Game Thread Marvel Heroes Mafia - Half of You Will Enjoy This

EzekelRAGE

EzekelRAGE

*truffleshuffle*
Natiko said:
As you can see above, Kyan points out some bits of WIFOM regarding me. He then mentions that he can think of one explanation, I explain my thought process during the bit he questioned and lo and behold and agrees that it makes sense. From that point forward he doesn't appear to scum read me again. But yeah, I definitely felt so threatened that I just had to take him out.
Click to expand...
So just like I stated here:
EzekelRAGE said:
Which part do you mean? Cuz the exchange im looking at between you and kyan was him calling you out on your wifom posting/busy work. You rebuttal it, but he isnt 100% on you in any way.
Click to expand...

Natiko said:
Except only one of them voted me and his case never had examples, even when I pushed him to provide context.
Click to expand...
all 3 were suspicious or voted for you. How does you saying only one voted for you change what I said?

Natiko said:
If you want to scum read Melon and/or me then go for it.
Click to expand...
I tried to scum read melon. You been goin back and forth with me all day with nothing to back up melon being town but "scum wouldnt try that" or "really for extra town points?" You've defended Melon more than she has defended herself. You have backed up nothing you said about melon being town. If I knew all i had to do to stop you from defending melon was connect dots for you being scum, I wouldve done it long ago.
 
Natiko

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
EzekelRAGE said:
So just like I stated here:



all 3 were suspicious or voted for you. How does you saying only one voted for you change what I said?


I tried to scum read melon. You been goin back and forth with me all day with nothing to back up melon being town but "scum wouldnt try that" or "really for extra town points?" You've defended Melon more than she has defended herself. You have backed up nothing you said about melon being town. If I knew all i had to do to stop you from defending melon was connect dots for you being scum, I wouldve done it long ago.
Click to expand...
Then place your vote and get me lynched. If you can't see how inconsistent your argument is then nothing I can say is going to change that. All I can say is your theories rely on a scum team that is brave enough to do a double scum thunderdome, but so scared about people wondering who caused it as to claim to try and stop discussion. A scum team that is ballsy enough to loudly argue with a nearly confirmed townie about scum plans, but so scared of being suspected of scum that they kill anyone that even looks at them sideways. A scum team that is afraid to bus Rynam with a fairly weak PR, afraid to bus Melon with a spent PR, but eagerly helps start a wagon on Grizzly. You're looking at dots, but not connecting anything. Events don't happen in a vacuum.
 
Terraforce

Terraforce

This Zeke v. Nat situation feels like town on town so I want to ignore it, but I know I'm going to have to do a reread anyway to see what the hell is actually going on.

Anyway, REALLY want to hop on Extreme Tactician for reasons I said before, but it'll only do so much if I go it alone. So I'll join the train on Mr. Runner-up.

VOTE: Ynnek

Anyone else want to put the heat on E.T., just hit ya boy up.
 
heymonkey

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
Terra, while, I appreciate you following up and hitting Trigger after I missed, why didn't you hit Tactician during the event, then?
 
melonrabbit

melonrabbit

The only good kind of melon
Blargonaut said:
looks like melon won something
Click to expand...

tumblr_m7zs3ycRoZ1rsy50k.gif
 
Terraforce

Terraforce

heymonkey said:
Terra, while, I appreciate you following up and hitting Trigger after I missed, why didn't you hit Tactician during the event, then?
Click to expand...
He actually wasn't even on my mind at the time, honestly. I was more focused on the inactive players, and I saw someone else bring up Trigger so I went for that one since he was already on my list to begin with.

Tactician comes across as one of those players who posts just to post, so he'd definitely be in the running if I get a second chance.
 
Brazil

Brazil

heymonkey said:
Brazil, I'm dying for your input on some of these happenings.
Click to expand...
I’m trying so hard but catching up is despair-inducing.

One out of every three posts is like “I have no idea of what’s happening, so *Vote on a player that I already forgot was in the game*”
 
Blargonaut

Blargonaut

SCUM UP!
Brazil said:
I’m trying so hard but catching up is despair-inducing.

One out of every three posts is like “I have no idea of what’s happening, so *Vote on a player that I already forgot was in the game*”
Click to expand...
Excuse me, this is a power-based game, we don't need to catch up
 
Terraforce

Terraforce

Blargonaut said:
Why Ynnek now
Click to expand...
For me at least, when I reread his posts, they can be summarized as: basic observations, fluff, and defending himself. His most vocal moments and a majority of his posts are just him defending himself, and he doesn’t make a compelling argument in his favor. Not much of note when it comes to his reads or analyzing people, and his sole vote the entire game was his weird bandwagon vote which he admittedly had no good reason to be on. The sole person he made a marginal effort to deem "scummy" was someone who he has completely ignored since. He very much comes across as trying to maintain a presence without amounting to much, which is scum sign 101. The way he voted Grizzly just pushes the nail deeper.
 
Blargonaut

Blargonaut

SCUM UP!
Terraforce said:
For me at least, when I reread his posts, they can be summarized as: basic observations, fluff, and defending himself. His most vocal moments and a majority of his posts are just him defending himself, and he doesn’t make a compelling argument in his favor. Not much of note when it comes to his reads or analyzing people, and his sole vote the entire game was his weird bandwagon vote which he admittedly had no good reason to be on. The sole person he made a marginal effort to deem "scummy" was someone who he has completely ignored since. He very much comes across as trying to maintain a presence without amounting to much, which is scum sign 101. The way he voted Grizzly just pushes the nail deeper.
Click to expand...
well, by those standards, personally I think Nomadic is worse

Nomadic Sparks why do you think I think this
 
Terraforce

Terraforce

Blargonaut said:
well, by those standards, personally I think Nomadic is worse

Nomadic Sparks why do you think I think this
Click to expand...
Oh for sure. But I'm going to have to take the wait and see approach on that one. I've confronted him at least three times now and his responses have been nothing or nothing. He hasn't contributed to a single point as far as I recall, and a majority of his posts have been shitposting, but apparently he's always like this as town, so I'm still mulling over how to deal with someone like him.
 
LuxCommander

LuxCommander

Bro.
Interesting... I'm finally starting to piece together the day. Will need to keep my ear closer to the ground as we near the ITAs... Just in general if I'm honest with myself.

Zippedpinhead said:
I'm role cop, I investigated verelios, I got a return that says Target is a role cop.

So either someone swapped verelios and I (which would make spec chat laugh), verelios has some sort of ability causing my target to reflect back at myself (again laughter), or both of us have this role and I just blew up two powerful roles on day 2.
Click to expand...

@Zippedpinhead ed calls out @Verelios as ROLE COP. Claims to be one himself. I can BUY that. But not all COPS are on the straight and narrow in this DAMN city. It's easy drag one down to that level. With the player count being so HIGH I can easily see this as a real possibility. Makes one start to think...

Seems there's beef between @EzekielRAGE and and @melonrabbit. Not sure what to make of it. Nor can I make heads or tails of the ynnek7 train. @Sawneeks and @heymonkey, I could use your help here. Explain to me what you're seeing here.
 
Blargonaut

Blargonaut

SCUM UP!
Terraforce said:
Oh for sure. But I'm going to have to take the wait and see approach on that one. I've confronted him at least three times now and his responses have been nothing or nothing. He hasn't contributed to a single point as far as I recall, and a majority of his posts have been shitposting, but apparently he's always like this as town, so I'm still mulling over how to deal with someone like him.
Click to expand...
I'll ITA him if you ITA him

That's 50/50 odds
 
heymonkey

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
heymonkey said:
This, I guess, is at the heart of why I'm asking. Because I guess this says Rynam's flip factors in - but it also sounds like the suspicion here started with Grizzly's flip, so I'm not getting why you felt better about Vere at start of day and then suddenly shifted back.
Click to expand...

Zippedpinhead said:
It comes down to if day one was a three legged race between three scum, who would they agree was the best to have die? I can only guess that scum must have thought grizzly was the best one of the three.

Seeing Rynam flip gave me the impetuous to try this out. Because I always say that a 1:1 trade always benefits town.
Click to expand...
Since you're back, Zipped:
What it comes down to shouldn't factor in unless something else changed your mind, since at start of day, after you got your result, you said you felt better about Vere. Then Rynam flipped and you wanted to "try this out."

I'm all on board with the philosophy of the 1v1 trade. What I'm not on board with is the gap here that I can't seem to wrap my head around.
 
Brazil

Brazil

Zippedpinhead said:
Yes, and I investigated verelios and got my exact same role back
Click to expand...
Alright.

I have a hard time picturing you wanting to go 1 for 1 with a townie!Verelios as scum.

But at the same time, claiming to get a confusing result for your check is a great set up to a “Can you blame me for acting that way?” type of defense if Verelios flips town.

Hmmm
 
heymonkey

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
Well, isn't this interesting formatting...
LuxCommander said:
Interesting... I'm finally starting to piece together the day. Will need to keep my ear closer to the ground as we near the ITAs... Just in general if I'm honest with myself.

@Zippedpinhead ed calls out @Verelios as ROLE COP. Claims to be one himself. I can BUY that. But not all COPS are on the straight and narrow in this DAMN city. It's easy drag one down to that level. With the player count being so HIGH I can easily see this as a real possibility. Makes one start to think...

Seems there's beef between @EzekielRAGE and and @melonrabbit. Not sure what to make of it. Nor can I make heads or tails of the ynnek7 train. @Sawneeks and @heymonkey, I could use your help here. Explain to me what you're seeing here.
Click to expand...
Sneeks feels convinced by the vote on Grizzly, which does read as a potential bus. I think that's a good starting point, but Ynnek's behavior after being called out there is super shady - all busywork and mechanics talk when not defending himself.

Vere's flip will shed some light on Ynnek if we see it today, because he did involved himself in that a little and take a shot at Vere, but that's also low hanging fruit at this point, so won't be totally conclusive.
 
Blargonaut

Blargonaut

SCUM UP!
Terraforce said:
If by Lyncher you're implying an "Executioner"-like role, great minds think alike because that definitely came to mind for me as well. But that doesn't explain how Zipped knew Vere's role.
Click to expand...
what kind of professional doesn't have a detailed description of his mark

Maybe it was included in his own Role PM
 
heymonkey

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
Brazil said:
Alright.

I have a hard time picturing you wanting to go 1 for 1 with a townie!Verelios as scum.

But at the same time, claiming to get a confusing result for your check is a great set up to a “Can you blame me for acting that way?” type of defense if Verelios flips town.

Hmmm
Click to expand...
The biggest problem here is that it's easy for them to both be town or one to be a neutral. There's nothing preventing it, and Zipped was weird about making the claim.

But if we want to WIFOM it, a scumZipped can push this and then come back to the "wow, I guess that was in the game after all, how odd" or whatever. I wonder if anyone who's been here longer can weigh in - traditionally in this community, role cops have more often been scum regardless, yeah? In a game like this that's role heavy that isn't necessarily going to be the case but it could be neither is town also. They just aren't on a team together.
 
heymonkey

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
It's also worth noting that Zipped isn't voting for Vere and vice versa. I know votes seem to take lower precedence in this game but that's just fucking weird all around.

==== DAY 2 VOTES ====
Day Start

verelios (5 votes)
stuart444 - #2622
geno - #3019
kawl - #3026
nomad sparkster - #3044
melonrabbit - #3045

ynnek7 (2 votes)
sawneeks - #1734 #1739
sawneeks - #1739
heymonkey - #1882 #2445
heymonkey - #3095

melonrabbit (2 votes)
ezekelrage - #2286
swamped - #2465

kawl (1 votes)
muffin - #1767 #2727
stuart444 - #2024 #2622
blargonaut - #2453

zippedpinhead (1 votes)
nzjubjub - #2307

ynnek (1 votes)
terraforce - #3107

kyanrute (1 votes)
apollo - #2047

rynam (0 votes)
geno - #2245 #3019

alexem (0 votes)
heymonkey - #2445 #2719

Post Counts:
stuart444: 172 verelios: 121 heymonkey: 113 melonrabbit: 105 geno: 81 blargonaut: 75 natiko: 61 sawneeks: 58 sorian: 55 kawl: 52 muffin: 51 ezekelrage: 51 terraforce: 48 nomad sparkster: 40 alexem: 36 zippedpinhead: 33 ynnek7: 29 extreme tactician: 25 dcpat: 20 faircure: 19 brazil: 19 poltergust: 18 kyanrute: 16 stanleypalmtree: 15 apollo: 15 xbro: 15 splinter: 14 swamped: 14 mazre: 14 rynam: 11 bladesymphony: 10 nin1000: 8 necktochicken: 7 gorlak: 7 coolestspot: 6 luxcommander: 6 oreomunsta: 4 nzjubjub: 4 ferg: 4 lone_prodigy: 3 hom3land: 3 briefs_cat: 2 zubz: 2 hecht: 1 include: 1 fireblend: 1

Click here to go to the Vote Tool!
 
Terraforce

Terraforce

Blargonaut said:
what kind of professional doesn't have a detailed description of his mark

Maybe it was included in his own Role PM
Click to expand...
Name or flavor I've seen that paired with a lyncher/exe, but knowing the exact role of their target sounds a bit much. But I definitely feel like some piece of information is missing which is why I entertained the idea to begin with.
 
Terraforce

Terraforce

heymonkey said:
It's also worth noting that Zipped isn't voting for Vere and vice versa. I know votes seem to take lower precedence in this game but that's just fucking weird all around.

==== DAY 2 VOTES ====
Day Start

verelios (5 votes)
stuart444 - #2622
geno - #3019
kawl - #3026
nomad sparkster - #3044
melonrabbit - #3045

ynnek7 (2 votes)
sawneeks - #1734 #1739
sawneeks - #1739
heymonkey - #1882 #2445
heymonkey - #3095

melonrabbit (2 votes)
ezekelrage - #2286
swamped - #2465

kawl (1 votes)
muffin - #1767 #2727
stuart444 - #2024 #2622
blargonaut - #2453

zippedpinhead (1 votes)
nzjubjub - #2307

ynnek (1 votes)
terraforce - #3107

kyanrute (1 votes)
apollo - #2047

rynam (0 votes)
geno - #2245 #3019

alexem (0 votes)
heymonkey - #2445 #2719

Post Counts:
stuart444: 172 verelios: 121 heymonkey: 113 melonrabbit: 105 geno: 81 blargonaut: 75 natiko: 61 sawneeks: 58 sorian: 55 kawl: 52 muffin: 51 ezekelrage: 51 terraforce: 48 nomad sparkster: 40 alexem: 36 zippedpinhead: 33 ynnek7: 29 extreme tactician: 25 dcpat: 20 faircure: 19 brazil: 19 poltergust: 18 kyanrute: 16 stanleypalmtree: 15 apollo: 15 xbro: 15 splinter: 14 swamped: 14 mazre: 14 rynam: 11 bladesymphony: 10 nin1000: 8 necktochicken: 7 gorlak: 7 coolestspot: 6 luxcommander: 6 oreomunsta: 4 nzjubjub: 4 ferg: 4 lone_prodigy: 3 hom3land: 3 briefs_cat: 2 zubz: 2 hecht: 1 include: 1 fireblend: 1

Click here to go to the Vote Tool!
Click to expand...
I called Vere out for it, but Zipped completely went unnoticed from me. Now that's especially fookin weird.
 
NZJubJub

NZJubJub

Zippedpinhead said:
Matrix dodging? I have been barely playing... that's so far below dodging its not even funny.
Click to expand...
So if you weren't dodging me then surely you wouldn't mind acknowledging this in some way?

The standard play here would be to lynch Verelios right? Even so, that isn't going to stop me from taking a shot at zipped in the last ITA phase if I feel like he's still just blowing me off.
 
Terraforce

Terraforce

Blargonaut said:
or another Role Cop, of course

Leaving them alon? Town benefits either way
Click to expand...
Yup, that's how I see it. This is a scenario that will unravel itself sooner rather than later. A scum team would get little benefit from keeping a role cop alive. The potential knowledge of one of their roles being outted by far outweighs whiffing to set up a potential mislynch. Some form of a framer is the only way out of a situation like this for them (other than outright killing them of course).
 
Terraforce

Terraforce

Blargonaut said:
Missing info? Like what
Click to expand...
Just blind speculation, but I could see there being a third party being part of the cause, or I feel that Zipped isn't giving us the entire truth, mainly because of how weird his initial claim was, and he a bit felt dodgy and dismissive about it. One of the "missing truths" I considered earlier was the Lyncher/Exe situation you brought up.
 
heymonkey

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
NZJubJub said:
So if you weren't dodging me then surely you wouldn't mind acknowledging this in some way?

The standard play here would be to lynch Verelios right? Even so, that isn't going to stop me from taking a shot at zipped in the last ITA phase if I feel like he's still just blowing me off.
Click to expand...
Standard in a red check, yeah. But this isn't really a red check situation so it's a little more nuanced.
 
Terraforce

Terraforce

heymonkey said:
The tone of all your posts since your reappearance here is just weird, man. Am I the only one feeling this?
Click to expand...
I guess kinda weird in that it feels as if he's just going through the motions and following along without indicating he has reason to believe in the lynch itself. And it does feel out of nowhere considering how little he has posted before.
 
Blargonaut

Blargonaut

SCUM UP!
Terraforce said:
Just blind speculation, but I could see there being a third party being part of the cause, or I feel that Zipped isn't giving us the entire truth, mainly because of how weird his initial claim was, and he a bit felt dodgy and dismissive about it. One of the "missing truths" I considered earlier was the Lyncher/Exe situation you brought up.
Click to expand...
I think you're scum that's glad to have someone suggest a way out for both of them?

If you had such a bright idea, why didn't you say it before I did?

Am I just that much better and faster than you?

Why am I so good at this?
 
Sawneeks

Sawneeks

little green dog
LuxCommander said:
Interesting... I'm finally starting to piece together the day. Will need to keep my ear closer to the ground as we near the ITAs... Just in general if I'm honest with myself.



@Zippedpinhead ed calls out @Verelios as ROLE COP. Claims to be one himself. I can BUY that. But not all COPS are on the straight and narrow in this DAMN city. It's easy drag one down to that level. With the player count being so HIGH I can easily see this as a real possibility. Makes one start to think...

Seems there's beef between @EzekielRAGE and and @melonrabbit. Not sure what to make of it. Nor can I make heads or tails of the ynnek7 train. @Sawneeks and @heymonkey, I could use your help here. Explain to me what you're seeing here.
Click to expand...

Since monkey more or less covered the ynnek thing I will say the Zeke vs Melon fight has been interesting. I haven't commented on it yet but part of me doesn't even put it past a scum!melon to thunderdome a buddy for shits n giggles, especially splinter and especially in this game. However, this feeling is not strong enough to say 'lets kill her' but I'm entertaining the idea a bit.
 
Terraforce

Terraforce

Blargonaut said:
I think you're scum that's glad to have someone suggest a way out for both of them?

If you had such a bright idea, why didn't you say it before I did?

Am I just that much better and faster than you?

Why am I so good at this?
Click to expand...
Ah man Blarg, I thought we were buds :(

I didn't mention it for the exact reason I said not too long ago. I feel the answer could be one of several alternatives, so in the end my thought is the same as I've said long before you were even here. That's a lynch-battle I'd prefer not to mess with right now. We can entertain a myriad of blind theories, but we don't get any further in deciding which of the two to settle on since it's all purely conjecture at the end of the day.

But what are you implying I'd get out of getting a "way out" of the Vere vs Zipped situation? To me, the actually easy "out" would be to jump on one of the two and call it a day since one of them is likely telling the truth.
 
Terraforce

Terraforce

Sawneeks said:
Since monkey more or less covered the ynnek thing I will say the Zeke vs Melon fight has been interesting. I haven't commented on it yet but part of me doesn't even put it past a scum!melon to thunderdome a buddy for shits n giggles, especially splinter and especially in this game. However, this feeling is not strong enough to say 'lets kill her' but I'm entertaining the idea a bit.
Click to expand...
You really think she would risk gladiating a Jack though? No matter how jokey someone can be, that seems like far too much of a stretch for me. Too risky, especially when in most cases situations like that don't end in an east no lynch.
 
EzekelRAGE

EzekelRAGE

*truffleshuffle*
Natiko said:
Then place your vote and get me lynched. If you can't see how inconsistent your argument is then nothing I can say is going to change that. All I can say is your theories rely on a scum team that is brave enough to do a double scum thunderdome, but so scared about people wondering who caused it as to claim to try and stop discussion. A scum team that is ballsy enough to loudly argue with a nearly confirmed townie about scum plans, but so scared of being suspected of scum that they kill anyone that even looks at them sideways. A scum team that is afraid to bus Rynam with a fairly weak PR, afraid to bus Melon with a spent PR, but eagerly helps start a wagon on Grizzly. You're looking at dots, but not connecting anything. Events don't happen in a vacuum.
Click to expand...
Im not confident enuff that you are scum yet. I don't even know how this turned into me vs you when my target has been melon. You are really just over complicating the whole scenario by adding all this stuff with Grizz/Ryan etc that happened after the TD. Let's table that discussion between me and you since you seem to be goin nowhere with it and we are goin in circles.

So lets discuss something else about melon. You seemed sure that Melon and Splint would shot each other using ITAs. Then why didnt Melon take the opportunity to do it as I pointed out earlier, if she was so set on seeing Splinters flip?
 
Extreme Tactician

Extreme Tactician

Well, even if you don't want mine, here's my thoughts on it:

I don't scumread Nat. He's being sly on what he thinks will happen. But that's still suspicious. Why even be so sure if there's no reason too? I think he has some other ulterior motive.
 
EzekelRAGE

EzekelRAGE

*truffleshuffle*
@melonrabbit ignored the following post
EzekelRAGE said:
@melonrabbit
why didnt you shoot Splint first given the chance? Especially since it seems like the consensus was he was gonna shoot you day 2.
Click to expand...

Can you explain why you didnt try to shoot splinter at all?

Splinter's last msg in regard to you is:
Splinter said:
Shoot: melon, as fate foretold
Vote: Kawl, even though he totally Wouldn't Do This As Scum™
Protect: the mysterious tree stump

I don't think I trust anyone in danger of ITA.
Click to expand...

So as far as everyone knows, Splinter is shooting you wn ITA starts.
======
After splinter is killed, you post various posts regretting how you didnt do it and also this:
melonrabbit said:
Kinda mad.

I knew it. I knew it and he talked me out of it.
Click to expand...

How did he talk you out of it when one of his last posts is about shooting you?
 
Sorian

Sorian

Neutral Ascetic 1-Shot BP SK Alignment Cop
Staff member
==== DAY 2 VOTES ====
Day Start

verelios (5 votes)
stuart444 - #2622
geno - #3019
kawl - #3026
nomad sparkster - #3044
melonrabbit - #3045

ynnek7 (4 votes)
sawneeks - #1734 #1739
sawneeks - #1739
heymonkey - #1882 #2445
heymonkey - #3095
terraforce - #3162
luxcommander - #3163

melonrabbit (2 votes)
ezekelrage - #2286
swamped - #2465

zippedpinhead (1 votes)
nzjubjub - #2307

gorlak (1 votes)
blargonaut - #3161

kyanrute (1 votes)
apollo - #2047

kawl (0 votes)
muffin - #1767 #2727
stuart444 - #2024 #2622
blargonaut - #2453 #3161

rynam (0 votes)
geno - #2245 #3019

ynnek (0 votes)
terraforce - #3107 #3162

alexem (0 votes)
heymonkey - #2445 #2719

Post Counts:
stuart444: 172 verelios: 121 heymonkey: 117 melonrabbit: 105 blargonaut: 83 geno: 81 natiko: 61 sawneeks: 60 terraforce: 56 sorian: 55 ezekelrage: 53 kawl: 52 muffin: 51 nomad sparkster: 40 alexem: 36 zippedpinhead: 33 ynnek7: 29 extreme tactician: 26 dcpat: 20 faircure: 19 brazil: 19 poltergust: 18 kyanrute: 16 stanleypalmtree: 15 apollo: 15 xbro: 15 splinter: 14 swamped: 14 mazre: 14 rynam: 11 bladesymphony: 10 nin1000: 8 necktochicken: 7 gorlak: 7 luxcommander: 7 coolestspot: 6 nzjubjub: 5 oreomunsta: 4 ferg: 4 lone_prodigy: 3 hom3land: 3 briefs_cat: 2 zubz: 2 hecht: 1 include: 1 fireblend: 1

Click here to go to the Vote Tool!
 
EzekelRAGE

EzekelRAGE

*truffleshuffle*
Extreme Tactician said:
Well, even if you don't want mine, here's my thoughts on it:

I don't scumread Nat. He's being sly on what he thinks will happen. But that's still suspicious. Why even be so sure if there's no reason too? I think he has some other ulterior motive.
Click to expand...
Sorry about that, just skimmed this last page and player list for random semi active names. I wanted thoughts moreso on melon not shooting splinter
 
Blargonaut

Blargonaut

SCUM UP!
Terraforce said:
Ah man Blarg, I thought we were buds :(

I didn't mention it for the exact reason I said not too long ago. I feel the answer could be one of several alternatives, so in the end my thought is the same as I've said long before you were even here. That's a lynch-battle I'd prefer not to mess with right now. We can entertain a myriad of blind theories, but we don't get any further in deciding which of the two to settle on since it's all purely conjecture at the end of the day.

But what are you implying I'd get out of getting a "way out" of the Vere vs Zipped situation? To me, the actually easy "out" would be to jump on one of the two and call it a day since one of them is likely telling the truth.
Click to expand...
good job
 
heymonkey

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
I'm about to go to bed. I'll weigh in on Natiko tomorrow. I need time to develop that read anyway.

But before I go - @Sawneeks, how do you feel about the reasons these two have joined us on this vote?
 
Xbro

Xbro

Bags his own tea
Looks like I missed the event.

LuxCommander said:
I trust you Monkey, you better not let me down.

VOTE: Ynnek7
Click to expand...

You're previous post before thisone was you asking if everyone was flipping over to zipped, and this one is you putting your vote in another's hands. This reads like you're just trying to find the safest wagon to hop on to.
 
EzekelRAGE

EzekelRAGE

*truffleshuffle*
I’d like to remind ppl of the following:

CoolestSpot said:
So it seems that items are in play, from what I can gather, that when gathered can control the game in a way that's like a mafia verison of the gantlet itself. May be some wild guessing but that's the implication I'm getting from this.

So...um...I'm sharing this so our team has a fighting chance but do with this info as you will. Hopefully we can warrock this thing up.
Click to expand...

Melon now has an item and she may be scum.
 
Zubz

Zubz

So... ITA means I just fire & have a chance of autokilling, right?

Happy to see Blarg is here & is as Blargy as ever! But if Blarg isn’t the mysterious entity... then who or what is it?

I read through all the posts I missed from work... on mobile... so I’m going to have clearer thoughts soon.
 
Sawneeks

Sawneeks

little green dog
Terraforce said:
You really think she would risk gladiating a Jack though? No matter how jokey someone can be, that seems like far too much of a stretch for me. Too risky, especially when in most cases situations like that don't end in an east no lynch.
Click to expand...

I don't think it's super likely she would but we also don't know the entire make up of the Scum Team yet so we don't even know if Splinter had the strongest role or not. It would also create the gambit of whoever lives that thunderdome would be assumed Town and given this game was advertised as high death then Townie Points are something Scum want to stack up FAST.

Think you're putting a lot more stake on what I'm saying than how I actually feel about it. I think it's a very slim possibility that Zeke could be right but I don't think it's something we can say has a 0% chance of happening.

EzekelRAGE said:
@Terraforce
@Sawneeks
@Mazre
@faircure
@Zubz
@Kawl
@Swamped
@Verelios
@StanleyPalmtree
@Stuart444
@Gorlak
@heymonkey
@NZJubJub

Can I get your thoughts on this post?
b77c73218423c64736fc7bc963a4ab61.png
Click to expand...

It's honestly really hard for me to tell what's serious or not when it comes to Splinter and Melon saying they'd shoot one another. Melon ended up using her shot against me, a gut read, instead of Splinter so I do find it weird how she complained to you about it. I would have to go back and look at the specific timing of the event though. Was she around and posting before you shot Splinter or did she only come in later?

heymonkey said:
I'm about to go to bed. I'll weigh in on Natiko tomorrow. I need time to develop that read anyway.

But before I go - @Sawneeks, how do you feel about the reasons these two have joined us on this vote?
Click to expand...

Terra - Haven't seen anything that crazy out of Terra and his reasoning behind the vote seems solid, I have no issues with it.
Lux - There's nothing else to say here except it's a real blatant bandwagon vote. Having not really played much with Lux I immediately dislike this vote a lot and would prefer a further explanation of it outside of blind sheeping (and why sheep Monkey and I out of everyone here?) @LuxCommander
Blarg - As confusing as usual. Don't think he's given a reason why he voted for Ynnek yet. I do want to say that his 'surface level' questions he keeps asking reminds me of Scum!Blarg moreso than anything. Lots of talk and question but little outside of that. Would shoot.
 
Verelios

Verelios

Were-elios
Going to sleep, but I'll round off before doing so
heymonkey said:
It's also worth noting that Zipped isn't voting for Vere and vice versa. I know votes seem to take lower precedence in this game but that's just fucking weird all around.

==== DAY 2 VOTES ====
Day Start

verelios (5 votes)
stuart444 - #2622
geno - #3019
kawl - #3026
nomad sparkster - #3044
melonrabbit - #3045

ynnek7 (2 votes)
sawneeks - #1734 #1739
sawneeks - #1739
heymonkey - #1882 #2445
heymonkey - #3095

melonrabbit (2 votes)
ezekelrage - #2286
swamped - #2465

kawl (1 votes)
muffin - #1767 #2727
stuart444 - #2024 #2622
blargonaut - #2453

zippedpinhead (1 votes)
nzjubjub - #2307

ynnek (1 votes)
terraforce - #3107

kyanrute (1 votes)
apollo - #2047

rynam (0 votes)
geno - #2245 #3019

alexem (0 votes)
heymonkey - #2445 #2719

Post Counts:
stuart444: 172 verelios: 121 heymonkey: 113 melonrabbit: 105 geno: 81 blargonaut: 75 natiko: 61 sawneeks: 58 sorian: 55 kawl: 52 muffin: 51 ezekelrage: 51 terraforce: 48 nomad sparkster: 40 alexem: 36 zippedpinhead: 33 ynnek7: 29 extreme tactician: 25 dcpat: 20 faircure: 19 brazil: 19 poltergust: 18 kyanrute: 16 stanleypalmtree: 15 apollo: 15 xbro: 15 splinter: 14 swamped: 14 mazre: 14 rynam: 11 bladesymphony: 10 nin1000: 8 necktochicken: 7 gorlak: 7 coolestspot: 6 luxcommander: 6 oreomunsta: 4 nzjubjub: 4 ferg: 4 lone_prodigy: 3 hom3land: 3 briefs_cat: 2 zubz: 2 hecht: 1 include: 1 fireblend: 1

Click here to go to the Vote Tool!
Click to expand...
It's (votes) not going to go anywhere until ITA 3 and my feelings are already known on that.
EzekelRAGE said:
@Terraforce
@Sawneeks
@Mazre
@faircure
@Zubz
@Kawl
@Swamped
@Verelios
@StanleyPalmtree
@Stuart444
@Gorlak
@heymonkey
@NZJubJub

Can I get your thoughts on this post?
b77c73218423c64736fc7bc963a4ab61.png
Click to expand...
I mentioned this earlier in the thread in relation to the TD and afterewards and Stuart I believe said it didn't matter in the grand scheme of things and Melon did the equivalent of a shrug. It's still weird but what are you going to do.
Extreme Tactician said:
Well, even if you don't want mine, here's my thoughts on it:

I don't scumread Nat. He's being sly on what he thinks will happen. But that's still suspicious. Why even be so sure if there's no reason too? I think he has some other ulterior motive.
Click to expand...
What?
 
EzekelRAGE

EzekelRAGE

*truffleshuffle*
Zubz said:
I trust Melon’s gladiator claim, so I think she has a win condition involving personal kills. Or at least Thunderdomes. I see no reason to doubt her.
Click to expand...
If either of those were true, one actively hurts town and she would need to be lynched and the other would be neutral at best and would need to be lynched. Which was reasoning for Grizz lynch for some.

Sawneeks said:
I don't think it's super likely she would but we also don't know the entire make up of the Scum Team yet so we don't even know if Splinter had the strongest role or not. It would also create the gambit of whoever lives that thunderdome would be assumed Town and given this game was advertised as high death then Townie Points are something Scum want to stack up FAST.

It's honestly really hard for me to tell what's serious or not when it comes to Splinter and Melon saying they'd shoot one another. Melon ended up using her shot against me, a gut read, instead of Splinter so I do find it weird how she complained to you about it. I would have to go back and look at the specific timing of the event though. Was she around and posting before you shot Splinter or did she only come in later?
Click to expand...
Yea, i understand that. the way the TD turned out just rubbed me the wrong way. Timing/Candidates/No Lynch push. Then I saw how they interacted with each other afterwards.

She not only posted before me, she was the first post of the event.
804b21d2171adc59ab57b67de0b5a490.png


Also what are your thoughts on her saying she was forbidden to claim/breadcrumb her role at all during Day one phase?
- She conviently said that when I called her out for not counterclaiming kawl and I would look for her breadcrumbs from Day.
------Side note: She has posts from day 1 where she outright denies doing the TD. But she says that was ok cuz its not claiming.
 
Natiko

Natiko

Town's Friendly Neighborhood Serial Killer
Splinter said:
...right

Anyway, to business

@melonrabbit
giphy.gif

I challenge you to a duel. I propose pistols at [strike]dawn[/strike] ITA phase two.
Click to expand...

melonrabbit said:
I'm cool with a dance off, not like we can be any more constructive with our time.

aN81pRt.jpg


Man, I need really, really to catch up.

I wasn't really here for the push for Grizzly which at the time (from skimming the thread during work) seemed outtta nowhere that completely derailed the Verelios push and Ryanm pushes.

Four deaths is somewhere surprising number to see, but given the player size should've been expected. I don't know recall a single Crimson post, so that is a surprising pick. Hecht stood the most of the picks and he was fairly antagonistic.

Praying Mysterious Entity is Blarg. This was but both a blessing and a curse for his trolling nature.
Click to expand...

melonrabbit said:
Also, @Splinter started it.

And if he shoots, I shoot.
Click to expand...

I feel like we already talked about this, but you keep bringing it up. Splinter instigated the duel, he explicitly said ITA phase 2, and Melon said she would shoot if Splinter shot.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom