot of my posts woulda been very similar if town (minus my 'hunting' ones). I meant it when I was rooting for town to pull themselves back up and keep at it when ya'll seemed a bit de-energized. Then town came back with a furious vengeance. I overestimated my ability to yap out of a bad situation, but lack of time and focus got me. And that's not to take away from town's awesome work because it was obvious a lotta people were busy as hell too (like moving!)

My scum play is gonna bite me in the ass next time I'm town. This is my pre-game apology for when that time comes.
 
Geno

Geno

Damn it, wish I didn't have to go to sleep before day start, maybe I could've salvaged this, then again we were in a 2-1-1 situation.
 
Geno

Geno

Oh ofc Bert and Ernie were shared and of course it was Salvapot, the only player who changed pfp is the same one that did so in Mafia All Stars for the costume.
 
Pinocchio

Pinocchio

Costume
Really interesting concept and a fun game. GG to Scum for pulling it over the finish line.

It was more difficult than I had expected to juggle two accounts, and it also didn't make it easier to keep track of all players, but I still had lots of fun this game.
 
Abby Cadabby

Abby Cadabby

Costume
Elmo said:
I should have sat back and just let the day play out, triumph wanted Jeff still maybe there is a chance lamb does enough to swing the vote that way.

Trouble was i was so convinced lamb was scum :thisisfine:
Click to expand...
That's town talk! Elmo was a neutral trying to survive, and Elmo survived! The last night was a flip of a coin who Jeff/Wiz killed after it was already over. In my mind, you won it. Don't you worry about those annoying town players. Those muppets all got what they deserved. Elmo knows it deep down in Elmo's cold, fuzzy heart.
 
Fozzie Bear

Fozzie Bear

Costume
Elmo said:
I should have sat back and just let the day play out, triumph wanted Jeff still maybe there is a chance lamb does enough to swing the vote that way.

Trouble was i was so convinced lamb was scum :thisisfine:
Click to expand...
The scary issue is if you had sat back and they had flipped to Jeff, you might have been the hammer vote and died anyway. For how well you did all game, you were in a tough position at the end.
 
Fozzie Bear

Fozzie Bear

Costume
If I had stayed alive I was going to push for a no vote, make Jeff bring it to a final 3. Still think it would have been the same end sadly but would have been a fun rocking of the boat that last day.
 
Bert

Bert

Costume
Geno said:
Oh ofc Bert and Ernie were shared and of course it was Salvapot, the only player who changed pfp is the same one that did so in Mafia All Stars for the costume.
Click to expand...
I don't know how you didn't figure it out, I never made an effort to hide it.
 
Jeff Tracy

Jeff Tracy

Costume
Fun and unique game, thanks Rando, players and game watchers! My favorite part was matching up the pairs.
Shang Bu Huan said:
I didn't bother trying to guess anyone either. Did anyone try to guess who I was impersonating day 1 on Fozzie?
Click to expand...
I was pretty bad at finding the players but I think I had Fozzie down as maybe nin on day 1?
Abby Cadabby said:
Jeff/Wiz: it was a delight. I loved having a scummate who put up with my silly and nonsense. You were a great partner for getting down to business with overnight analysis on who we should kill because I was mostly pulling my choices out of my rearend. Couldn't have done it without you and your smart choices. My only regret is we didn't get to watch you go boom.

Also: I take the blame for the poison flub. It worked out well with the confusion it caused, but yeah....that was on me lol
Click to expand...
You were a great team mate and really set the tone for the whole game.
I loved that you thought in terms of what would make the game more exciting / entertaining and lift the energy in the room.
And I wouldn't worry on the poison, I think you were a lot more proficient with the hopping between accounts and having to play out more as Piggy would have just gotten me tangled up.
Elmo said:
I've finally got over my botch job at end game and came to tell everyone GG, was really fun. Thanks Random for running it.
Click to expand...
There was no botch job, you played great and were in the ideal position for the whole run of the game. I wish I thought for a few moments on why Rando was asking me to choose the kill instead of just automating it, woulda happily stabbed Triumph at the end instead but at the time it was just quicker to type Elmo lol
 
Jeff Tracy

Jeff Tracy

Costume
Pinocchio said:
Really interesting concept and a fun game. GG to Scum for pulling it over the finish line.

It was more difficult than I had expected to juggle two accounts, and it also didn't make it easier to keep track of all players, but I still had lots of fun this game.
Click to expand...
You were scary on that last day, looking at your reads in spec I have no regrets over pulling the triple stack to push you out >:D
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom