Game Thread Marvel Heroes Mafia - Half of You Will Enjoy This

Include

Include

I have no idea what's going but I am back, well rested and ready to play again!! :D No need for a recap though, I want to read with my own eyes and have my own judgement (yes, it means I will not trust anyone with their recaps, sorry not sorry)

Please give me time to read though... So many pages OMG you guys. I am gonna spend hours reading back, write my notes, update my read lists, aren't I? Why do I play this game again? >_<!!
 
Stantastic

Stantastic

Our Badminton Stanpion
So i dont think im following the Vere lynch idea all that well?
like Zipped role copped Vere and got the exact same role back that he has, that makes enough sense, but im not following how this makes him into much of a lynch target.
im guessing i just glossed past it in the perpetual catch-up that is this game, could anyone point me to where it was more completely laid out, or maybe sum it up or something?

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

So earlier somebody was referencing me in regards to somebody else proposing a Nomad lynch, i assume referring to how much i pushed for his lynch in my last game only for him to turn out town.

i would like to state right here that i am still totally down for lynching nomad right now.
I dont think he is scum, but damn do i want him to not be alive anymore.
Oh and thats not to say i think he is town either, i just dont care much, hes just a source of annoyance either way.

EzekelRAGE said:
@Terraforce
@Sawneeks
@Mazre
@faircure
@Zubz
@Kawl
@Swamped
@Verelios
@StanleyPalmtree
@Stuart444
@Gorlak
@heymonkey
@NZJubJub

Can I get your thoughts on this post?
b77c73218423c64736fc7bc963a4ab61.png
Click to expand...

first of all, quote posts, dont screen shot them.

secondly, if you do have to screen shot them dont cut off who posted it or when it happened, like damn man that just makes me mistrust you on instinct.

thirdly, and actually importantly, I think melon is town, and from both a pure game logic angle and a player behavior angle Melon being town and causing the TD herself makes by FAR the most sense to me.

i can appreciate the effort you are putting into this but you dont have nearly the ammunition you seem to think you have, and your obsessive insistence on this tunnel only makes me doubt your view of the whole deal more and more.
 
Include

Include

Sawneeks said:
Also @Include You had a question for me last Phase that I never got to. Well, more like a statement than anything but do you still want a reply to that or no?
Click to expand...

Why did you wait until today Saw? Why ignore me until now? But yes please, I haven't read D2 yet but from D1 you made your entry to my scum lean list.




-------------------------------------*-------------------------------------------------*--------------------------------------
Off-topic answer to everyone
Natiko said:
Hope all is well Include! We'll only mildly consider shooting you in your absence.
Click to expand...

melonrabbit said:
tumblr_lwvym0M3xK1qdv84j.gif


Always here for you, dear Cordy.
Click to expand...

Ynnek7 said:
Take care, Include! Game will still be here later.
Click to expand...

Verelios said:
Take care of your business, no worries
Click to expand...

Nomad Sparkster said:
Take care @Include

Treat yourself once the stress rides over
Click to expand...

Sawneeks said:
Feel better soon, Include <3
Click to expand...

Thank you all lovely people, I feel so much better today <3
 
Stuart444

Stuart444

Just woke up, Slept from like 6pm until 9am felt sooo good. :D now let's see here

Also Happy you're doing better than last night @Include (I was asleep so couldn't give any well wishes :( )

*reads thread*

All those misses.

Also first time I've seen a Millar in a game now. Seems pretty useless role but hey.

Vote is staying where it is unless Vere kicks it during the next ITAs
 
Stuart444

Stuart444

StanleyPalmtree said:
secondly, if you do have to screen shot them dont cut off who posted it or when it happened, like damn man that just makes me mistrust you on instinct.

thirdly, and actually importantly, I think melon is town, and from both a pure game logic angle and a player behavior angle Melon being town and causing the TD herself makes by FAR the most sense to me.
Click to expand...

Besides the fact that I agree that I think Melon is Town, I didn't reply to that post because of what you said. It's hard to look at/read for me and my eyes already suck as it is. Having to read blurry screenshots (which they look like to my eyes) instead of posts is just annoying.
 
Geno

Geno

While I think Ynnek has a good chance of being scum, the whole Vere/Zipped thing MUST end tonight. There's no way we leave both alive at day end.
 
Include

Include

Stuart444 said:
Just woke up, Slept from like 6pm until 9am felt sooo good. :D now let's see here
Also Happy you're doing better than last night @Include (I was asleep so couldn't give any well wishes :( )
Click to expand...

Morning and thank you! Also you just spoiled me that we may have a miller. >_<!!

Also can someone elaborate on this:

"During which time anyone may take a shot as long as they have not already tried shooting once today." It's from the ITA rules, I am not sure I understand, does it mean that people can only play one ITA phase?
 
Stuart444

Stuart444

Include said:
"During which time anyone may take a shot as long as they have not already tried shooting once today." It's from the ITA rules, I am not sure I understand, does it mean that people can only play one ITA phase?
Click to expand...

Oh and, it means you have only one shot per day and may use it during any ITA phase that day. Sorian earlier did @s to people who still had one shot left for the final ITA phase this day
 
Stuart444

Stuart444

Anyway about Vere, last night I also felt a rather interesting change in his attitude. He started putting out images in responses rather than trying to scum hunt. I mean before the claims with Zipped/Vere, I was the only one 'tunneling' onto Vere. And once the claim happened, his reaction to it is very odd, instead of admitting it, he just attacked Zipped.

He had been given opportunities with some of the earlier discussion to say there could be two RCs both on Towns side but instead he doubled down on 'not believing Zipped'

Who benefits from the Town losing an RC? Scum.

Now I'm sure some people may say "Zipped could be scum and checked Vere, saw he was an RC and wants him out of the way"

Yes but Zipped claimed first. Scum RC wouldn't do that because it'd be the biggest dumb move for Scum. For Town, it's be a trade, get Scum out of the way and then get killed by Scum. (and he has no BP left) Town has more than Scum so doing a trade, town for scum is something Zipped has admitted is a trade he'd make.

In short: Vere is likely scum to me, based on his change in attitude and reaction to Zipped. Scum are likely happy now that Zipped has lost his BP so Zipped is a goner tonight. I could be wrong but I think I'm likely quite right here and think Vere should be lynched. If Scum, I'm right, if not, I guess I'm on the chopping block if I survive tonight for not backing down on this.
 
Stuart444

Stuart444

Oh and one more thing

Vere thinks Zipped is a JOATs rather than RC & BP but I don't think there is enough evidence of that. Look at Grizzly

He was a RB & Godfather. An Active and Passive Ability similar to Zipped.

Zipped lost his passive now though but considering Grizzly had two specific roles, one passive and one active, I'm likely to believe Zipped is who he claims and I think it's odd to suggest he's a JOATs at this stage.
 
Blargonaut

Blargonaut

SCUM UP!
Stuart444 said:
Oh and one more thing

Vere thinks Zipped is a JOATs rather than RC & BP but I don't think there is enough evidence of that. Look at Grizzly

He was a RB & Godfather. An Active and Passive Ability similar to Zipped.

Zipped lost his passive now though but considering Grizzly had two specific roles, one passive and one active, I'm likely to believe Zipped is who he claims and I think it's odd to suggest he's a JOATs at this stage.
Click to expand...
I now officially Town-read you because of this post. Congratulations
 
Poltergust

Poltergust

I do agree with the running topic of Zipped vs. Vere ending today. I think I’ll also go for Vere at this point because I don’t find there to be a good reason to lynch Zipped first. Additionally, if Vere truly is scum then it is best to lynch him before he has a chance to use his ability. Either way, it’s unlikely for either of them to make it past Day 3 at this rate.

Vote: Verelios
 
Blargonaut

Blargonaut

SCUM UP!
well I mean technically it's not "shooting" since I imagine we're all using our respective superpowers underneath the highlights, so
 
Blargonaut

Blargonaut

SCUM UP!
Poltergust said:
You know, I would not be surprised if someone here was Hawkeye or something whose power is to never miss an ITA. Basically a daytime vigilante.

Anyways, I’m going to bed. Looking forward to the last ITA results!
Click to expand...
I would certainly be quite disappointed in Sorian if this wasn't true
 
Stuart444

Stuart444

Mazre said:
D&D time for me, not sure where the lie/truth is between Zipped/Vere but I'd tend to imagine that if we have 2 role cops and one is BP and the other isn't, the one with BP is more likely to be scum.
Click to expand...

I don't understand this here.

BP helps Scum more than Town?

Look at the deaths from N1. 4 Town at once. If do go with the assumption of many killing roles for Scum side, then the logical assumption if an RC with BP is very very likely to be Town.

Zipped also came out and claimed first saying he had RC & BP. It's very unlikely for Scum to do something like that.
 
Stuart444

Stuart444

Poltergust said:
You know, I would not be surprised if someone here was Hawkeye or something whose power is to never miss an ITA. Basically a daytime vigilante.

Anyways, I’m going to bed. Looking forward to the last ITA results!
Click to expand...

Well someone is Hawkeye but flavour is flavour.

That said, the power wouldn't surprise me so if we see someone who always hits, we'd know it was true I guess.
 
Stuart444

Stuart444

Terraforce said:
This Zeke v. Nat situation feels like town on town so I want to ignore it, but I know I'm going to have to do a reread anyway to see what the hell is actually going on.

Anyway, REALLY want to hop on Extreme Tactician for reasons I said before, but it'll only do so much if I go it alone. So I'll join the train on Mr. Runner-up.

VOTE: Ynnek

Anyone else want to put the heat on E.T., just hit ya boy up.
Click to expand...

LuxCommander said:
I trust you Monkey, you better not let me down.

VOTE: Ynnek7
Click to expand...

Also while I can't say I trust Ynnek, these votes read weird to me.

Terra: "I want to go for Extreme Tactician but instead of trying to make a case or start a train, I'll jump onto the Runner up because why not"

Lux: "I trust you monkey!"

I'm wary on Extreme myself so I'm not to suspicious over Terra but the vote still reads weird to me.

Lux however jumps up on my maybe Scum list. That vote was too weird and bandwagony to me. Maybe nothing but I'm keeping this in mind.
 
Alexem

Alexem

Yeah, I'm town
I can see the motivations for an Ynnek lynch that people have and wouldn't be opposed to it, but I still think we need to get somewhere with Vere and Zipped first - I can see it going on and choking up more time in D3 if we don't get some answers today. I'd like to wait and see what the rest of the day - particularly the last ITA window - brings before deciding on votes, though, just in case we get any more information.
 
Extreme Tactician

Extreme Tactician

Stuart444 said:
Yes but Zipped claimed first. Scum RC wouldn't do that because it'd be the biggest dumb move for Scum. For Town, it's be a trade, get Scum out of the way and then get killed by Scum. (and he has no BP left) Town has more than Scum so doing a trade, town for scum is something Zipped has admitted is a trade he'd make.

In short: Vere is likely scum to me, based on his change in attitude and reaction
Click to expand...
Makes sense to me. I think I'll vote now:

VOTE: verelios
 
Geno

Geno

Yup, we lynch Verelios first because if Zipped with 3 scum dead had the guts to out of nowhere claim that he is either a really bad player which I don't think or a really bold player.
 
Zippedpinhead

Zippedpinhead

Zip it!
Nzjubjub,

I’m dead already and have left literally everything I have about my role and game already on the table. I don’t know what else you want from me
 
heymonkey

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
Alexem said:
I can see the motivations for an Ynnek lynch that people have and wouldn't be opposed to it, but I still think we need to get somewhere with Vere and Zipped first - I can see it going on and choking up more time in D3 if we don't get some answers today. I'd like to wait and see what the rest of the day - particularly the last ITA window - brings before deciding on votes, though, just in case we get any more information.
Click to expand...
What is your aversion to voting more than once?
 
heymonkey

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
Stuart444 said:
Oh and one more thing

Vere thinks Zipped is a JOATs rather than RC & BP but I don't think there is enough evidence of that. Look at Grizzly

He was a RB & Godfather. An Active and Passive Ability similar to Zipped.

Zipped lost his passive now though but considering Grizzly had two specific roles, one passive and one active, I'm likely to believe Zipped is who he claims and I think it's odd to suggest he's a JOATs at this stage.
Click to expand...
How isn’t this an argument for RC Zioped to be scum though? You said it yourself that it’s more like Grizzly. Vere’s choice of term may be wrong but the comparison stands.

(I don’t know if that’s the case here or if they are both just role cops or what’s up. I’m guessing one is not town but dunno if that means neutral)
 
EzekelRAGE

EzekelRAGE

*truffleshuffle*
Natiko said:
I feel like we already talked about this, but you keep bringing it up. Splinter instigated the duel, he explicitly said ITA phase 2, and Melon said she would shoot if Splinter shot.
Click to expand...
The latter part is my problem. Why give someone the chance to shoot and killl you? You cant return a shot if you are dead.

Extreme Tactician said:
I think I'm misreading your post. Did you eant opnlinions on Nat or Melon?
Click to expand...
Melon not shooting splinter when giving the opportunity.
 
Stuart444

Stuart444

heymonkey said:
How isn’t this an argument for RC Zioped to be scum though? You said it yourself that it’s more like Grizzly. Vere’s choice of term may be wrong but the comparison stands.

(I don’t know if that’s the case here or if they are both just role cops or what’s up. I’m guessing one is not town but dunno if that means neutral)
Click to expand...

Because Zipped came out first, Scum had already lost 3 Scum players.

Don't focus on just one thing, focus on them all. Put together, Zipped can't be scum. He would have to be the most bold player ever or the worst player ever to be Scum and do that and I don't believe he's bad nor do I believe he'd be bold in this situation.

The only possibility is that Zipped is guaranteed Town. Neutral at worst but what he did could be considered the most Towniest move ever because we'd be getting rid of a potential Scum Role Cop allowing Townies to keep their roles secret from Scum.
 
heymonkey

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
I really don’t know how I feel about the Zioped/Vere situation, but I do know I don’t like the people piling on Ynnek, so:

vote: LuxCommander

Either you are super lost or that was the scummiest of bandwagon votes.

I do feel mafia is likely to NK a real role cop so it does feel like we are doing the work for them, especially without a red check. They’ve botched acted shady and while Zipped feels a little more pure about his shadiness, there’s a chance neither is mafia.
 
heymonkey

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
Stuart444 said:
Don't focus on just one thing, focus on them all. Put together, Zipped can't be scum. He would have to be the most bold player ever or the worst player ever to be Scum and do that and I don't believe he's bad nor do I believe he'd be bold in this situation.

The only possibility is that Zipped is guaranteed Town. Neutral at worst but what he did could be considered the most Towniest move ever because we'd be getting rid of a potential Scum Role Cop allowing Townies to keep their roles secret from Scum.
Click to expand...

"Don't look at just one thing, but only one thing is possible."
¯\_(ツ)_/¯

you do you, Stu
 
Swamped

Swamped

Dazzling Mafia Queen
Is there a reason not to vote Vere given Zipped's claim?

VOTE: Verelios

Zeke initially made some interesting points about Melon, but her responses regarding her being unable to claim make sense. I felt he had a very unique perspective which made me want to see where the melon thing was going, but it seems more likely she is town.

I think she got the thunderdome PM, and couldn't resist using it on Splinter given that they are the best of friends (I'm a little jealous I'll be honest). Not sure if she honestly truly thought he was scum, which is why she didn't shoot at him during ITA. Or, he certainly wasn't her top scum read.
 
heymonkey

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
I do hope this mess gets resolved in the ITA. I’d love to see a new situation arise to shake up some of the people hiding in the woodwork.
 
EzekelRAGE

EzekelRAGE

*truffleshuffle*
StanleyPalmtree said:
first of all, quote posts, dont screen shot them.

secondly, if you do have to screen shot them dont cut off who posted it or when it happened, like damn man that just makes me mistrust you on instinct.

thirdly, and actually importantly, I think melon is town, and from both a pure game logic angle and a player behavior angle Melon being town and causing the TD herself makes by FAR the most sense to me.
Click to expand...

Stuart444 said:
Besides the fact that I agree that I think Melon is Town, I didn't reply to that post because of what you said. It's hard to look at/read for me and my eyes already suck as it is. Having to read blurry screenshots (which they look like to my eyes) instead of posts is just annoying.
Click to expand...
Please don't try to spin this as he is screen shoting = scum trying to finagle the posts. I will just link to the posts from now on, its here #2876. I didn't even ask you to comment on Scum TD, because it would just be us going in circles. I just wanted your opinion on if you find it odd that Melon didnt take the shot on splinter? (Stuart you explained why you didnt try).

And the game logic argument. This isnt a normal game. Also it's a Sorian game. Last Sorian game I played had a Neutral Serial Killer Ascetic Cop (I may be missing some words lol). So I wouldnt shutdown anything based solely off game logic.
 
Swamped

Swamped

Dazzling Mafia Queen
Ohhhh so given the miller and godfather roles, we definitely have a regular cop in play too (or maybe items that give that ability). Possible to have two rolecops on top of that? Maybe, seems unlikely. One town role cop and one town regular cop? Maybe more likely?
 
Swamped

Swamped

Dazzling Mafia Queen
EzekelRAGE said:
And the game logic argument. This isnt a normal game. Also it's a Sorian game. Last Sorian game I played had a Neutral Serial Killer Ascetic Cop (I may be missing some words lol). So I wouldnt shutdown anything based solely off game logic.
Click to expand...

fb82196abe7224465e33865e6bbff345.gif
 
Include

Include

OMG, you guys are back to posting. I am at page 41 only. I don't even know how many hours it has been already. I should just skim through but then I will miss subtle scums mistakes and we can't afford it.

Ok dead line the next ITA, gotta catch up by then, don't wanna be behind.
 
Stuart444

Stuart444

EzekelRAGE said:
Please don't try to spin this as he is screen shoting = scum trying to finagle the posts.
Click to expand...

I'm not, I just didn't read because it hurts my eyes to read blurry screenshots which those were to me.

EzekelRAGE said:
I just wanted your opinion on if you find it odd that Melon didnt take the shot on splinter? (Stuart you explained why you didnt try).
Click to expand...

It seems like Melon was having a bit of fun because of the image right after the ITA started. Nothing else. Then almost right after that, someone else took the shot.

I guess Melon was just having some fun with it and hoping to survive (cause 15% chance is low) Splinters shot.
 
EzekelRAGE

EzekelRAGE

*truffleshuffle*
Stuart444 said:
I'm not, I just didn't read because it hurts my eyes to read blurry screenshots which those were to me.
Click to expand...
Yea, was directed at SP.

Stuart444 said:
This is likely actually. Godfather = town alignment on check. So theoretically, there needs to be someone who can check alignments.
Click to expand...

Will review Vere/Zipp situation

Stuart444 said:
Oh and also

wut? O.o
Click to expand...
lol.
Stuart444 said:
It seems like Melon was having a bit of fun because of the image right after the ITA started. Nothing else. Then almost right after that, someone else took the shot.
I guess Melon was just having some fun with it and hoping to survive (cause 15% chance is low) Splinters shot.
Click to expand...
Extreme Tactician said:
I think she's being playful, that's all.
Click to expand...
Alright you two think its playful. Ok. all I wanted were opinions on the matter.
 
Alexem

Alexem

Yeah, I'm town
heymonkey said:
What is your aversion to voting more than once?
Click to expand...
I don't know, really - I suppose I just prefer to be sure in myself when I make a decision. Still, I suppose there's not much risk of a turbo with this many players in the game, so no harm in sticking a vote down now.
VOTE: Verelios
 
EzekelRAGE

EzekelRAGE

*truffleshuffle*
After Melon answers me about why she didnt shoot Splinter, I will drop it. Which Im sure now something about being "playful" about giving someone a chance to kill you will be part of the response.

Nothing about her play/use of her power/ responses has been pro town. Especially actively saying she didnt do the TD.

But maybe that was just her being playful too?

*shrug*

======
I just didn't like that fact that some of the players were
1). They were both in the TD so they have to be town! - Which is/was flawed
2). Melon HAS to be town, with no proof whatsoever to back that up. Can't even point to her play or anything to support her being town other than thinking scum wouldnt put both themselves in the TD.

That's it. Think I've plead my case and I'll leave there for now.
 
Include

Include

And just like that we lost a doc and another townie... Hype went back to normal... nin seems to be cursed as doc we lynched him on HvV :c
 
hom3land

hom3land

Why has @Kawl gotten a pass from his day 1 shenanigans?

EzekelRAGE said:
After Melon answers me about why she didnt shoot Splinter, I will drop it. Which Im sure now something about being "playful" about giving someone a chance to kill you will be part of the response.

Nothing about her play/use of her power/ responses has been pro town. Especially actively saying she didnt do the TD.

But maybe that was just her being playful too?

*shrug*

======
I just didn't like that fact that some of the players were
1). They were both in the TD so they have to be town! - Which is/was flawed
2). Melon HAS to be town, with no proof whatsoever to back that up. Can't even point to her play or anything to support her being town other than thinking scum wouldnt put both themselves in the TD.

That's it. Think I've plead my case and I'll leave there for now.
Click to expand...

Zeke, why did you drop @Kawl so quickly? You tunneled so hard for Melon even though you admit that @Kawl wasn't helping town

EzekelRAGE said:
Can we just vote kawl just for causing all this confusing?

All my theories about vere and splinter are back on
LOL.

Either way, kawl gives us the most answers. Him doing this at the end of the day doesn't help town AT ALL.
Click to expand...
 
melonrabbit

melonrabbit

The only good kind of melon
I was having fun. The one thing I agree with Kawl about is the game is supposed to be fun first and foremost.

The odds of his actually taking the shot were low in my mind. And if he had, I would've shot back.
This is just how we operate. Since you took the shot while he was sleeping, we were interrupted.

So that ends our story.
 
NeckToChicken

NeckToChicken

Did some rough skimming to catch up, and I’m having trouble following the small ynnek push.

Vere vs zipped is making me... uneasy for some reason? I get that zipped making the first move, Vere admitting to being a role cop, and some level of protection in place are marks for zipped’s claim. I will think on this some more.

I’m a bit less suspicious of Alexem than I was in a previous post, despite Rynam being mafia.

Glad to see Blarg was summoned like some sort of blood magic.
 
hom3land

hom3land

NeckToChicken said:
Did some rough skimming to catch up, and I’m having trouble following the small ynnek push.

Vere vs zipped is making me... uneasy for some reason? I get that zipped making the first move, Vere admitting to being a role cop, and some level of protection in place are marks for zipped’s claim. I will think on this some more.

I’m a bit less suspicious of Alexem than I was in a previous post, despite Rynam being mafia.

Glad to see Blarg was summoned like some sort of blood magic.
Click to expand...

I was trying to make sense of it as well. I found this post.. But i think it was made before Melon claimed Gladiator so it kind of makes sense.

Ynnek7 said:
I'm not really sure about who I'd bulletproof. Probably either Melon or Splinter. I felt they both responded pretty well to the thunderdome. A part of my would give it to Blarg just because I'd love to give him more of a shot at playing in case he's picked off during the ITA.

I might shoot either Ry or CoolestSpot. Rynam for the event antics, and Coolest due to his opening post powerclaim/fish.
Click to expand...
 
EzekelRAGE

EzekelRAGE

*truffleshuffle*
hom3land said:
Why has @Kawl gotten a pass from his day 1 shenanigans?

Zeke, why did you drop @Kawl so quickly? You tunneled so hard for Melon even though you admit that @Kawl wasn't helping town
Click to expand...
Funny thing is I had brought it up earlier day 2. before the ITAs

EzekelRAGE said:
...............Still think we need a kawl flip. His play at the end of the day about claiming TD was during Grizz vote. Didn't really deter from grizz though. Idk........
Click to expand...

I was going to shoot Kawl. Because as I said earlier, the confusion he caused and his flip would give the most answers.

Then I looked at how playful Splinter and Melon were being with it each other. Looked back how both of them pushed for a no lynch in the TD. And figured they were both scum hamming it up.

Took shot at splinter based on that.
 
Ynnek7

Ynnek7

OH MY GOD, THEY LYNCHED YNNEK
Heya, all. Sorry for disappearing after the last event last night. A friend came into town unexpectedly and I pretty much only took a chance participating in that since it was a low involvement one.

We're actually going out to a festival today, so I'm not really sure I'll have much of a chance to post today.

I can completely understand if I end up voted out tonight, or killed in the ITA, but hopefully I'll still be around tomorrow.

I will say that I had something happen to me during the last night phase, but since it's pretty NAI I didn't think it was that important or useful to bring up.
 
Terraforce

Terraforce

Stuart444 said:
Also while I can't say I trust Ynnek, these votes read weird to me.

Terra: "I want to go for Extreme Tactician but instead of trying to make a case or start a train, I'll jump onto the Runner up because why not"

Lux: "I trust you monkey!"

I'm wary on Extreme myself so I'm not to suspicious over Terra but the vote still reads weird to me.

Lux however jumps up on my maybe Scum list. That vote was too weird and bandwagony to me. Maybe nothing but I'm keeping this in mind.
Click to expand...
@Stuart444 I made a case for Yn before and after that vote, so that isn't true at all. I was also pretty clear that I suspected Ynnek because he was in my list ages ago for "Vote,Kill,Protect" and he was my other choice for my ITA shot.
 
Sorian

Sorian

Neutral Ascetic 1-Shot BP SK Alignment Cop
Staff member
Did I see people talking shit about my SK design in here!?!?

Have a vote count:

==== DAY 2 VOTES ====
Day Start

verelios (9 votes)
stuart444 - #2622
geno - #3019
kawl - #3026
nomad sparkster - #3044
melonrabbit - #3045
poltergust - #3218
zippedpinhead - #3237
swamped - #3246
alexem - #3259

ynnek7 (3 votes)
sawneeks - #1734 #1739
sawneeks - #1739
heymonkey - #1882 #2445
heymonkey - #3095 #3243
terraforce - #3162
luxcommander - #3163

zippedpinhead (1 votes)
nzjubjub - #2307

melonrabbit (1 votes)
ezekelrage - #2286
swamped - #2465 #3246

kyanrute (1 votes)
apollo - #2047

luxcommander (1 votes)
heymonkey - #3243

kawl (0 votes)
muffin - #1767 #2727
stuart444 - #2024 #2622
blargonaut - #2453 #3161

rynam (0 votes)
geno - #2245 #3019

gorlak (0 votes)
blargonaut - #3161 #3187

ynnek (0 votes)
terraforce - #3107 #3162

alexem (0 votes)
heymonkey - #2445 #2719

Post Counts:
stuart444: 190 heymonkey: 123 verelios: 122 melonrabbit: 107 blargonaut: 98 geno: 85 ezekelrage: 65 sawneeks: 63 natiko: 62 terraforce: 57 sorian: 56 kawl: 52 muffin: 51 nomad sparkster: 40 alexem: 38 zippedpinhead: 35 ynnek7: 30 extreme tactician: 29 poltergust: 20 dcpat: 20 faircure: 19 brazil: 19 swamped: 17 xbro: 17 kyanrute: 16 stanleypalmtree: 16 apollo: 15 splinter: 14 mazre: 14 rynam: 11 bladesymphony: 10 necktochicken: 8 include: 8 nin1000: 8 gorlak: 7 luxcommander: 7 coolestspot: 6 zubz: 6 nzjubjub: 5 hom3land: 5 oreomunsta: 4 ferg: 4 lone_prodigy: 3 briefs_cat: 2 hecht: 1 fireblend: 1

Click here to go to the Vote Tool!
 
Stuart444

Stuart444

Terraforce said:
@Stuart444 I made a case for Yn before and after that vote, so that isn't true at all. I was also pretty clear that I suspected Ynnek because he was in my list ages ago for "Vote,Kill,Protect" and he was my other choice for my ITA shot.
Click to expand...

I did say I wasn't too suspicious of you, I just thought the vote itself was weird when you seemed more eager to go after someone else
 
heymonkey

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
Stuart444 said:
I did say I wasn't too suspicious of you, I just thought the vote itself was weird when you seemed more eager to go after someone else
Click to expand...
I mean, not that I think Terra is the towniest or anything, but if you have two suspects and one already has votes on them....

Just feels like you’re nitpicking based on how you would play rather than evaluating players. This also extends to some of outnumbering conversations.
 
Include

Include

And welcome @Brazil , guys if I feel scum vibes from him please please believe me. I always know when he is scum, I never ever made a mistake. My record in sniffing him out is spotless. I swear to god if I get ignored again when I scum read him and he is scum again, I will snap.

I am page 53 and I have 1h left before ITA, I should be able to make it hopefully.
 
EzekelRAGE

EzekelRAGE

*truffleshuffle*
Although Melon being scum situation is w/e, so lets not focus on that.
I think we should look at the no lynches for the TD.

These are the facts. Splinter was scum and actively pushed for a no lynch for w/e reason.

Scum team could be around 10 or so players? All alive at this point in the game for the vote.
There were 29 total votes for the event. We have no confirmed town voters as of yet on the no lynch.
The confirmed townies we do know of. Werent even on the no lynch. So 23 votes.

e52ec9c5726b9ecb899f52ad282359b4.png


Here is splinters post during the TD.
Splinter said:
Gotta be honest, these melon votes are a bit weird

Hecht vote on melon
Nin vote on melon
Trigger vote on melon
Kyan vote on melon

There's more than I'd expect, and none of them give a reason. (I left out Gorlak who did give a reason, though none of these people commented on it.)

The votes for me at least have reasons, mostly that melon is more active. If I was a third party and felt forced to choose (ignoring no lynch), that's probably what I'd do too.

Yet we have no less than 5 unreasoned voted for melon. I'd wager that at least some of these are scum trying to split themselves between the two options.
Click to expand...
ALL the ppl he called out on the melon vote, were confirmed town.


Does anyone else think we should start looking at the no lynch vote for the TD?
 
Terraforce

Terraforce

Stuart444 said:
I did say I wasn't too suspicious of you, I just thought the vote itself was weird when you seemed more eager to go after someone else
Click to expand...
Yeah I know, I'm just saying why that line of logic is wrong. My Ynnek vote didn't come out of a "bandwagon" when I've been vibing against him long before that.

And I'm not particularly "more eager" to vote Tactician. Mostly because I just doubt how much will come from voting him right now.
 
Stuart444

Stuart444

Terraforce said:
Yeah I know, I'm just saying why that line of logic is wrong. My Ynnek vote didn't come out of a "bandwagon" when I've been vibing against him long before that.

And I'm not particularly "more eager" to vote Tactician. Mostly because I just doubt how much will come from voting him right now.
Click to expand...

Fair enough then.
 
Terraforce

Terraforce

EzekelRAGE said:
Although Melon being scum situation is w/e, so lets not focus on that.
I think we should look at the no lynches for the TD.

These are the facts. Splinter was scum and actively pushed for a no lynch for w/e reason.

Scum team could be around 10 or so players? All alive at this point in the game for the vote.
There were 29 total votes for the event. We have no confirmed town voters as of yet on the no lynch.
The confirmed townies we do know of. Werent even on the no lynch. So 23 votes.

e52ec9c5726b9ecb899f52ad282359b4.png


Here is splinters post during the TD.

ALL the ppl he called out on the melon vote, were confirmed town.


Does anyone else think we should start looking at the no lynch vote for the TD?
Click to expand...
That's something I pointed out before, and I definitely think there's some merit to that for sure. And something I've been mulling over myself.
 
faircure

faircure

Ugh, I've been mulling this over and I have no clue if I'm just overthinking or what. So opinions on Blade's behavior would be nice cause I'm not too sure if it's malicious, just being a new player or absolutely nothing lol

Firstly, I feel like he's just significantly quieter today compared to d1 and that's a bit weird. All he's commented on so far this phase is me, Stuart, Xbro and some ITA stuff. But lemme unpack my thoughts starting with this:
BladeSymphony said:
Faircure also agreed with Stuart's scum vibes after Grizz pointed it out. Then even after the bandwagon gave Grizz the benefit of the doubt. Don't like that. Scum vibes.
Click to expand...
It kinda felt like he purposely was leaving out that I defended Stuart and did disagree/was suspicious of Grizzly at times. Just felt a bit unfair and narrative-y to me but I replied with the relevant posts and asked his thoughts on those in case he'd just missed them or something. (#1766) Which I thought was rather unlikely since it looked like he'd iso'ed all my posts.

But then he just disappeared and never really replied? That's what's weirdest to me, that he wouldn't interact with me or expand on his thoughts when I was a scumread. I didn't reply all that much later to his initial post too.
BladeSymphony said:
Shoot: faircure, his back and forth and failure to really commit in the previous posts I mentioned on Grizzly make me think he's just saving face
Click to expand...
And then here, is it just me reading this totally different? Like I'm reading this like a very fair accusation in comparison to what he said earlier but I'm not sure how/why he changed to this.

So idk, I'm willing to believe I'm just overthinking/taking newb behavior as scum behavior/omgus-ing a little but I'd really like the outside opinion of some people since I'm biased in this situation. He's not a terribly strong scum read for me right now but this was bugging me.
 
Yuta

Yuta

Gorlak's back in action ~ of course a teeny weeny exhausted from yesterday's party but alas no chinese taxi driver could sent me into madness! The good ol' bike got me home in safety.

*dream* ... sometimes I miss these adventures, surely I have to go back one day
 
heymonkey

heymonkey

Known Roblox Expert
Staff member
It’s likely there’s scum on the no lynch vote in the TD, yeah. Comparing to votes for Rynam and Grizzly might help there, with looking at timing on Grizzly.

I’m gonna be around a little to check on the ITA but I’m out for much of today until closer to EoD.
 
Brazil

Brazil

Verelios getting lynched today seems inevitable at this point. I understand where those asking for us to leave it up to the night phase are coming from, but at the same time, if one of them is actually scum, scum could let the townie live to make us lynch them tomorrow... and then we’d end up taking two more phases to solve this entire thing.

Include said:
And welcome @Brazil , guys if I feel scum vibes from him please please believe me. I always know when he is scum, I never ever made a mistake. My record in sniffing him out is spotless. I swear to god if I get ignored again when I scum read him and he is scum again, I will snap.
Click to expand...
This is all true.

Hey Include :)
 
NZJubJub

NZJubJub

Would scum trade a raw BP for a town role cop?

Zippedpinhead said:
Nzjubjub,

I’m dead already and have left literally everything I have about my role and game already on the table. I don’t know what else you want from me
Click to expand...
Anything, anything at all. I just wanted you to say something about the suspicions on you yesterday since it might've helped me decide if I want to shoot at you or not. But fair enough if you're resigned to catching a NK tonight.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top Bottom