Game Thread Marvel Heroes Mafia - Half of You Will Enjoy This

heymonkey

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
Fandorin said:
Surprised that monkey went for the cop item as she did. Thought that as town she’d follow me into the strong kill or picked a easier item instead, knowing that the cop item would be the most picked one. Doesn’t affect my town read on her much.
Click to expand...
I was hoping it would be so obvious and so desired that no one else would pick it. Also I just really want to check Gorlak's alignment.
 
EzekelRAGE

EzekelRAGE

*truffleshuffle*
Brazil said:
giphy.gif
Click to expand...
Me and you will just have to agree to disagree.
I can't even defend anything because you are grasping at straws, based on no facts.
You say a quick post saying go ahead is some mastermind post detailed to make everyone claim what they did first.

I can argue all day about my reasoning for voting or my theories.

But I cant argue about you seeing stuff that isnt there or seeing so much in a post with so little.
CharmingUnderstatedAlaskanmalamute.gif
 
melonrabbit

melonrabbit

The only good kind of melon
Okay but does any of this have to do with me or Kawl or linking us together?

If you're so intrested in who was attacked last night why don't you talk to Zeke.
 
Sawneeks

Sawneeks

little green dog
Gorlak said:
@Sawneeks I'm also interested in why you townread faircure, but maybe some older posts of yours will deliver the answer.

All in all I again have a problem with a certain part of this readlist, but here I don't want to go into detail yet. If you remember last time I also said that there was something up with your list and it was about your read on me specifically

In an earlier look at Grizzly votes you find my vote weird: #1777 - yet later you town read me amongst other things because of the Grizzly situation:
Click to expand...

Dunno if I have said it elsewhere but I Townread her sudden willingness to claim during the Event. It was unnecessary and seemed like a very Townie thing to do.

And I'll be honest I likely forgot that information. It's been difficult to keep up and compound both D1 and D2 info.

NZJubJub said:
Third point (concerning #1169): Apologies as I have no idea what you mean here, also the phrase "doesn't matter" does not appear in that post.
Click to expand...

You accuse Zipped of doing the same exact thing you were doing. However, for Zipped it was 'scummy' but for you it was not.


Muffin said:
Well good thing I took a break from pushing there, as Kawl got green checked. It's called not tunneling. My shot at Kawl was to try to pursue that push a bit more at the time while others were resolving the Vere/Zipped situation as I didn't really know who of the two to believe. Got pretty clear because of Veres reactions during the ITA phase though. After that, I took my focus off of Kawl as Vere survived the first ITA phase and that situation needed to be resolved.
Click to expand...

No offense but that's all with the benefit of hindsight now. You weren't even remotely tunneling, you hadn't even picked up a shovel to start digging the tunnel at all. You dropped a vote on him, shot him, and that's about it. You didn't question, follow up on stuff - nothing.

heymonkey said:
Just caught up to the ITA:

We have people who are completely unreadable due to being so inactive and so nonparticipative and y'all shoot someone who was at least trying? Giving reactions and more that might become something we could read?

tumblr_p83xtli0rb1r399heo1_500.gif
Click to expand...

look at me right in the eyes and tell me you could confidently read nomad's anything.

Muffin said:
Hm, interesting. What makes you town read Zeke in particular? I have a blind spot there.

And I see people scumread Blarg, what's the reason for that? I did notice that Blarg is more passive than the last time I played with him, but besides that Blarg seems normal.
Click to expand...

Fandorin said:
Blarg's wagon is pretty bad to me. Might be missing some of the more compelling posts on it, but from what I've seen the case against him is mostly meta based, which I'll be trying to avoid at my best after the ass whopping we had on Power Rangers Mafia.
Click to expand...

Go and read over any of his posts. They are nonsense, have no cohesion, and aren't scum hunting. He's simply making noise.

Blargonaut said:
If someone has another Thunderdome power that doesn't involve themselves, please trap Sawneeks and Gorlak, thanks
Click to expand...

As amusing as I fight this idea how about no
 
Sawneeks

Sawneeks

little green dog
Also to reiterate because some people are giving Blarg a pass for some weird ass reason:

Sawneeks said:
Gonna head to bed, if there is anyone folks want me to elaborate on just ask and I'll try to get to it before Day End.

For now I'm fine with staying on Blarg. He makes a lot of noise but little of it is helpful or constructive and is simply there. Still think his shot at Nomad yesterday was an easy out without not taking a shot and his brief thoughts here and there or not very consistent and feels like he simply shows up to make himself a presence. Basically he isn't interested in Scum hunting, only looking like he is playing.
Click to expand...
 
melonrabbit

melonrabbit

The only good kind of melon
Since Blarg isnt playing anymore. I should probably get back to work.

As far as rivlaries go:

I'd vote Alexm over Blarg.

I'd vote Brazil before Zeke.

I'd weed out LP and on the off chance someone wants to get this Sawneeks train going, I'll be over here.
 
heymonkey

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
Sneeks: I will look you right in the eye and tell you I believe Nomad is most likely town in any situation and I’m not particularly worried about him if he’s not.

It was a dumb shot. There were better targets.
 
Brazil

Brazil

EzekelRAGE said:
Me and you will just have to agree to disagree.
I can't even defend anything because you are grasping at straws, based on no facts.
You say a quick post saying go ahead is some mastermind post detailed to make everyone claim what they did first.

I can argue all day about my reasoning for voting or my theories.

But I cant argue about you seeing stuff that isnt there or seeing so much in a post with so little.
CharmingUnderstatedAlaskanmalamute.gif
Click to expand...
I swear, if I had a coin for each time someone tries to counter one of my theories with "You're saying I had a masterplan" despite the fact that I never claim that...

Sawneeks said:
Also to reiterate because some people are giving Blarg a pass for some weird ass reason:
Click to expand...
Yes. Blarg's at best someone who's being completely unhelpful at every level.
 
Sawneeks

Sawneeks

little green dog
heymonkey said:
Sneeks: I will look you right in the eye and tell you I believe Nomad is most likely town in any situation and I’m not particularly worried about him if he’s not.

It was a dumb shot. There were better targets.
Click to expand...

Despite the fact he had a gun every phase with a 15% chance to kill anyone he wanted?

whatever. agree to disagree.

melonrabbit said:
Is that the only comment of his that stood out to you?
Click to expand...

Yes. The rest of it was noise.
 
Yuta

Yuta

~ the mysterious adventures of a man who wandered Cthulhu island ~

first act - a loud intro (20min)
Lone Stranger said:
Vote: Include
Click to expand...
Blargonaut said:
WHAT'S YOUR POINT
Click to expand...

second act - taking some time (60min)
Lone Stranger said:
Howdy Partner: Natiko
Click to expand...
Blargonaut said:
It is?
That can't be right
I remember you
Click to expand...

third act - the big reversal (20min)
Blargonaut said:
Is it ITA time????
Click to expand...
Lone Stranger said:
Vote: Nomad Sparkster
Click to expand...

fourth act - timezones (90min)
Blargonaut said:
hey
signed up for the event
Promptly forgot I did
MVP
Click to expand...
Lone Stranger said:
Vote: nzjubjub
Click to expand...

finale - caught in the act (6min)
Lone Stranger said:
Vote: rac
Click to expand...
Blargonaut said:
not big enough
I'm not here to entertain you sry
Click to expand...

-------------
yeah pretty sure blarg is/has control over the lone stranger
 
Brazil

Brazil

Gorlak said:
~ the mysterious adventures of a man who wandered Cthulhu island ~

first act - a loud intro (20min)



second act - taking some time (60min)


third act - the big reversal (20min)


fourth act - timezones (90min)



finale - caught in the act (6min)



-------------
yeah pretty sure blarg is/has control over the lone stranger
Click to expand...
Ha, goddamn.
 
Yuta

Yuta

^ this is every instance of the lone stranger appearing
blarg posted one or two times outside these apperances as well, but only very little
 
Kalor

Kalor

Kay-lor? Kah-lor?
Depending on Alexems response, I might move over to Blarg. Showing up and being vague isn't helping anyone. Although if they control the Lone Stranger that muddies the waters as I don't know if scum would have two NPCs that they can use.
 
EzekelRAGE

EzekelRAGE

*truffleshuffle*
Brazil said:
I swear, if I had a coin for each time someone tries to counter one of my theories with "You're saying I had a masterplan" despite the fact that I never claim that...
Click to expand...
uhm I don't want to make a big wall of text of you post. But you laid a pretty elaborate theory based on my saying "go ahead" and "I went for cop item"

So yea, I would call that masterplan status.
 
LuxCommander

LuxCommander

Bro.
Zippedpinhead said:
I am so so confused here...

Luxcommander why did you say I was jailed?
Click to expand...

Zippedpinhead said:
I got "no result", but Luxcommander posted me being jailed before I mentioned how my result was returned.
Click to expand...

Because you were in Jail. I listened to what happened to you last night. You were placed in jail, and then someone tried to kill you. You survived because that's how jail works in Mafia; those in jail can't be killed and cannot use their abilities. I did not put you there, I simply followed you.
 
Brazil

Brazil

EzekelRAGE said:
uhm I don't want to make a big wall of text of you post. But you laid a pretty elaborate theory based on my saying "go ahead" and "I went for cop item"

So yea, I would call that masterplan status.
Click to expand...
The size of my theory says nothing about your intent or lack thereof. I analyzed the sequence of events. I never claimed that you had a masterplan - it's actually the exact other way around. If I'm right, you fucked up from the get-go.
 
melonrabbit

melonrabbit

The only good kind of melon
LuxCommander said:
Because you were in Jail. I listened to what happened to you last night. You were placed in jail, and then someone tried to kill you. You survived because that's how jail works in Mafia; those in jail can't be killed and cannot use their abilities. I did not put you there, I simply followed you.
Click to expand...

You listened.

You keep using that word. Shouldn't it be watched, tracked, etc.
 
Zippedpinhead

Zippedpinhead

Zip it!
LuxCommander said:
Because you were in Jail. I listened to what happened to you last night. You were placed in jail, and then someone tried to kill you. You survived because that's how jail works in Mafia; those in jail can't be killed and cannot use their abilities. I did not put you there, I simply followed you.
Click to expand...
I know the jailer and I had a long conversation on why I was in jail and what to do with today. and the jailer also said who he jailed (or attempted to jail) the previous night. It wasn't you, and I never saw your Listen claim.
 
Natiko

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Muffin said:
You're conveniently ignoring that I pushed Rynam and especially Include. So your nice little read here looks incriminating out of context, good job.

And no shit is my view that this specific lynch looks like it's going too fast not an objective truth but my subjective view, my "feels". Tell me something new.

If I don't like Alexems answer to all this I'll be happy to lynch him, and if he turns out town, I'll be happy to look at you lot pushing this lynch so hard without an answer yet. It's win-win.
Click to expand...
This is like, the scummiest thing lol

rac said:
brazil lynch>alexem lynch>ezekel lynch
Click to expand...
I know some already asked about this some, but is the Brazil read gut or? I don't recall you talking about it much before.

Brazil said:
As I was saying, the difference is that the real townie play after trying and failing to grab the cop check, as seemingly demonstrated by Monkey and Coolest, was to immediately reveal that information as soon as the event ended.

Instead, you came back into the thread with a careful post not revealing anything about yourself, but asking others to do it.

There's a huge difference between being open from the get-go and withholding information. It could be just an unfortunate misstep, sure. But you had the opportunity to make the perfect town play, as Monkey and Coolest did, and you didn't. Maybe because you couldn't.

You could argue that I was the same because I was waiting for everyone else to claim first - but you can't verify that like I can with your post at Gorlak. And, as a townie, I had no reason to pressure anyone to reveal their info before I did. If you are scum, you had a reason to do just that.


I disagree. The way people do things is something I always look out for. It's not a factor I base my arguments on, but it's something that reinforces them.

I'm not interested in debating methodology, though.
Click to expand...
I do see the point you're making on Ezekiel and how he generally was a bit more passive during this exchange than I would've expected. That being said I still find it very unlikely he's scum for the same reasons I find it unlikely melon is. I just don't see scum risking as good a role as Splinter had that early when he was widely town read.

Gorlak said:
@rac came in and tried to downtalk the Alexem issue

rac also asked why revealing the items matters, but nobody reacted

I can only guess that lone stranger wants us to discuss this?
Click to expand...
I clearly need to find out where you learned the art of translating votes into thoughts.

Blargonaut said:
I'm not divulging shit you're gonna have to kill me and make sure I stay dead
Click to expand...
Blarg is taking his ball and going home apparently.

NeckToChicken said:
What.

Pardon me while I go shriek in the bathroom.
Click to expand...
lol Do you have anything to add besides your misinterpretation?

Blargonaut said:
One of them is feeding Natiko lines under the table
Click to expand...
Oh no. Error, error. Beep boop, human is aware. Error, my code is showing. Error, error.

Really though what do you mean? The Lone Stranger or scum?

heymonkey said:
Sneeks: I will look you right in the eye and tell you I believe Nomad is most likely town in any situation and I’m not particularly worried about him if he’s not.

It was a dumb shot. There were better targets.
Click to expand...
Until the day I actually get to see scum Nomad I'll probably always end up town reading his floundering. He's done it too many times at this point for it to be a fluke. That being said, it was odd that he suddenly started trying. That sounds bad, but it was something I'm not sure I'd ever seen. He was oddly coherent during that section too. That being said most people (or any?) didn't point to that as their concern, instead they referenced his play the entire game so it's a bit of a moot point.
 
Zippedpinhead

Zippedpinhead

Zip it!
utlimately, I think you are alright Luxcommander, just wanted to understand the situation better.

I guess back to these tri thunderdome messes?
 
heymonkey

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
Sneeks: if you gave me a gun with three shots and put me in a room with briefs_cat, LP, Oreo, and Nomad, Nomad is the one I leave alive. Unless we are close to lylo and then I leave LP alive.

Oreo is proven as slippery. No clue where he is in this game, if he’s just busy or not.

NO read on briefs_cat whatsoever. Could be just not playing, could be active in scumchat. No minimum here means no way of knowing.

This game is perfect for LP to hide in if scum.

Nomad can bumble around and maybe kill one person, and maybe it’s a good shot, maybe it’s a terrible shot, but unless we are approaching endgame it’s a waste.

It’s also such an obvious play that the shots are NAI so we lose the ability to read those people who shot him because of it. Or rather can’t use that as a factor.
 
Brazil

Brazil

Zippedpinhead said:
I still don't know how luxcommander knew something that only me and the jailer knew...
Click to expand...
It's pretty clear that Lux is a watcher. The role itself is NAI, but despite believing the claim at first, its timing did seem a bit strange. I think the very fact that Zipped had survived the night while being roleblocked was all the information we needed on that sequence of events.
 
Muffin

Muffin

is being held hostage by Sammi
I went away to eat and Alexem still hasn't shown. This is getting dumb.

Quick warning: I have to get up early tomorrow so I won't be around till day end. Will leave a vote before that though.
 
Brazil

Brazil

Natiko said:
I do see the point you're making on Ezekiel and how he generally was a bit more passive during this exchange than I would've expected. That being said I still find it very unlikely he's scum for the same reasons I find it unlikely melon is. I just don't see scum risking as good a role as Splinter had that early when he was widely town read.
Click to expand...
That's fair. I'll go back and reread that part of the game again later.
 
Sawneeks

Sawneeks

little green dog
melonrabbit said:
I believe he was serious on linking me and Kawl. Why I don't know.
Click to expand...

And you trust him on this because....?

heymonkey said:
Sneeks: if you gave me a gun with three shots and put me in a room with briefs_cat, LP, Oreo, and Nomad, Nomad is the one I leave alive. Unless we are close to lylo and then I leave LP alive.

Oreo is proven as slippery. No clue where he is in this game, if he’s just busy or not.

NO read on briefs_cat whatsoever. Could be just not playing, could be active in scumchat. No minimum here means no way of knowing.

This game is perfect for LP to hide in if scum.

Nomad can bumble around and maybe kill one person, and maybe it’s a good shot, maybe it’s a terrible shot, but unless we are approaching endgame it’s a waste.

It’s also such an obvious play that the shots are NAI so we lose the ability to read those people who shot him because of it. Or rather can’t use that as a factor.
Click to expand...

Sawneeks said:
whatever. agree to disagree.
.
Click to expand...
 
Natiko

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Gorlak said:
~ the mysterious adventures of a man who wandered Cthulhu island ~

first act - a loud intro (20min)



second act - taking some time (60min)


third act - the big reversal (20min)


fourth act - timezones (90min)



finale - caught in the act (6min)



-------------
yeah pretty sure blarg is/has control over the lone stranger
Click to expand...
Well, that would be fitting.

Zippedpinhead said:
I still don't know how luxcommander knew something that only me and the jailer knew...
Click to expand...
It's pretty clear he has a power that allows him to know what actions occurred on a target each night.

LuxCommander said:
Bit hard to watch when your eyes don't work. Tracking is accurate though.
Click to expand...
Based on what you said tracking is very much not accurate unless you're withholding something or lying.

Zippedpinhead said:
I know the jailer and I had a long conversation on why I was in jail and what to do with today. and the jailer also said who he jailed (or attempted to jail) the previous night. It wasn't you, and I never saw your Listen claim.
Click to expand...
That's an interesting role. Don't reveal too much though.
 
EzekelRAGE

EzekelRAGE

*truffleshuffle*
Fandorin said:
Now you’re being purposely dense, c’mon.
Click to expand...

Brazil said:
The size of my theory says nothing about your intent or lack thereof. I analyzed the sequence of events. I never claimed that you had a masterplan - it's actually the exact other way around. If I'm right, you fucked up from the get-go.
Click to expand...

Is there some fact to back up anything other than reading too much into 7 words?

As far as brazil's reasoning for going for the strong kill. What else was he suppose to say? An argument can be made for either one of you about goin for the strong kill.
 
Sawneeks

Sawneeks

little green dog
re: Alexem

Would honestly like to see his responses to all of this before passing judgement. I leave soon for work so I'm keeping my vote on Blarg in case I'm not able to check back in though.
 
rac

rac

whatever
i think its interesting we have two people claiming a save happened

blade saying they saved stuart and lux claiming to see a jailor saving zipped
 
heymonkey

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
Brazil said:
The size of my theory says nothing about your intent or lack thereof. I analyzed the sequence of events. I never claimed that you had a masterplan - it's actually the exact other way around. If I'm right, you fucked up from the get-go.
Click to expand...
You’re not right but this game is packed with silly tunnels so what do I know.
 
heymonkey

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
Okay, Sneeks, rac: define interesting here and what you think we should take from it.

Otherwise it’s just “some stuff happened”
 
Sawneeks

Sawneeks

little green dog
heymonkey said:
Okay, Sneeks, rac: define interesting here and what you think we should take from it.

Otherwise it’s just “some stuff happened”
Click to expand...
We already had a Doctor flip (Nin) so I find it interesting, i.e. slightly odd and suspicious, that we now have two more claims of Protectors out there.
 
heymonkey

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
Like the theory that Blade delay killed Stu? THAT is interesting.

“Stuff happened” isn’t. C’mon.
 
heymonkey

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
Sawneeks said:
We already had a Doctor flip (Nin) so I find it interesting, i.e. slightly odd and suspicious, that we now have two more claims of Protectors out there.
Click to expand...

Well, nin was odd night so as per Berserk an even night is possible and jailer is totally different. But it is a lot. Too much for here? Dunno.
 
K

Kawl

Owner of the Gun Show
Sawneeks said:
We already had a Doctor flip (Nin) so I find it interesting, i.e. slightly odd and suspicious, that we now have two more claims of Protectors out there.
Click to expand...
To be 100% accurate we had an odd night doctor flip.

What was last night again?
 
rac

rac

whatever
well for one do these claims do anything except try to gain town credit?
why did blade claim to save stuart?
why is it important for lux to tell the thread that zipped was jailed?
 
Sorian

Sorian

Neutral Ascetic 1-Shot BP SK Alignment Cop
Staff member
==== DAY 3 VOTES ====
Day Start

blargonaut (10 votes)
rac - #4632
bladesymphony - #4644
sawneeks - #4976
swamped - #5035
zubz - #5054
extreme tactician - #5061
stanleypalmtree - #5087
kawl - #5421
lone stranger - #5456
geno - #5464

alexem (5 votes)
heymonkey - #5253
gorlak - #5254
kalor - #5255
ezekelrage - #5258
natiko - #5280

lone_prodigy (1 votes)
melonrabbit - #3885 #4072
melonrabbit - #4956

include (1 votes)
brazil - #4018 #5094
sawneeks - #4059 #4976
luxcommander - #4070 #4571
melonrabbit - #4072 #4956
natiko - #4116 #4930
nomad sparkster - #4273
swamped - #4347 #5035
lone stranger - #4368 #4779
kawl - #4399 #4735

natiko (1 votes)
blargonaut - #4200

ezekelrage (1 votes)
blargonaut - #4172 #4200
brazil - #5230

faircure (1 votes)
dcpat - #4804

nzjubjub (1 votes)
kawl - #4735 #5421
heymonkey - #4906 #5253
lone stranger - #4928 #5338
natiko - #4930 #5280
luxcommander - #5189

extreme tactician (1 votes)
fandorin - #4924

muffin (0 votes)
gorlak - #5072 #5254

nomad sparkster (0 votes)
lone stranger - #4779 #4928

hom3land (0 votes)
heymonkey - #4565 #4906
luxcommander - #4571 #5189

rac (0 votes)
lone stranger - #5338 #5456

coolestspot (0 votes)
geno - #4652 #5464

Post Counts:
heymonkey: 175 ezekelrage: 156 gorlak: 140 muffin: 89 blargonaut: 83 stuart444: 82 melonrabbit: 80 brazil: 70 sorian: 67 sawneeks: 55 nomad sparkster: 49 rac: 48 extreme tactician: 46 natiko: 44 coolestspot: 44 alexem: 43 fandorin: 39 stanleypalmtree: 35 kawl: 32 geno: 31 luxcommander: 25 kalor: 24 poltergust: 19 swamped: 16 dcpat: 16 zippedpinhead: 14 necktochicken: 14 faircure: 13 include: 11 nzjubjub: 10 ynnek7: 9 lone stranger: 6 bladesymphony: 6 oreomunsta: 6 zubz: 4 hom3land: 3 xbro: 2

Click here to go to the Vote Tool!

Majority is 17
 
Sawneeks

Sawneeks

little green dog
heymonkey said:
Like the theory that Blade delay killed Stu? THAT is interesting.

“Stuff happened” isn’t. C’mon.
Click to expand...

heymonkey said:
Well, nin was odd night so as per Berserk an even night is possible and jailer is totally different. But it is a lot. Too much for here? Dunno.
Click to expand...

Basically put those two together.

I believe Lux/Zipped over Blade HOWEVER I'm not suspicious enough of Blade to suggest killing him in the case I'm wrong and he is actually some sort of Doctor. Hence why I keep saying to watch him if he lives.
 
EzekelRAGE

EzekelRAGE

*truffleshuffle*
rac said:
i guess lux at least offers the thread info on why zipped didn't get a result
Click to expand...
I dont think so. I believe Lux claimed b4 zipped had a chance to say anything.

Apparently Zipped talked with teh jailer.

So lux didnt even had to claim anything and let it play it.
 
Brazil

Brazil

I'm going to move my vote to a train that actually has a chance of happening.

VOTE: Alexem

The Lone dude seems like a neutral's affair, and I appreciate the connection Gorlak did between them and Blarg. I won't oppose that lynch at all. However, Alexem is completely absent, and his flip will help clear my thoughts regarding the last event.

I'll be back in a few.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom